Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Well, say he uses an MP5 in one room at nakatomi plaza. Conference room A, for arguments sake. He is never shown using the Mp5 in the cafateria.I set up a battle in the cafateria, then tell you "Hey, he is never shown using his MP5 in the cafateria in the movies, so it literally wont fire there."
What then?
Its slightly different.
And of course it'd be bollocks.
Itsa poor analogy really.
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Its slightly different.And of course it'd be bollocks.
Itsa poor analogy really.
It's a very rational analogy, it's the same thing. Spells are shown being cast everywhere. Patronus is shown at hogwarts and at privet drive. Expelliarmus at the graveyard where Harry fought Voldy and in the room of requirement, as well as several other locations. Avada Kedavra is shown used in the defense against the dark arts class, the graveyard, as well as the ministry. Spells are unaffected by locale. The age line is just another spell, it can be cast anywhere. It's lunacy to dispute this.
No I dont. And you gimped things so much already.Then made a big thing of quitting out of the thread when your arguments had been disproved and your gimping revealed, now you're back trying to claim superiority using really strechy arguments to try to prolong the suffering.
The clones knockdown hogwarts ageline or no.
So sit down, break out the beer and the marshmellows and enjoy toasting them on the firey rubble that is left. 😛
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
No I dont. And you gimped things so much already.Then made a big thing of quitting out of the thread when your arguments had been disproved and your gimping revealed, now you're back trying to claim superiority using really strechy arguments to try to prolong the suffering.The clones knockdown hogwarts ageline or no.
So sit down, break out the beer and the marshmellows and enjoy toasting them on the firey rubble that is left. 😛
How are they gonna cross the age line when it is extanded as far out to keep their weapons out of range? That'd be a neat trick.
There's no gimping on my part, only the thread starter can gimp. All I have done is explain the steps the wizards would take to beat the Clones. It's impossible for anyone but the thread starter to gimp.
Current thread conditions are that the wizards have two hours prep time, and that the clones are just attacking, no prep time, and that they can used their ground vehicles and troops, no ships. I am sticking to the thread conditions 100%.
Cause by the time they've done that Hogwarts is rubble.
cause in order for the clones to be there at all, it implies:
1) That theyve had intell.
2) Clones are always ready for combat.
Thats where the moviefeats only comes in.
The mgic wont work on it, Im sure, if it expands out too far, it could affect the populous, anyhow.
What, did the portal hit your ass on the way out and you had to come back?
This whole prep-time is nonsense, as almost any outcome can be reached, unless there's a truly weak or resourceful character(s) at play.
Anyhow, prep or no prep. Those spell aren't stopping the air-assault aspect of the Clones. Wait, let me guess, there's an anti-airbombardment spell somewhere up Dumbledores crinkled old sphinctor.
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Cause by the time they've done that Hogwarts is rubble.cause in order for the clones to be there at all, it implies:
1) That theyve had intell.
2) Clones are always ready for combat.Thats where the moviefeats only comes in.
The mgic wont work on it, Im sure, if it expands out too far, it could affect the populous, anyhow.
Intel? hmm, let's see what lum says about that:
Originally posted by Luminatus
What would the wizards do with prep anyway? They aren't techno geniuses or military leaders...
But fine. They get 2 hours to prepare for the 501st's arrival.And the 501st has no prep. They never did. They're just attacking.
501 has no prep, they never did. This means no intel.
Care to try again?
"Try again" mistakenly implies that there was some kind of failure the 1st time.
He says it in protest. Hence the "But fine" (Indicating that you had pressed him on it, in your need for "control"/gimpage.)
It was even stevens til you complained.
Cause rather than learn from the thread that in likelihood its a quick clone stomp, you had to alter it out of fanboyism.
Originally posted by Sadako of GirthYeah, I mind ****ed Lum into evening the odds, into NOT making this a spite thread. He saw that he wasnt clear in the conditions, went back, and rectified it. I used the Jedi mind trick on him. 🙄
Yeah you've stuck to the conditions 100% since you gimped the original ones, RJ.
Originally posted by Robtard
What, did the portal hit your ass on the way out and you had to come back?This whole prep-time is nonsense, as almost any outcome can be reached, unless there's a truly weak or resourceful character(s) at play.
Anyhow, prep or no prep. Those spell aren't stopping the air-assault aspect of the Clones. Wait, let me guess, there's an anti-airbombardment spell somewhere up Dumbledores crinkled old sphinctor.
Hey, you got a problem with the thread conditions, dont ***** to me, aint my thread. No ships for the clones, wizards get prep.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
501 has no prep, they never did. This means no intel.Care to try again?
Forum Rule: Combatants have basic knowledge of each other.
Your entire portkey premise is ridiculous. If some clone happens to bump into a tree while making their way to Hogwarts and vanishes, do you think the Clones will just ignore it as some fluke, seriously?
This portkey nonsense will work a few times, after which the Clones will be savvy to the setup.
Also, this assumes that Hogwarts is surrounded by some dense forest, when it isn't, ergo, your portkey defense was flawed from the start, care to try again?
Seems the clones have a nice open clearing to attack from, they can also potentially launch a multi-sided assault via the water and air.
Like I said from the start, many a clone will die; in the end, it's another Order 66. Dead children and all.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Yeah, I mind ****ed Lum into evening the odds, into NOT making this a spite thread. He saw that he wasnt clear in the conditions, went back, and rectified it. I used the Jedi mind trick on him. 🙄Hey, you got a problem with the thread conditions, dont ***** to me, aint my thread. No ships for the clones, wizards get prep.
No you used the RJ tears trick. Big Difference.
No ships: No battle, by the fact that ships get the clones there, HPFB.
The ships have no combatative role.
You dont even NEED to gimp them, yet you seem to still want to do so out of spite.
If you keep stripping this away, denying that basic ability away, evetually when you'd get the "win" you crave, all you would be left with its 'Dumbles' and co winning aginst like 1 clone in his underpants, and a catapult.
Big f***ing deal.
You see...?
Basically, the thread asked a question.
It got answered.
(Purpose of thread over.)
You didnt like it and cried about it.
Turned it into what you percieve as your own thread (hiding behind the threadstarters revised/RJ gimped rules) and bitching about things further until we all throw you your dummy and say "Here RJ, its alright! Dumbles wins! No need worry to worry about the big nasty dumbleywumbley killersssss...." before tucking you in for the night and reading you story about how Hogwarts can neverbe defeated and 'Harry and his chums are alllll invinciblllllle and they all lived happily ever after'. 🙄