Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
In case you guys forgot, I agreed that Hogwarts cannot stand up to the full might of the 501st, ships included. This is why the thread was altered, to make it not so one sided.
Then the thread should have ended with you, technology wins vs magic in the case. /the end
Like I've told you since your batman V swagger thread long ago, if you start gimping, any outcome can be reached; what's the point then.
Funny thing, even with the clone gimping and Hogwarts prep, your "fail-safe" win fails, as there isn't some dense forest around Hogwarts, son. So the clones still win.
Explain how the Clones cross the age line. Go ahead. The age line will be drawn to where all of their weapons are out of range, mind you.
You can't you the age line becuase you have no idea how long it takes to set up. For all we know it could require special chalk that takes years to produce, ergo there is too little info on it to be used in this thread. Ergo you FAAAAIIILLLLLL. 😛
Hows that?
Originally posted by Sadako of GirthAgain, ignoring the prep time. The age line will be drawn BEFORE he clones even land, their long range weapons will be out of range, they HAVE to cross the age line to get in range. Do you need a popup book or flash cards or sumthin?
Nah. The long range weapons will have fired by then and Hogwarts will have failed, regardless.
Originally posted by NephthysIt is a non verbal spell. name me one spell that requires more than a wand and an incantation. Go ahead.
You can't you the age line becuase you have no idea how long it takes to set up. For all we know it could require special chalk that takes years to produce, ergo there is too little info on it to be used in this thread. Ergo you fail. 😛
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Explain how the Clones cross the age line. Go ahead. The age line will be drawn to where all of their weapons are out of range, mind you.
Few holes in this plan too, RJ.
1) Clones have ships, at least drop ships, otherwise they're not getting there. So they could drop over that line.
2) Dumbledore has to trace the line, correct? If so, two hours isn't going to be enough, even if he makes it as small as possible by drawing it closely around the castle.
3) How does Dumbledore know the range specifications of the Clones weapons, all their weapons?
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
It is a non verbal spell. name me one spell that requires more than a wand and an incantation. Go ahead.
You dont know that. NOONE knows the incantation.
Also, all it is ais a parental control seeting.
These clones are gonna be piling in and it wont help against all clones as they are of staggered ages anyways....
Originally posted by Robtard
Few holes in this plan too, RJ.1) Clones have ships, at least drop ships, otherwise they're not getting there. So they could drop over that line.
2) Dumbledore has to trace the line, correct? If so, two hours isn't going to be enough, even if he makes it as small as possible by drawing it closely around the castle.
3) How does Dumbledore know the range specifications of the Clones weapons, all their weapons?
Let me ask you this......How exactly do the troops and AT AT's drop? Are the ships actually on the ground and they disembark, or are they dropped on repulsor lifts?
It is a non verbal spell. name me one spell that requires more than a wand and an incantation. Go ahead.
It isn't a non-verbal spell, you just decided it was because it helps your argument. How about the horcruxes spell? Also, prove it's actually a spell, it could very well be a potion, or a magic imbued item use.