501st vs. Hogwarts

Since when in the MOVIE have they been able to move teh age line? I havent seen it done. I've seen all of the films. And i can understand your reasoning but it doesnt work none the less.... You realize.... a .50 cal sniper rifle something thats real and powerful in our world but the starwars is nothing can shoot from more than 500 yards away. The commando sniper rifle has insane range. The Empire did not spare weapon technology when they made weaponry for them. The tanks would have way more range also. And lastly. Prep time? The OP said they LAUNCH an attack on Hogwartz. Which would mean Preemptive strike.

Originally posted by Kaibs
Since when in the MOVIE have they been able to move teh age line? I havent seen it done. I've seen all of the films. And i can understand your reasoning but it doesnt work none the less.... You realize.... a .50 cal sniper rifle something thats real and powerful in our world but the starwars is nothing can shoot from more than 500 yards away. The commando sniper rifle has insane range. The Empire did not spare weapon technology when they made weaponry for them. The tanks would have way more range also. And lastly. Prep time? The OP said they LAUNCH an attack on Hogwartz. Which would mean Preemptive strike.

The age line can be drawn anywhere Dumbledore wishes.

I was just using 500 yards as an example. Whatever the range is, extend the portkeys and/or age line to that point.

Read a few pages back, hogwarts gets two hours prep time.

Really? anywhere. Post a scene in the movie wehre dumbledore states this. Its movie proof only sorry. And I will look right now for the prep time post.

Originally posted by Kaibs
Really? anywhere. Post a scene in the movie wehre dumbledore states this. Its movie proof only sorry. And I will look right now for the prep time post.

What you are saying is silly. What if I said "Hey, Clones blasters don't work outside the SW universe, prove they work outside the SW universe?"

That was for the Goblet of fire. And im sorry if we're using movie proof as i've seen you so specifically stated in some posts to your advantage id say you should abide by it now. As for the storm troopers blasters working outside their universe thats a whole other scenario. A blaster and an age barrier are way 2 different circumstances.

Originally posted by Kaibs
That was for the Goblet of fire. And im sorry if we're using movie proof as i've seen you so specifically stated in some posts to your advantage id say you should abide by it now. As for the storm troopers blasters working outside their universe thats a whole other scenario. A blaster and an age barrier are way 2 different circumstances.

Im saying he didnt do it in a movie. 🙂. ANd that's enough for me. It blows when the tables are turned on you with movie proof aint it.

OK, then the force doesnt work for Anakin on Earth. Plasma based weapons dont work on Earth. Looks like the clones are screwed 🙄

Okay then how'd they even get there in the first place? If they know their weapons wont work then they'll go get wapons that will. Which could mean that hogwartz swill survive a nuke? LOL. Dont dig yourself into a grave mate.

Didn't know the clones had nukes on them, or on the AT AT's.

You are saying that the age line only works in that one room, and only around the goblet of fire. So why do all other spells work anywhere the wizard wishes? Why was Harry able to use a Patronus against the dementor near Privet drive? Why are spells used in Hogwarts used in the ministry? Location means shit. Spells can be cast anywhere at any time.

You're saying hte clones are to stupid to get hteir hands on a nuke if their weapons dont work? Now you're just not even using logic. As for the magic shit. Okay so you saying dumbldore puts athe age limit at lets say 20 or younger. Okayyyyyyyyy so that means what? EVERYONE 20 or older gets put out and they still die.

Dumbledore can set the age line so that no one under a certain age can cross it. Those inside the line at the time it is cast are fine, but people trying to cross the line trying to get in who are under the set age cannot cross it.

See its useless arguing this again. You have no proof that in movies this is true. ANd I dont have proof that they will demolish hogwartz even though everyone agrees except u and maybe one other?

I have no proof? Dude, its an age line. No one under/over a certain age can cross it. This is said in the Goblet of fire movie, and there is a wiki link to further back that fact.

As for the clones blasting hogwarts, they have to get within range. If the age line blocks them from getting within range, what are they to do?

Dont bring wiki articles into this you will lose horribly. So I'll just stop arguing. I am going to say the 501st would lose and leave it there. I have argued my points and you havent countered it. We dont even know Dumbledore is albe to expand teh spell to that range in the first place. But alas i am done wiht this thread for a while until other people decide to go back into it.

Originally posted by Kaibs
Dont bring wiki articles into this you will lose horribly. So I'll just stop arguing. I am going to say the 501st would lose and leave it there. I have argued my points and you havent countered it. We dont even know Dumbledore is albe to expand teh spell to that range in the first place. But alas i am done wiht this thread for a while until other people decide to go back into it.

Or lets say we are talking about Han's blaster. A wiki article about it is a valid reference.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
OK, then the force doesnt work for Anakin on Earth. Plasma based weapons dont work on Earth. Looks like the clones are screwed 🙄

Not so fast, gimp boy.

Laser ones do though. 🙂

Its got a close working cousin on Earth, unlike the rubbish youre talking about with silly wizards and spells etc.

Bring us proof that the spells work on earth, and well bring proof that laser and particle weaopns exist.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Not so fast, gimp boy.

Laser ones do though. 🙂

Its got a close working cousin on Earth, unlike the rubbish youre talking about with silly wizards and spells etc.

Bring us proof that the spells work on earth, and well bring proof that laser and particle weaopns exist.

What if I told you in a McClane thread that his pistol fired in one room, but not in the next?

Same thing.

If it was that way in the movies, for McClane, Id have to respect it.

Well, say he uses an MP5 in one room at nakatomi plaza. Conference room A, for arguments sake. He is never shown using the Mp5 in the cafateria.

I set up a battle in the cafateria, then tell you "Hey, he is never shown using his MP5 in the cafateria in the movies, so it literally wont fire there."

What then?