Thor vs. Superman: How close (or far) apart are they?

Started by the ninjak16 pages

Spire how about giving your snide comments a rest.
The JLA/Avengers issue could have just as easily been written by someone else and Thor's hammer could have had more of an effect that a magical/enchanted artifact should have had against Supes. Your comments like "Thor crapping his pants" show your angry intent to such a level that you come off as a biased kid, compared to Quan who actually answers your comments calmly.

This is going to get ugly!

Originally posted by the ninjak
This is going to get ugly!

facepalm

It has been shown that Thor can fly without his hammer but lets be fair.. it has also been shown that he can't fly without his hammer.

Originally posted by Spire
facepalm

😛

Originally posted by Spire
Ok, aside from the fact that you don't read comics and are oblivious to the context behind the books, you realize that your comparison is extremely retarded?

Superman does the same thing. Like when he killed DD with a single punch.

I can prove it. Thor first fight with Hyperion, he lost but every fight after that, he crushed hyperion easily.

Thor fight against glads, he lost, every fight after that he crushed him.

Thor first fight against Wonderman, he lost, every fight after that hes crushed him.

Thor first fight against vision, he lost, every other fight after that he crushed him.

Thor first fight against mangog, he got annihilated. The fights after that, he took wins almost every time.

Thor first fight against absorbing man, he lost, after that he crushed him every time.

Firelord, he lost, second encounter, he crushed him.

Beta Ray Bill, he lost, every fight after that, bill appears to nothing compared to him.

I can go all day.

A true warrior learns from his mistakes

Originally posted by the ninjak
Spire how about giving your snide comments a rest.
The JLA/Avengers issue could have just as easily been written by someone else and Thor's hammer could have had more of an effect that a magical/enchanted artifact should have had against Supes. Your comments like "Thor crapping his pants" show your angry intent to such a level that you come off as a biased kid, compared to Quan who actually answers your comments calmly.

This is going to get ugly!

Thank you. He doesn't get to me and I answer his questions while he dodges mine and insults because it's getting to him. It's so obvious.

Originally posted by Spire
Lol forgot....

Thor crapping his pants was due to them both really trying to beat each other up.

Again with your quangic. "Could' and 'might' doesn't mean 'will'. Also it doesn't exclude the fact that it 'could' and 'might' go the same way again(Superman standing over Thor's unconscious body.)

Thor didn't crap his pants he was shocked and forgot he never saw anything like it even though he had years ago to give Superman an edge.

I have cited history and my opinion as to why it would go differently. You never actually debate though so debating takes a back seat to posting smileys and insulting other posters which is all you really do on here.

Originally posted by batdude123
It's hilarious to me that Thor fans still fail to accept what happened, and search for every excuse in the book in order to satisfy their fragile little egos.
Who is looking for excuses? Superman barely won. That's exactly what happened and in no way determines he wins a majority on kmc or any other board for that matter.

Originally posted by carver9
*Replies to something I wasn't talking about*

You realize I was responding to quan's incredibly astute argument that Thor beats people when not holding back(In other words - generic comic book hero trait) and that this some how means Thor has an advantage/or actually beats Superman, who, mind you can't/doesn't do the same thing. Superman totally didn't kill DD, after he just got done beating up a group of heroes. Totally.

Now lets get on the topic of the hammers hitting power. I seen someone say that its not as damaging as Supes fist. HHHHMMMM, lets see because I think its a lot more damaging than Supes fist.

First I want to start by using just thors punches. He levels a country side with it.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Stats/ThorStrength33338.jpg

The hammer:

Knocks Beta Ray bill out of orbit (no amps).

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Mjolnir/ThorMjolnir168-StrikingPower461.jpg

Galactus never felt pain before until being hit by Thors hammer whereas Superman had to get an amp (blue Superman) in order to breach Imperexs hide.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Mjolnir/ThorMjolnir51-StrikingPower161.jpg

Thor knocks Galactus the hell out.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Mjolnir/ThorMjolnir109-StrikingPower.jpg

Dented Primary Adamantium.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Mjolnir/ThorMjolnir58-StrikingPowerAvengers.jpg

I'll let you read this yourself.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Mjolnir/ThorMjolnir119-StrikingPower.jpg

Just wow.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Mjolnir/ThorMjolnir138-StrikingPower388.jpg

Again, just wow.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Mjolnir/ThorMjolnir165-StrikingPower439.jpg

Mjlonir hits creating nuke like explosions.

http://i578.photobucket.com/albums/ss225/OdinBorson/Thor%20Feats/Hammerbreaking.jpg
http://i578.photobucket.com/albums/ss225/OdinBorson/Thor%20Feats/Hammerbreaking2.jpg

Its pretty clear who hits the hardest.

Originally posted by Spire
You realize I was responding to quan's incredibly astute argument that Thor beats people when not holding back(In other words - generic comic book hero trait) and that this some how means Thor has an advantage/or actually beats Superman, who, mind you can't/doesn't do the same thing. Superman totally didn't kill DD, after he just got done beating up a group of heroes. Totally.
Not just beating dominating. See Surfer and Warlock and Ares and Pluto while facing him in handicap fashion.

Supes didn't hold back against WW and she managed to defeat him at the end.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor didn't crap his pants he was shocked and forgot he never saw anything like it even though he had years ago to give Superman an edge.

Yes. I totally, completely, and literally meant that Thor actually crapped his pants.

Proof that Thor 'forgot' anything?

Originally posted by quanchi112
I have cited history and my opinion as to why it would go differently. You never actually debate though so debating takes a back seat to posting smileys and insulting other posters which is all you really do on here.

The irony is truly amazing.

I pointed out how ridiculous your mention of 'could' and 'might' was and you respond with the above in an attempt to 'debate'.

Also, remember to include this proof that Thor forgot something.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Not just beating dominating. See Surfer and Warlock and Ares and Pluto while facing him in handicap fashion.

Supes didn't hold back against WW and she managed to defeat him at the end.

Cool.

Regardless of who Thor beat/slightly beat/completely beat, it has nothing to do with the fact the point you tried to make was ridiculous.

Originally posted by Spire
Yes. I totally, completely, and literally meant that Thor actually crapped his pants.

Proof that Thor 'forgot' anything?

The irony is truly amazing.

I pointed out how ridiculous your mention of 'could' and 'might' was and you respond with the above in an attempt to 'debate'.

Also, remember to include this proof that Thor forgot something.

If he saw the same thing why did he act like it was something he never witnessed before?

You restate yourself all the time. Other posters have called you out on it as well. You don't debate you just make rude comments because this stuff seriously effects you.

Originally posted by Spire
Cool.

Regardless of who Thor beat/slightly beat/completely beat, it has nothing to do with the fact the point you tried to make was ridiculous.

The fact that Thor can fight and want to win and then fight with no restraints and completely dominate his peers into the dirt. Superman had his hands full with a weaker character who held back while he didn't.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Superman had his hands full with a weaker character who held back while he didn't.

prove that thor was holding back and that superman went all out on him even with the fact that superman only punch him once and didnt use nothing else

Originally posted by Darkesthero
prove that thor was holding back and that superman went all out on him even with the fact that superman only punch him once and didnt use nothing else

Its kind of obvious that both held back if you ask me and the fight isnt legit at all.

Ironman almost koed Superman with a repulsor ray whereas Superman was ok from a magical lightning attack from Thor. 😕

The story was stupid unless you truly believe that Ironman>Supes and Thor.

Lets not even bring up Wonderman owning Gl.

Originally posted by quanchi112
If he saw the same thing why did he act like it was something he never witnessed before?

You restate yourself all the time. Other posters have called you out on it as well. You don't debate you just make rude comments because this stuff seriously effects you. The fact that Thor can fight and want to win and then fight with no restraints and completely dominate his peers into the dirt. Superman had his hands full with a weaker character who held back while he didn't.

So you don't have any proof that Thor forgot anything.

Concession accepted.

Also, your attempt to derail this into Supes/WW discussion to lead away from your ridiculous argument is duly noted.

I see it like this, the story was meant for Superman to win and in my eyes I dont see anything wrong with Superman winning BUT for a majority, not happening.

Another thing, Superman used his powers in that fight where thor didnt use 1% of what he had. He did more swinging than anything whereas Supes used his heat vision in like 2 to 3 full panels.

Originally posted by carver9
I see it like this, the story was meant for Superman to win and in my eyes I dont see anything wrong with Superman winning BUT for a majority, not happening.

Another thing, Superman used his powers in that fight where thor didnt use 1% of what he had. He did more swinging than anything whereas Supes used his heat vision in like 2 to 3 full panels.

Tom Brevoort laughs at you. Hard.

Originally posted by Spire
Tom Brevoort laughs at you. Hard.

😆

Tell him to meet me here and be prepared to bring some scans to back up his claim.

http://marvel.com/blogs/Tom_Brevoort/entry/846