Harry Potter Magic versus the Force (Army thread).....

Started by Robtard73 pages

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Can the Jedi CONJURE these items at will? Out of thin air? Nope.

It's a wizard power to use conjuring spells.

The 501st and their machines are back in SWverse. The Jedi must contact them, have them make the journey to Earth, all in 30 minutes. Not gonna happen.

Gimp master zero, bro. I see how you angled so the wizards could draw on outside forces while making sure the Jedi were far far away from theirs.

HP cant do that either in a universe governed by the force, RJ.

And as a matter of fact; Nothing EVER comes from nowhere.
No energy is ever destroyed or created.

Its the same universe here, dude.
Move away from the gimp suit...

Originally posted by Robtard
And as I said, Precog for when they "poof" back.
Sure. The Jedi will have the presence of mind to track and attack when dealing with: fiendfyre, death spells, vanishing spells, apparating wizards, thousands of bludgers attacking them, a big ass fire breathing basilisk with a Medusa stare, not to mention Jedi fighting Jedi after they are Imperio'd. Not to mention the dozens of other spells the wizard have.

Crushed throat = choking death, no casually grabbing a vial and downing it in the middle of a battle like it's mid-day tea, son.
Nah, grab the vial, pop the top, swallow the tears, instant regen.

So now they're "thousands of feet" high? LoL, dude. Fiendfryre has mass, it can be pushed and held. Those few that can both cast and control it, would be open to attack/death.
Sure, the Jedi might be able to hold fiendfyre at bay, but as they do so, they still have to deal with: death spells, vanishing spells, apparating wizards, thousands of bludgers attacking them, a big ass fire breathing basilisk with a Medusa stare, not to mention Jedi fighting Jedi after they are Imperio'd. Not to mention the dozens of other spells the wizard have.

LoL, K. If wizards can call in minions, so can the Jedi. Obi radios and calls in the 501st. /thread.
And they arrive in 30 minutes? Not.

Conjuring spells= Instantaneous.

😄

Originally posted by Robtard
Gimp master zero, bro. I see how you angled so the wizards could draw on outside forces while making sure the Jedi were far far away from theirs.

haermm Conjuring spells is NOT an outside force, dude. The wizards can conjure whatever they wish, because it is a power they have.

Getting on a radio and calling in backup is NOT a power.

Death Star laser didn't take 30 mins to get to places. Fact.

And if it did, the Wizards had no escape against a machine thats power pales into insignificance next to the power of the force.

Radio back up is an onscreen feat.
Opening a door isnt "a power", but it is a wizard ability, for example.
Oh...and "Theyre all dead, Dave."

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
HP cant do that either in a universe governed by the force, RJ.

And as a matter of fact; Nothing EVER comes from nowhere.
No energy is ever destroyed or created.

Its the same universe here, dude.
Move away from the gimp suit...

The JEDI and the WIZARDS are in the same universe, the 501st are not.

Conjuring spells: Instant, whatever the wizard wish to conjure.

Jedi calling in the cavalry: Not instant. They'll be dead by the time they arrive.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Sure. The Jedi will have the presence of mind to track and attack when dealing with: fiendfyre, death spells, vanishing spells, apparating wizards, thousands of bludgers attacking them, a big ass fire breathing basilisk with a Medusa stare, not to mention Jedi fighting Jedi after they are Imperio'd. Not to mention the dozens of other spells the wizard have.

Nah, grab the vial, pop the top, swallow the tears, instant regen.

Sure, the Jedi might be able to hold fiendfyre at bay, but as they do so, they still have to deal with: death spells, vanishing spells, apparating wizards, thousands of bludgers attacking them, a big ass fire breathing basilisk with a Medusa stare, not to mention Jedi fighting Jedi after they are Imperio'd. Not to mention the dozens of other spells the wizard have.

And they arrive in 30 minutes? Not.

Conjuring spells= Instantaneous.

😄

They've done it while facing/countering hundreds and hundreds of shots. So yeah. 20 wizards isn't some overwhelming might to them.

Crushed throat = quick choking death. So no, no swallowing tears.

You argue as if the Jedi won't be attacking back and the wizards can just zip about on their brooms at leisure. Fail, bro. Being Force-slammed, crushed, having wands pulled/broken, broomsticks shattered, Jedi flpping about and slicing. It will be madness to the wizards in kind.

As I said, you catered the scenario to give the wizards the angle of being able to draw upon outside forces, very telling, that.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Death Star laser didn't take 30 mins to get to places. Fact.

And if it did, the Wizards had no escape against a machine thats power pales into insignificance next to the power of the force.

Theyre dead, Dave.

The Death Star has a limited range, Pinball. It cannot fire from another galaxy and hit something in this galaxy. Plus, the wizards can simply vanish the death star. Or turn it into a micro machine.

Besides, SW is "A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away." How they gonna call in something from another time?

Now, if the Jedi had the power to conjure objects out of thin air, you'd have a good point. They can't. You don't.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
The JEDI and the WIZARDS are in the same universe, the 501st are not.

Conjuring spells: Instant, whatever the wizard wish to conjure.

Jedi calling in the cavalry: Not instant. They'll be dead by the time they arrive.

Actually by the time the troops get their based on a precog informed descision based order, they SHOULD actually arrive excatly when needed. 🙂

Nice gimp attempt though, Elizabeth O'Gimpey.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
The Death Star has a limited range, Pinball. It cannot fire from another galaxy and hit something in this galaxy. Plus, the wizards can simply vanish the death star. Or turn it into a micro machine.

Besides, SW is "A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away." How they gonna call in something from another time?

Now, if the Jedi had the power to conjure objects out of thin air, you'd have a good point. They can't. You don't.

Yes and thanks to probes, precog, remote seeing etc, The death Star was able to move at lightspeed into just outside of earth in time. 🙂

Gotta love onscreen SW feats and tech.

Originally posted by Robtard
They've done it while facing/countering hundreds and hundreds of shots. So yeah. 20 wizards isn't some overwhelming might to them.
And many Jedi fell, yeah!!!! Also, there was not a big ass wall of fiendfyre coming at them. Nor were Jedi neing tricked into fighting one another.

Crushed throat = quick choking death. So no, no swallowing tears.
Nah, they'd have at least a few seconds to regen.

You argue as if the Jedi won't be attacking back and the wizards and just zip about on their brooms at leisure. Fail, bro. Being Force-slammed, crushed, having wands pulled/broken, broomsticks shattered, Jedi flpping about and slicing. It will be madness to the wizards in kind.
And the moment the Jedi decide to mount an offensive, they'll be burnt alive.

As I said, you catered the scenario to give the wizards the angle of being able to draw upon outside forces, very telling, that.
Nope. Conjuring spells are a wizard power. Deal with it.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Actually by the time the troops get their based on a precog informed descision based order, they SHOULD actually arrive excatly when needed. 🙂

Nice gimp attempt though, Gimpey.

Different timeline, dude. The Jedi are in Manhattan due to unknown reasons, they cannot summon forces from the past.

If they had time turners they could 😱

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Yes and thanks to probes, precog, remote seeing etc, The death Star was able to move at lightspeed into just outside of earth in time. 🙂

Gotta love onscreen SW feats and tech.

Mhm, and how long does it take the death star to travel the galaxy via lightspeed? How far is Earth from SWverse?

Fail.

And due to the wizard power of Transfiguration, the Jedi are all transformed into ferrets:

YouTube video

And our beloved SW saga is transformed into this:

YouTube video

It dropped out of Hyperspace and into lightspeed and regular space a light year away from earth just over a year ago, due to prophecy and precog.

Also youve got to appreciate that travelling in non hyperspace in ESB took Han and the posse a few minutes of screen time to cross at least half the entire galaxy. Same as Obiwans trip to Kamino in the outer rim, from Coruscant in the middle of the galaxy.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
It dropped out of Hyperspace and into lightspeed and regular space a light year away from earth just over a year ago, due to prophecy and precog.

"A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away........"

Wizards can alter space and time. Jedi cannot.

Ahhhhhh so now you sabotage the very possibility of the match occurring in the first place...? 🙄

The Jedi routinely alter space when they send their dirty little ripples of force energy through the space in question is made of.. 🙂

The Jedi see past present and future.
And its not unfeasible that Wormholes are travelled through to get to now, to circumnavigate your gimpage.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Ahhhhhh so now you sabotage the very possibility of the match occurring in the first place...? 🙄

The Jedi routinely alter space when they send their dirty little ripples of force energy through the space in question is made of.. 🙂


Time travel does not exist in SWverse, babe.

The Jedi cannot time travel, dude. The Jedi cannot turn a two person tent into a small mansion. They cannot conjure objects out of thin air.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth

The Jedi see past present and future.
And its not unfeasible that Wormholes are travelled through to get to now, to circumnavigate your gimpage.

As do the wizards.

No. The Jedi FIND themselves in Manhattan. They, like the wizards, are there and have 30 minutes prep.

Nah they dont...they had no force connection.

Ok They found their fleet in orbit around the planet which is standard SW onscreen Emporer gear and undeniable capabilitah.