Count Dooku (Physical Prime) Vs. Mace windu

By the will of the force itself, it has taken Count Dooku's spirit and give it a new body to inhabit, it is his own physical body, restored to its physical prime and peak. Dooku also retains all knowledge, experience, skills that he had acquired over the course of his life and subsequent death and betrayal at the hands of sidious and anakin. Dooku is made aware of all the events hat have transpired since his death and what has occured in the galaxy, the rise and fall of the jedi, siths, and empires, the wars.

Versus

Mace Windu, who has been ressurected by the force itself, give his body in its physial prime, and also retains all memories, experiences, skills he had experienced over the course of his life up to his subsequent death.

This match is both utilizing all their intelligence, skills, force powers, physical fitness, in a duel to the death, who comes out victorious?

Mace.

Essentially it's still Vaapad>Dark Side. So Mace.

Mace....Wasn't it the case that he would've defeated Dooku in the Boz pity duel if it wasn't for the Magna Guards

Vaapad > dark side really is ones opinion. As demonstrated with Mace Windu versus Sidious, where sidious easily held his own against overwhelming numbers, and saved Mace so he could manipulate the situation to seem as though he were about to be killed right when anakin arrives to sway him.

See how easy it is to have a perception?

I see vaapad just as another form, a philosoph, not better or greater then any other.

Originally posted by Board Walker
Vaapad > dark side really is ones opinion. As demonstrated with Mace Windu versus Sidious, where sidious easily held his own against overwhelming numbers, and saved Mace so he could manipulate the situation to seem as though he were about to be killed right when anakin arrives to sway him.

See how easy it is to have a perception?

I see vaapad just as another form, a philosoph, not better or greater then any other.

Canon is material, which each interprets as their own, except for the few pieces in which the writers have stated on "lucas behalf" of what some thing is or more often of what some thing is not.

As for vappad being the anti life formula to all sith in combat, is not canon, nor is it supported concretely any writer source, its left for your interpretation. Vaapad may have been designed to utilize the grey line skating the dark side energies, but does it mean it defeats all sith or gives a massive advantage over them? No.

Originally posted by Board Walker
Vaapad > dark side really is ones opinion. As demonstrated with Mace Windu versus Sidious, where sidious easily held his own against overwhelming numbers, and saved Mace so he could manipulate the situation to seem as though he were about to be killed right when anakin arrives to sway him.

See how easy it is to have a perception?

I see vaapad just as another form, a philosoph, not better or greater then any other.

Wrong dude!!! Sidious didn't "easily" hold his own in any respect. Read the novel. Watch the movie. Sidious was being overwhelmed by Maces onslaught. No ifs, ands, or buts about it.

Originally posted by Board Walker
Canon is material, which each interprets as their own, except for the few pieces in which the writers have stated on "lucas behalf" of what some thing is or more often of what some thing is not.

As for vappad being the anti life formula to all sith in combat, is not canon, nor is it supported concretely any writer source, its left for your interpretation. Vaapad may have been designed to utilize the grey line skating the dark side energies, but does it mean it defeats all sith or gives a massive advantage over them? No.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Then you clearly have no respect for canon.

😱

Discontinuity

I use this method all the time with Star Wars. It works wonders.

I have watched the movie, which is the highest form of canon, and yes I interpret their fight as being in sidious favor. He easily dispatched the jedi accompanying Windu, and then kept windu occupied till Anakin was in position to be swayed to his influence. And it worked effectively indeed.

Originally posted by Board Walker
I have watched the movie, which is the highest form of canon, and yes I interpret their fight as being in sidious favor. He easily dispatched the jedi accompanying Windu, and then kept windu occupied till Anakin was in position to be swayed to his influence. And it worked effectively indeed.

Seriously, are you an idiot or are you just THAT unaware?

If you have the DVD, just watch it with Lucas' comments enabled. You'll hear that "Mace overpowered Palpatine".

Originally posted by Board Walker
I have watched the movie, which is the highest form of canon, and yes I interpret their fight as being in sidious favor. He easily dispatched the jedi accompanying Windu, and then kept windu occupied till Anakin was in position to be swayed to his influence. And it worked effectively indeed.

Also: What kind of interpretation do you have when you think that Sidious FAKED getting his lightsaber kicked out of his hand? Think about that? How do you fake getting something kicked out of your hand? Can't happen.

You can fake the tactical error of allowing your hand to be in a position where Mace can kick it.

'Zomg! I've left myself wide-open totally by mistake! You'd think a master swordsman would be above that!'

It's a fact that Sidious lost the duel. But its also a fact that Sidious faked losing the force battle.

Originally posted by ares834
It's a fact that Sidious lost the duel. But its also a fact that Sidious faked losing the force battle.

and remember sidious>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Dooku

Originally posted by ares834
It's a fact that Sidious lost the duel. But its also a fact that Sidious faked losing the force battle.

Yes, then lame Anakin shows up and cuts off his (Mace's) arm hence causing his barbecue.

Barbeque, rather.
Barbecue=almost the same thing, sorry about that guys.