Wizards vs Mutants

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Uber powerful in the X Men world, not the wizarding world.

No. Voldemort time travels back before the battle even starts.

No defense against Dementors then? OK.

That doesn't make any sense, Xavier being able to mass mind-rape and Phoenix's powers would be powerful in the Harry Potter world, as would the wizards powers in the Marvel universe.

Why does the wizards side get prep?

Never said the mutants did, only that Phoenix (and possibly Xavier) can destroy them faster and in mass, than they can soul-suck someone to death.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
So both sides get prep in this battle? Unless stated otherwise he can't do so, as well as Mindset said, if he didn't do it in the movies then he can't do it here anyway.

Originally posted by Robtard
That doesn't make any sense, Xavier being able to mass mind-rape and Phoenix's powers would be powerful in the Harry Potter world, as would the wizards powers in the Marvel universe.

Why does the wizards side get prep?

Never said the mutants did, only that Phoenix (and possibly Xavier) can destroy them faster and in mass, than they can soul-suck someone to death.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
So both sides get prep in this battle? Unless stated otherwise he can't do so, as well as Mindset said, if he didn't do it in the movies then he can't do it here anyway.

FYI, I know this doesn't count but Voldemort hates to time travel. They didn't say so in the movie, but he's such a parnoid bastard that his past self wouldn't trust his future self and he would AK him and **** the future up.

Originally posted by Dr Will Hatch
Noone gets prep.

FYI, I know this doesn't count but Voldemort hates to time travel. They didn't say so in the movie, but he's such a parnoid bastard that his past self wouldn't trust his future self and he would AK him and **** the future up.

I know, I'm just providing some perspective.

Doesnt even have to be Voldemort. He can send a Death eater back and have them do it. Hell, he could send back as many as he wanted.

Does the fight actually take place at Hogwarts?

Originally posted by Mindset
Does the fight actually take place at Hogwarts?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
It's not prep. The time turner is right there at Hogwarts. Just give it to Voldy and let him do as he wishes. And yes, Voldy would likely do this, he is not exactly stable, and not the most moral bound person around. Hermione used it, why couldnt Voldy?

Yes, but WHICH is the more powerful of the two? Impossible to tell.

I already addressed this, look up.

OK, I'll amuse you for a moment and assume that DP will destroy all the wizards. How is she gonna destroy the Dementors? She cannot see them, they are invulnerable to any and all physical attacks. The Dementors are gonna swoop around, INVISIBLE, and one by one render all mutants helpless. The only defense against a Dementor is Expecto Patronum. This means no amount of physical or mental attacks will affect them. If you cannot produce a Patronus, you are literally screwed.

Yeah but anyone who time travels is bfring themselves and once their out of the match their gone, no other actions can be taken.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Never said that in the movie.

Has Voldemort or a death eater time traveled in the movies?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Doesnt even have to be Voldemort. He can send a Death eater back and have them do it. Hell, he could send back as many as he wanted.

Once again self-BFR.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Yeah but anyone who time travels is bfring themselves and once their out of the match their gone, no other actions can be taken.

Has Voldemort or a death eater time traveled in the movies?

Once again self-BFR.

Originally posted by omgchos
You ignored the dementors there. Hes absolutely correct. Only a wizard can see them and only a wizard can defend against getting soul sucked.

What does anything you just said have to do with time travel not being applicable here as it would be self-bfr and since no one has done it in the movies to my knowledge?

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
What does anything you just said have to do with time travel not being applicable here as it would be self-bfr and since no one has done it in the movies to my knowledge?

He's not dismissing the Dementors, you're ignoring what he said and trying to make another point. And besides, summoning the Dementors would be pointless since by the time they got there, the fight would be over. And obviously Xavier and Jean can sense their presence, while Logan can smell them.

Actually no, why would they be able to? They can only be seen by wizards, because they are a type of magial creature that is undetectable by any muggle. And mutants are muggles. And i was actually pointing out that he ignored the other point RJ was making. And since the dementors did occupy hogwarts throughout the third movie, they wouldn't need to be summoned.

But they were evicted after that. Since this has Voldemort and Death Eaters, it's obviously from the 5th movie. And when did I say they would see them. Xavier and Jean would sense their presences, while Logan could use his hyper senses to smell them, and instinctively know something was wrong.

And who knows, maybe every single mutant is a Squib.

That last part was a failed attempt at humor. And dementors cant be smelled... wtf? U can't sense their presence just cuz you can read peoples minds. No on screen feet tells us that they can sense magical creatures. And since no speific movie was mentioned, they could still be there.

Originally posted by omgchos
Actually no, why would they be able to? They can only be seen by wizards, because they are a type of magial creature that is undetectable by any muggle. And mutants are muggles. And i was actually pointing out that he ignored the other point RJ was making. And since the dementors did occupy hogwarts throughout the third movie, they wouldn't need to be summoned.

Where is it stated that a mutant is a muggle? I didn't ignore it, I only read what he said to me from the previous point I made.

Actually, no they couldn't. Like I said, since Voldemort and the Death Eaters are actively fighting, this has to be the 3rd movie. Was Voldemort shown being able to fight in the 3rd movie, I don't think so.

And no on screen feats show that Dementors are capable of sucking the soul of a mutant.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Where is it stated that a mutant is a muggle? I didn't ignore it, I only read what he said to me from the previous point I made.

Originally posted by KingD19
Actually, no they couldn't. Like I said, since Voldemort and the Death Eaters are actively fighting, this has to be the 3rd movie. Was Voldemort shown being able to fight in the 3rd movie, I don't think so.

And no on screen feats show that Dementors are capable of sucking the soul of a mutant.