Originally posted by RobtardThe only sad thing is that the clones will be vanished before they exit the star destroyers.
This has become sad.Let's just gimp the Clones some more and say they're all unarmed and naked, that way the HP crew wins in a stomp and only suffers one casualty, Dumbledore having a heart attack from seeing 500 hanging penises at once.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
The only sad thing is that the clones will be vanished before they exit the star destroyers.
-"Portus" doesn't work on inanimate objects I don't think, let alone a Star-****ing-destroyer. <--- they're quite large, in case you didn't know
-Clones don't drop in Stardestroyers
-You failed again, so gimp the Clones some more, have at it.
Originally posted by Sadako of GirthHA HAHAHAHAHA nice try, but no. The troops will never make it out of the star destroyers, man. One portused twig will make the star destroyers go bye bye.
They will be firing at the half aparated intruders.The troops will be past the stardestroyer phase, (Unless you want the star destroyer weapons to be a factor, reducing further your argument to scrap..
(Im surprised you forgot that you gimped away the ships early in the thread.)
And again, lets say a few drop ships make it off the star desroyers, big deal. A portkey is hovered at them, and one by one, the drop ships are portused. Best case scenario for the clones, they take out a coupla wizards, maybe, if they are lucky.
Hhahahahahahaaaa! Nice try, but no....
Originally posted by Robtard
-"Portus" doesn't work on inanimate objects I don't think, let alone a Star-****ing-destroyer. <--- they're quite large, in case you didn't know-Clones don't drop in Stardestroyers
-You failed again, so gimp the Clones some more, have at it.
Originally posted by RobtardPortus works on any object. It may be cast on anything, and nothing is immune to it. Whatever the portkey touches, vanishes. Fact. How else do you explain wizards portkeying with their clothes on? Use some common sense.
-"Portus" doesn't work on inanimate objects I don't think, let alone a Star-****ing-destroyer. <--- they're quite large, in case you didn't know-Clones don't drop in Stardestroyers
-You failed again, so gimp the Clones some more, have at it.
So what if they dont drop in star destroyers? They can drop in frigging De Loerans for all I care, point is that the drop ships will never make it off the star destroyers.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Portus works on any object. It may be cast on anything, and nothing is immune to it. Whatever the portkey touches, vanishes. Fact. How else do you explain wizards portkeying with their clothes on? Use some common sense.So what if they dont drop in star destroyers? They can drop in frigging De Loerans for all I care, point is that the drop ships will never make it off the star destroyers.
Read your own link, portkeys are activated when a PERSON touches them. A PERSON.
They're going to be dropping in many smaller ships, possibly 50 of them, the wizards won't be able to destroy them all and they'll suffer heavy loses to the heavy hitters attacking the ships.
"The Portus spell must be complex indeed, quite apart from the magic involved. We can safely assume that, like the Riddikulus spell and the Patronus charm, a significant part of the spell is actually derived from what you are thinking of at the time the spell is cast. There are a significant number of things that you must think of when casting Portus. Not only must you hold in your mind the destination that you desire, you must also decide whether the Portkey is to be a there-and-return key, in which case you must also hold the return destination in mind; additionally you must set the time when the portkey is to activate, or whether it is to activate upon command or upon contact. It may be possible to make a personal Portkey as well, in which case you must know whose contact will activate it."
Originally posted by RobtardOK, so Dumbledore apparates into a star destroyer, under the invisibility cloak of course, has a stone in his hand, sets it on the ground, portus's it, hovers it into a drop ship loaded with troopers, egorgio's it, and BAM all the troopers are portused. He repeats this until all the clones are gone.
Read your own link, portkeys are activated when a PERSON touches them. [b]A PERSON.They're going to be dropping in many smaller ships, possibly 50 of them, the wizards won't be able to destroy them all and they'll suffer heavy loses to the heavy hitters attacking the ships. [/B]
Meanwhile, Voldemort apparates into another star destroyer, casts fiendfyre, then apparates away. His death eaters do the same with the remaining start destroyers.
Thought you had me, didncha? 😉
Originally posted by Jaeh.is.Awesome
I'm not totally convinced with the portkey thing because dumbledore and co. aren't really military generals thinking about stuff like that. maybe that's what RJ would do if he was in charge, but I imagine dumbledore be more interested in "guarding" the children and think of that and that only. add that everyone is probably panicking, even if he'll be one of the few people who'll remain really calm, its hard to think under pressure. Also, dumbledore would have to calm not only the students but also the teachers - a trained military force suddenly attacking them is not exactly something that they teach in hogwarts to prepare for.
Originally posted by Jaeh.is.Awesome
sure.oh, and I don't think the clones would underestimate the wizards - i mean, they're WIZARDS for pete's sake.
I understand that there is almost no limit to magic, but if you take them by surprise and sheer panic, the wizards could be doomed. and that's they have going for the clones. panic and... well, panic. and the fact that there are A LOT of kids involved that they'd be anxious to protect first.
but if they had, say, like 6 hours prep time, heck, they could set up an age line and a portkey heaven and I'd back you up on it.
I want a simple attack - something basic that would come to you in a flash and you could get ready for in 2 hours... or an hour-and-a-half (they have to think about it too)....
Originally posted by Jaeh.is.Awesome
*points to my argument*Rj, have any response to mine? I just wanna see if other than the age line and the portkey, if you have any other tactic for the wizards to use in my scenario.
you might just convince me if you point something new out. ^^
Can someone provide me with a NEW scenario now?