Originally posted by Robtard
Yes and:- Can it be drawn underwater?
- Can it(chalked) be drawn on dirt, cus that's what is around Hoqwarts
- Can it be made that big? We only see it on smaller areas in the movie.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Screw the age line, check my new scenario, far more interesting.
Originally posted by Sadako of GirthThey ALL have to be dropped from the drop ships, man. Point is that they will never make it to the ground. Either the drop ships and everything inside them will be portused, or the AT AT's/non tank landers/whatever will be portused as they exit the drop ships. With Voldy, Dumbles and the death eaters all casting portus and hovering the portkeys around, this will be easy as pie.
So you are trying to gimp the ground forces getting there in the 1st place still..?No, troops in the non-tank landers will be able to blast/defend as the groundforces are dropped off. Its called "covering fire".
And here is ANOTHER scenario..
Voldemort, under the invisility cloak, casts Fiendfyre into the open bay doors of the drop ships, destroying everything within.
Again, TOO easy.
http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Fiendfyre
Fiendfyre (also known as Cursed Fire) is a type of fire made from Dark Magic. It is very powerful, as it cannot be put out by Aguamenti (or any normal type of water), but is very difficult for the caster to control. The blaze is so potent that Fiendfyre is one of the very few substances that are capable of destroying a Horcrux.
Fiendfyre initially appears a "roaring, billowing noise" and gives its victims only a moments warning. Its flames are of abnormal size and take the shape of monsters and beasts, such as serpents, Chimaeras, and dragons, continuously mutating. It appears to have enough consciousness to actually follow its intended victims. The fire will pursue nearby lifeforms as if it were alive itself, sentient. The fire will also pursue anything it can burn for more fuel.
It is unknown if there is a counter-curse for Fiendfyre; Aguamenti merely evaporates before touching it. Inexperienced casters will be able to conjure it, but will have virtually no control over the flames once they are unleashed, though an experienced Dark Wizard (like Lord Voldemort) would be able to control it and manipulate it to great effect.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
They ALL have to be dropped from the drop ships, man. Point is that they will never make it to the ground. Either the drop ships and everything inside them will be portused, or the AT AT's/non tank landers/whatever will be portused as they exit the drop ships. With Voldy, Dumbles and the death eaters all casting portus and hovering the portkeys around, this will be easy as pie.
Those drop ships only carry around 10 clones each, so they'll be at least 50 of them, even saying they carry twenty clones and the armor isn't coming along, they'll be 25 ships.
-Clones can fire their guns from the ships open sides (eg colisium battler in AOTC)
-The HP team isn't going to be able to destroy every ship and they'll be sustaining heavy loses to their heaviest hitters early on. So the ships that do make it, easily plunder the castle filled mostly win children wizards.
So we've gone full circle yet again, the clones suffer [heavy] losses, but Hogwarts is a smoking mess filled with dead wizards before nightfall. /the end
Originally posted by NephthysBullshit. The wizards have two hours prep, which means they will see the drop ships as they enter atmosphere (wizards will be on brooms everywhere scouting). The wizards apparate to the drop ships and execute.
The thread starts when they've been deployed, not before. Anyway, this is a stupid argument. If there was a terminator vs Vader thread, you wouldn't argue that terminator pwns vaders drop ship, becuase fights start when both sides are deployed, not before.
"Again, too easy.." just sounds so stupid from a poster who has been proven wrong for 25 whole pages in multitudes of times where he was convinced that he was right.
Why do you type these words...? Why do your fingers tap the keys that cause the words to appear on screen...?
Probably cause all else you do is copy paste wiki submissions.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Bullshit. The wizards have two hours prep, which means they will see the drop ships as they enter atmosphere (wizards will be on brooms everywhere scouting). The wizards apparate to the drop ships and are executed (by the covering blasterfire).
Yup.
Basic knowledge dude. They'll be expecting it.
Not that it matters, but these are the troop transports for the clones- http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Low_Altitude_Assault_Transport/infantry
Originally posted by Robtard
Fail, here's why.Those drop ships only carry around 10 clones each, so they'll be at least 50 of them, even saying they carry twenty clones and the armor isn't coming along, they'll be 25 ships.
The drop ships are the star destroyers, thats what I meant. The will be portused before anyone or anything can disembark.
And if the smaller craft make it out of the star destroyers, big deal, So the wizards cast portus on a big ass log or a rock, engorgio it and one by one, the drop ships are portused.
Moot point, because the drop ships will be portused before the bay doors even open. It takes a bit for the doors to open and for the
-Clones can fire their guns from the ships open sidesThey will be in the ocean, thousands of miles away, what are they firing at?
-The HP team isn't going to be able to destroy every ship and they'll be sustaining heavy loses to their heaviest hitters early on. So the ships that do make it, easily plunder the castle filled mostly win children wizards.Yes, yes they will. We already established the number of star destroyers earlier on. with 13ish AT AT's, probably no more than 2 or 3 star destroyers will be there. Or 5, whatever. Thats five portused onjects, five portused start destroyers.So we've gone full circle yet again, the clones suffer [heavy] losses, but Hogwarts is a smoking mess filled with dead wizards before nightfall.
They will be firing at the half aparated intruders and your protkeys is negated already, by the clones watching out for dispering of the scopes. Hell for all you know, the clones maybe able to pick up EM emmisions from the portals, essentially being space time rips.
So "forget them and move on, for the sake of what little argument you may have" would be my advice..
The troops will be past the stardestroyer phase, (Unless you want the star destroyer weapons to be a factor, reducing further your argument to scrap..
(Im surprised you forgot that you gimped away the ships early in the thread.)
RJ,
This has become sad, now you get to pick it's only 5 ships and they're landing in Stardestroyers? LoL, no, dude, Clones don't use Stardestroyers to land/assualt on ground. Does "portus" work on inanatimate objects? I don't think so.
Let's just gimp the Clones some more and say they're all unarmed and naked, that way the HP crew wins in a stomp and only suffers one casualty, Dumbledore having a heart attack from seeing 500 hanging penises at once.
Originally posted by Sadako of GirthAnd what can they do about it? Nothing. Ths star destroyers cannot fire, they can only drop the troops and vehicles. The wizards apparate to where the star destroyers are, portus a few rocks or twigs, and hover them into the start destroyers before the bay doors even open. Clear skies with a chance of showers.
Yup.Basic knowledge dude. They'll be expecting it.