The Presence vs The One Above All

Started by Slaanesh5 pages

TOAA

TOAA because the Presence isn't really the DC supreme being anymore.

Who is?

The Presence is God in DC, so that hasn't changed, he's the mind of the Primal Monitor/Overvoid/The Source. These concepts were unified and to be fair, other writers have suggested this before FC and Morrison.

Originally posted by Allankles
The Presence is God in DC, so that hasn't changed, he's the mind of the Primal Monitor/Overvoid/The Source. These concepts were unified and to be fair, other writers have suggested this before FC and Morrison.

So the Presence is an aspect of The Primal Monitor? Like the Word and Voice is to the Presence?

Originally posted by Prep-Man
So the Presence is an aspect of The Primal Monitor? Like the Word and Voice is to the Presence?

Presence is the mind of the Primal Monitor, I would call him the consciousness of the PM.

Originally posted by Allankles
Presence is the mind of the Primal Monitor, I would call him the consciousness of the PM.

so..does that mean it was the Presence who send those Monitor to investigate the DC Universe??

Originally posted by Allankles
Presence is the mind of the Primal Monitor, I would call him the consciousness of the PM.

And the Source is the body? That still doesn't make much sense considering the Source has shown to have a will and purpose of its own separate from the Presence.

Originally posted by Slaanesh
so..does that mean it was the Presence who send those Monitor to investigate the DC Universe??

my problems with it exactly, shouldnt he know about the damned thing? classic presence seemed a lot more envolved with things..tsc... omnipotence isnt what it used to be

Originally posted by Omega Vision
And the Source is the body? That still doesn't make much sense considering the Source has shown to have a will and purpose of its own separate from the Presence.

yeah this is all over the place, I dont think morrison thought this thing through

I agree. It doesn't make sense. The Presence met with Superman on more than one occasion. All of a sudden he doesn't "know" the Multiverse. LMAO>

Originally posted by 753
yeah this is all over the place, I dont think morrison thought this thing through

I think the inconsistency is fine considering inconsistency (and why its part of what makes comics special) was a theme of FC.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
And the Source is the body? That still doesn't make much sense considering the Source has shown to have a will and purpose of its own separate from the Presence.

The Source is also the same mind but the Monitor's call it the Overvoid which is also the Presence/God as of FC, I posted the article. Morrison chose to call it the Overvoid (or Mind of the Monitor) the reason being that he considers the metaphorical canvas stories are placed in, to be like an infinite void in which anything can happen.

Guys like Kirby pretty much intended for the Source to be a representation of DC's God in the 4th world, look at how he describes Highfather's first meeting with the Uni Friend? That had Pre Crisis God written all over it.

Even in Vertigo, where characters have in some stories made those type of distinctions, the Source itself has been described as omnipresent, omnipotent etc in Vertigo tales.

Starlin's source entity aside, I've never really understood why they would be seperate entities, since they seem to represent the exact same thing in the same DC reality.

Originally posted by Allankles
The Source is also the same mind but the Monitor's call it the Overvoid which is also the Presence/God as of FC, I posted the article. Morrison chose to call it the Overvoid (or Mind of the Monitor) the reason being that he considers the metaphorical canvas stories are placed in, to be like an infinite void in which anything can happen.

Guys like Kirby pretty much intended for the Source to be a representation of DC's God in the 4th world, look at how he describes Highfather's first meeting with the Uni Friend? That had Pre Crisis God written all over it.

Even in Vertigo, where characters have in some stories made those type of distinctions, the Source itself has been described as omnipresent, omnipotent etc in Vertigo tales.

Starlin's source entity aside, I've never really understood why they would be seperate entities, since they seem to represent the exact same thing in the same DC reality.

Uni Friend?

Originally posted by Prep-Man
I agree. It doesn't make sense. The Presence met with Superman on more than one occasion. All of a sudden he doesn't "know" the Multiverse. LMAO>

That was Pre Crisis though wasn't it? 😉

I prefer Morrison's take, it unifies all these concepts that writers have put together post crisis without being consistent with previous ideas.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
Uni Friend?

The Source directly conferring with Highfather in the form of a humanoid hand. It was pretty much like the image of Moses in the Bible getting the 10 commandments directly from God.

Originally posted by Allankles
The Source directly conferring with Highfather in the form of a humanoid hand. It was pretty much like the image of Moses in the Bible getting the 10 commandments directly from God.

👆

AKA The Hand.

Just like The Voice or The Word, it is an aspect of The Presence/Yahweh.

We saw the same hand reaching out to The Great Evil Beast.

It was even shown in an animated series..
Justice League Unlimited episode, "The Once and Future Thing, Part 2: Time Warped", where Batman and GL John Stewart chase Chronos before he merges with The Hand.

Stalemate

Originally posted by Xplosive
As it appears Primal Monitor may be above The Presence. If that is the case, then The Presence stands no chance.

If the existence of a character can influence the battle then your reasoning is flawed.

There is no universal rule that says that supreme from fiction A equals supreme from fiction B.

The Presence and TOAA stalemate in a yin-yang creation/destruction fest.