Batdude123 and TheKahn's Holiday Herald Tournament

Originally posted by -K-M-
I didn't match kyle with Talisman, but then again GL have shown to be weak against magic many times before. Also the scan of Kyle dealing with the spirit was taken out of context as it was Raven's doing not Kyles. *shrugs* Also going astral form is an automatic lose to the Spirit-Binder who has controlled skyfather astral forms before. Then again Talisman and Comet are obscure so people dont get their power/abilities.

So has CC, but to a much higher degree on more occasions. I figured these characters not being well known would hurt the case.

Even if it was Raven's doing, the only thing I needed to be proven is that the ring is suitable vessel for the imprisonment (based on Red Tornado feat).

Smurph, go ahead...tear'em a new one!
Go Smurphs!

I really hate magic. 🙁

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
Even if it was Raven's doing, the only thing I needed to be proven is that the ring is suitable vessel for the imprisonment (based on Red Tornado feat).

It was suitable due to Raven's doing not really the same *shrugs*.

Originally posted by TheKahn
I really hate magic. 🙁

Sorry for giving you headache, darling🙂 Now I want to read some impressive debating from others...

Also, Mungi, I know what it's like to debate for one's favourite character...that's what happened in all the tourneys before that (here I drafted the team I'm not so comfortable with).

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
Sorry for giving you headache, darling🙂

No worries. Something tells me that your and KM's magical tango is going to seem like the epitome of elegance and simplicity once I get through that monster Blair and Darthgoober spawned into existence. 😉

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
Smurph, go ahead...tear'em a new one!
Go Smurphs!

Jake's mostly behind the scenes at the moment, but he's very much around and on top of things as well. This is gonna be a fun match.

Originally posted by Original Smurph
Thanks Charlotte. 🙂

Jake's mostly behind the scenes at the moment, but he's very much around and on top of things as well. This is gonna be a fun match.

I wanted to see your "classico", Blair is outlandish as always...I can't remember the tourney without unrealistic tactics from him.

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
Also, Mungi, I know what it's like to debate for one's favourite character...that's what happened in all the tourneys before that (here I drafted the team I'm not so comfortable with).

Indeed, but in reality most AF characters arn't even quite in my top 10 favs. I do a lot of the respect threads for characters that deserve some respect and havn't gotten it. Prior to my arrival, Wolverine was given the clear majority over the entire Alpha Flight team (no joke). For this tourny I suggested Talisman due to he can pretty much cancel all magic users out. However, contrary to belief it wasn't me who suggested to use Captain Comet haha

Originally posted by -K-M-
Prior to my arrival, Wolverine was given the clear majority over the entire Alpha Flight team (no joke).

your arrival hasn't changed that belief. 😛

Originally posted by TheKahn
Here are the judging assignments for the other matches. Judges please let us know if there are any problems from your end.

Fight 2
Team Leonidas & Galen007 VS Team Omega Vision & JL King

kgkg
rotiart
Starscream
iceman24567
----------------------------------------

Fight 3
Team JaketheBank & Original Smurph VS Team darthgoober & Blair Wind

Digi
Tha C-Master
Badabing
Kahn
-----------------------------------

Fight 4
Team Philosophia and PR VS Team id369 and King Kandy

Batdude
Doctor Alvis
Mindset
Starscream

Originally posted by -K-M-
I didn't match kyle with Talisman, but then again GL have shown to be weak against magic many times before. Also the scan of Kyle dealing with the spirit was taken out of context as it was Raven's doing not Kyles. *shrugs* Also going astral form is an automatic lose to the Spirit-Binder who has controlled skyfather astral forms before. Then again Talisman and Comet are obscure so people dont get their power/abilities.

So has CC, but to a much higher degree on more occasions. I figured these characters not being well known would hurt the case.

Really its a moot point, that’s only one example. One instance. Here is another instance.
http://h.imagehost.org/0159/Green_Lantern_v3_72_pg19.jpg
http://a.imagehost.org/0481/Green_Lantern_v3_72_pg20.jpg

I would say Captain Comet is just as obscured of a character as Tangent Superman. Yes Captain Comet has a bigger displays of powers, yet Tangent S. has more impressive battle confrontation.

Originally posted by TheKahn
I really hate magic. 🙁

For Odin's sake. Allow me to draft Majin Dark Schneider.yep

Originally posted by Starscream M
your arrival hasn't changed that belief. 😛

NOOOOOOOO!

Originally posted by id369
It didn’t really matter who was matched with Talisman. Because Team CD, had given rings plus endow the knowledge on how to use they ring, through Kyles own experience. And really your taking the focus off the GL Ring‘s function, and crediting Raven. Yes Raven played a part, in Kyle’s demise. But it was the GL ring that absorbed and contained Kyle spirit.

Really its a moot point, that’s only one example. One instance. Here is another instance.
http://h.imagehost.org/0159/Green_Lantern_v3_72_pg19.jpg
http://a.imagehost.org/0481/Green_Lantern_v3_72_pg20.jpg

I would say Captain Comet is just as obscured of a character as Tangent Superman. Yes Captain Comet has a bigger displays of powers, yet Tangent S. has more impressive battle confrontation.

That's nice, but still wouldn't change much considering GL's have shown to be weak against magic. Also once again all that was thanks to Raven as stated.

Ive read that before, and that's not how Talisman and his spirits operate. So meh? Espeically when the professor was assisting in fighting the possession. Ive also seen Hal fail against magical spirits too and fail against magic in general. Also how will Kyle even know the spirit is present especially all the spirit we were using was just a wind attack? Naaaa..your giving the GL far to much credit and they are in fact in my top 10 favs.

Naaaa...T.S has been in more countless solo series then Comet has, and was even recently in a Tangent/New Earth crossover and was the practically lead character. Actually no T.S does not have more impressive battle confrontations at all.

and I quote your comment just a few days ago

Originally posted by id369
And I don't know a thing about Talisman.

Like I said obscurity seems to be the challenge here

well it's happened. I accidentally posted in a non-comic forum something that was supposed to go to KMC. And it included a link to a match. With no editing powers there, expect a lot of random comments in the Smurph match.

😮

Originally posted by Digi
well it's happened. I accidentally posted in a non-comic forum something that was supposed to go to KMC. And it included a link to a match. With no editing powers there, expect a lot of random comments in the Smurph match.

😮

Originally posted by Digi
well it's happened. I accidentally posted in a non-comic forum something that was supposed to go to KMC. And it included a link to a match. With no editing powers there, expect a lot of random comments in the Smurph match.

😮

I do enjoy it being referred to as "the Smurph match" though.

cuz I'm the besterest and stuff.

Its all you, I expect you to win this whole thing even just by yourself 👆

Awwww... 🙁

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
Shrinking in battle is not an issue, shrinking in prep to bypass room size limit in my opinion is akin to using speedforce to prolong prep time to unknown limits...same "relative alterations".

it is PRECISELY the same thing--though they did mention they were using their superspeed to turn the 5mins into a relative eternity as well . . .

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Awesome judge list. This is my first tournament ever so I'm hoping I don't get my ass kicked too badly. 😛

haermm