Thor vs Thanos

Started by quanchi11233 pages
quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
My view point is that there is no proof that Odin went all out during the Thanos fight, therefore the only proof I need is the actual comic where the fight took place.
The only proof that constitutes as proof according to you has never happened in any Odin appearance. That is why you won't answer my questions and will continue this dance of circular logic over and over again.

Silent Master Senior Member

I've already told you what I would accpet as proof, it's not my fault that all you can provide is opinion and specualtion.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
I've already told you what I would accpet as proof, it's not my fault that all you can provide is opinion and specualtion.
So, you would ask for something that has never occurred and accept nothing less as proof?

Silent Master Senior Member

I ask for proof, if you can't provide that, that is your problem.

h1a8 Senior Member

In a non PIS fight Thanos would lose everytime to Odin easily. Odin can do things far above imagination. This is a no contest.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
I ask for proof, if you can't provide that, that is your problem.
So, you wound ask for something that doesn't exist and continually post asking for it? Really?

Silent Master Senior Member

I would and will ask for proof when people make a claim, if the proof doesn't exist then the person shouldn't be making the claim.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
I would and will ask for proof when people make a claim, if the proof doesn't exist then the person shouldn't be making the claim.
You asked for my opinion. I gave it.

Silent Master Senior Member

Incorrect, I asked if you were claiming that Odin was going all out.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Are you claiming that you can prove Odin was going "all out"?
quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
Incorrect, I asked if you were claiming that Odin was going all out.
I asked you what else besides a statement would you consider as proof of Odin going all out. You refused to answer.

Silent Master Senior Member

Pay attention, I don't want you to miss me answering you again.

I'll accept anything that isn't opinion and/or speculation.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
Pay attention, I don't want you to miss me answering you again.

I'll accept anything that isn't opinion and/or speculation.

What constitutes as proof based on odin's appearances?

Silent Master Senior Member

Anything from the comics that isn't opinion and/or speculation.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
Anything from the comics that isn't opinion and/or speculation.
Tell me when Odin has gone all out before.

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
Gungir channeled enough power to visibly affect Thanos. Prior to using it Thanos was fine.

Thanos was hurt, but was nowhere near death. How the fight went on after that is anyone's guess.

Odin without Gungnir = Odin with Gungnir

Did it ever occur to you that Odin was holding back in the beginning even more than he did throughout of the fight?

For example in the beginning he held back 99%, then when he pulled it out he held back 95% etc.

I don't know know how to make it any clearer than that.

Gungnir does not increase Odin's power. Odin is more than powerful enough to smack around Thanos without Gungnir while holding back as it does not increase his power.

Christ. Will you get it through you're head?

My god.

Thanos was hurt, and as evident, the more the fight dragged on, the greater the damage dealt to him and the less Odin held back. If the fight continued, Thanos would have continued to be smacked around, but to a greater degree.

Eventually Odin would have grown tired of his insolence and put him down permanently.

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member
Originally posted by quanchi112
Tell me when Odin has gone all out before.

Obviously with his fight with Thanos...

🙄

Silent Master Senior Member
Originally posted by quanchi112
Tell me when Odin has gone all out before.

Whether or not he's gone all out in another fight has nothing to do with the fact that there is no proof that he was doing so in the Thanos fight.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Odin without Gungnir = Odin with Gungnir

Did it ever occur to you that Odin was holding back in the beginning even more than he did throughout of the fight?

For example in the beginning he held back 99%, then when he pulled it out he held back 95% etc.

I don't know know how to make it any clearer than that.

Gungnir does not increase Odin's power. Odin is more than powerful enough to smack around Thanos without Gungnir while holding back as it does not increase his power.

Christ. Will you get it through you're head?

My god.

Thanos was hurt, and as evident, the more the fight dragged on, the greater the damage dealt to him and the less Odin held back. If the fight continued, Thanos would have continued to be smacked around, but to a greater degree.

Eventually Odin would have grown tired of his insolence and put him down permanently.

Regardless, in the comic Thanos didn't get sent flying until gungir was introduced. That's a fact.

What would happen after the fight had stopped is anyone's guess.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Obviously with his fight with Thanos...

🙄

I see no reason as to why he would hold back in this fight. No reason at all.
Originally posted by Silent Master
Whether or not he's gone all out in another fight has nothing to do with the fact that there is no proof that he was doing so in the Thanos fight.
This is just another circular argument you wish to have.

Silent Master Senior Member
Originally posted by quanchi112
This is just another circular argument you wish to have.

No, you're the one that keeps trying to go off on tangents.