Originally posted by Sadako of GirthThere might be an incantation, there might not be one, doesnt matter. If the age is set at 15, then no one under 15 gets in.
You dont know that. NOONE knows the incantation.Also, all it is ais a parental control seeting.
These clones are gonna be piling in and it wont help against all clones as they are of staggered ages anyways....
Originally posted by Robtard
Few holes in this plan too, RJ.1) Clones have ships, at least drop ships, otherwise they're not getting there. So they could drop over that line.
2) Dumbledore has to trace the line, correct? If so, two hours isn't going to be enough, even if he makes it as small as possible by drawing it closely around the castle.
3) How does Dumbledore know the range specifications of the Clones weapons, all their weapons?
He tried to ignore this, I see.
Shame. Its a good post. It deserved better than the deflective counter questioning it got.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Let me ask you this......How exactly do the troops and AT AT's drop? Are the ships actually on the ground and they disembark, or are they dropped on repulsor lifts?
Thanks for not answering.
It can be both, sometimes the ships landed, sometimes they got close and the Clones either jumped off or repelled (eg collisium battle in AOTC).
Originally posted by Sadako of GirthOk, so the line is set as age twenty, the clones cant cross it, their weapons are out of range, the autopilot scenario is crap because Dumbledore can spot them from a LONG way away, cast a portus spell on a rock on the ground, wingardium leviosa it at the tanks, even engorgio it to make it bigger. All the while he is invisible, under Harry's cloak.
I bet he never used that on his bedroom.Well the genetic ages of some of those clones are in their thirties. So thats that.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
There might be an incantation, there might not be one, doesnt matter. If the age is set at 15, then no one under 15 gets in.
Again, it was shown being used in GOF around a very small circumference, you're talking about surrounding a humongous area. Also part of that area would be underwater, as the rear of the castle faces the coast.
So in short, this age-line tactics smells of pure fail.
Originally posted by Robtard
Few holes in this plan too, RJ.1) Clones have ships, at least drop ships, otherwise they're not getting there. So they could drop over that line.
2) Dumbledore has to trace the line, correct? If so, two hours isn't going to be enough, even if he makes it as small as possible by drawing it closely around the castle.
3) How does Dumbledore know the range specifications of the Clones weapons, all their weapons?
Originally posted by RobtardYou mean this?
Again, it was shown being used in GOF around a very small circumference, you're talking about surrounding a humongous area. Also part of that area would be underwater, as the rear of the castle faces the coast.So in short, this age-line tactics smells of pure fail.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
You mean this?
Regarless: Robtard's statement about the epicness of the task not being able to be completed in the two hours, stands.