Spider-Man vs Punisher · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

Battlehammer Senior Member

Here Alf tries to state Punisher should be top tier MA because of this

Originally posted by Deadline
No im not kidding, in PWJ and the beginning of the current series he has top tier h2h feats. Just some of them:
1. Beats a beserk Tiger Shark part of the fight was underwater. Captain Americe did something similar with Namor.

here is the event

Originally posted by SuperiorTech
The entire fight if you want to see it.

debate went for several pages which I was to lazy to post, but the short of it he argues that Punisher did that through skill and that is fine example and not pis.........so you can see what were dealing with here, if he find this to be a fine example then of course he going to think Punisher choking out Spiderman is fine and likely

SamZED Senior Member

Originally posted by Deadline
*sigh* Giving me examples of somebody more durable than Spiderman, proves your point how?

Wasn't responding to your post, was responding to this one:

Originally posted by Mshinu
A choke bypasses the durability, his brain still needs oxygene and the pressure needed to stop the blood flow is very light if applied correctly.

And according to it durability means jack if one could stop the blood flow. Eitherway Punisher choking Spider-man = bs.

Originally posted by Deadline
Hes not bulletproof for starters. People like Captain America have comparable durability showings. Obvoulsy now you're going to pick all of Spidermans high showings and say this is the norm.

Um.. no. High showings would be getting a hand ripped right through his chest and getting up like nothing's happened. Im on the other hand talking about his normal showings. It's way above Cap's and many others who're over class 10. He doesnt need to be bulletproof for it to make no sense. He's taken hits and attacks that would turn Cap into pudding.

Eternal Idol Lono, "The Dog"

Split.

namorsubby Senior Member

spidey shouldn't have too much trouble with this.........that is unless a writer wants a clash between these two to last more than 3 panels......which would most defintiely be the case in most situations.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Petey got owned again.

willyqpublic Junior Member

In a fair fight, Spiderman would probably win handily. This won't be a fair fight though. If you give Punisher two days to prep, he's going to spend one day prepping, shoot spiderman in the head, and be home in time to watch Leno. In a real, actual, lethal fight, Punisher wins.

BECAUSE PUNISHER CHEATS.

When Frank Castle wants to kill you, you're going to die, and don't expect him to follow the same rules you do.

SamZED Senior Member

Originally posted by willyqpublic

...don't expect him to follow the same rules you do.

Agreed. Although I dont see him shooting Pete FTW. More like set some crazy trap, use his ss against him. Something like that.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Bloodlust is on.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Didn't War Zone pretty much show us who'd win if Punisher is allowed to prep?

Anyway, in a straight up fight, Spidey slaughters him. With one-sided prep, Frank wins.

namorsubby Senior Member

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Petey got owned again.

Lol, spidey effortlessly tooled frank while verbally scolding him and purposely taking his harmless blows. Then Frank, while on the floor bleeding, threw a grenade that spidey somehow couldn't evade even though he was forewarned by his spider sense.

srankmissingnin VP of Comic Knowledge

Originally posted by namorsubby
Lol, spidey effortlessly tooled frank while verbally scolding him and purposely taking his harmless blows. Then Frank, while on the floor bleeding, threw a grenade that spidey somehow couldn't evade even though he was forewarned by his spider sense.

Do you not know how grenades work?

...

What's the problem here?

Branlor Swift Dead

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Do you not know how grenades work?
...
...
...
What's the problem here?

Grenades are just a flash of light that travel in one direction.

It's really just a slower flashfight.

srankmissingnin VP of Comic Knowledge

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Grenades are just a flash of light that travel in one direction.
It's really just a slower flashfight.

Yup. 😎

Some people most not have paid attention in grenade class.

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member

😂

namorsubby Senior Member

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Do you not know how grenades work?
...
...
...
What's the problem here?

I just don't know why spidey can dart out of the way of bullets but couldn't get out of range (lets say where punisher was) when his ss warned him before he threw it. smartass...

Mindset Senior Member

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Do you not know how grenades work?
...
...
...
What's the problem here?

He could have webbed it.

namorsubby Senior Member

Like he did with franks guns before he could even pull the trigger.

SamZED Senior Member

Frank is very Solid Snake these days.

srankmissingnin VP of Comic Knowledge

Originally posted by namorsubby
I just don't know why spidey can dart out of the way of bullets but couldn't get out of range (lets say where punisher was) when he ss warned him before he threw it. smartass...

Because bullets aren't aoe weapons with a two plus meter kill radius? It's almost like it's more difficult to avoid an all encompassing wave of concussive energy, then a small projectile that fallows a set path...

SamZED Senior Member

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Because bullets aren't aoe weapons with a two plus meter kill radius? It's almost like it's more difficult to avoid an all encompassing wave of concussive energy, then a small projectile that fallows a set path...

There's a difference ofcourse, but the better question is why did he fail to dodge it this time. I dont particularly mind but he's dodged grenades that exploded in his face. This time he had plenty of time to react.