saber style Makashi: Questions

Started by Gideon9 pages

Edit: Waaaaait a minute, you're saying Sidious would have killed himself due to the Force lightning? Now that's believable.

Originally posted by Galan007
I agree. All I'm saying is that Palpatine is the one who gave out before Mace in that particular scene. If Palpatine would have kept up his lightning, or tried to attack Mace again (while Mace still had his saber) then Palps almost certainly would have been killed.

Don't tell me to read through your assumptions anymore. One post to disprove this:

As long as Windu keeps reflecting, Palpatine can continue.

If you cannot, through logic we gather that Palpatine threw the fight.

Uh, if Windu kept reflecting, Palpatine would have ended up looking like Skeletor.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Uh, if Windu kept reflecting, Palpatine would have ended up looking like Skeletor.
Or dead.

DUDE

No.

What the hell?

Originally posted by Gideon
Edit: Waaaaait a minute, you're saying Sidious would have killed himself due to the Force lightning? Now that's believable.
Yes. What did you think I was talking about?

How can he kill himself when the ROTS novel explicitly states that his pain only increased his power?

Originally posted by Shoes
How can he kill himself when the ROTS novel explicitly states that his pain only increased his power?

Anakin Solo's increased power burst his cells and killed him. It can happen in Star Wars.

Originally posted by Shoes
How can he kill himself when the ROTS novel explicitly states that his pain only increased his power?
To how much? An endless amount?

Originally posted by Enyalus
Anakin Solo's increased power burst his cells and killed him. It can happen in Star Wars.

wtf is this shit

Originally posted by mattatom
To how much? An endless amount?

Obviously not, but the novelization makes it clear that Mace was about to give.

Originally posted by Shoes
Obviously not, but the novelization makes it clear that Mace was about to give.
After that statement was made, Mace continued deflecting teh lightning until Palps himself was mangled, and stopped manifesting it. Stop clinging to a disproven statement. If Mace were as exhausted as you seem to think, then he would have been overwhelmed by Palpatine's lightning.... But he wasn't.

I gave you a chance. See above post. It's canon fact that as long as Windu reflects, Palpatine will only continue. So what if his fake face melts? That's not even close to killing the most powerful sith lord in history. You've also neglected to adress the fact that Palpatine blasted him with lightning mere seconds after he "lost".

Futhermore, Mace was exhausted to the point of collapsing. The quote is not disproven, as we don't have a timeframe of how long he kept going after that statement was made. He could have gone an extra second, or half a second.

*sighs*

'Mere seconds' is a huge exaggeration. Nevertheless, it means nothing, considering that Dooku - an inferior Force user - went from completely fatigued to replenished in just the few seconds it took him to draw upon the Force again in his duel with Anakin and Obi-Wan in ROTS.

How many seconds is considered "mere"?

True, but people seem to think that Sidious was half-dead from absorbing his own lightning, and that's why he couldn't continue. Dooku wasn't.

Bane collapsed after unleashing his TK wave, and then lay there for several minutes. If Palpatine gave everything he had (plus his bonus form the pain) he wouldn't rise up agian.

Palpatine was already sitting on his ass leaning against the window pane. The lazy bastard wouldn't need to collapse, since he wasn't doing any physical exercise.

What do the words UNLIMITED POWER mean to you?

Sorry, you want me to discredit Palpatine calling himself too weak to continue the fight, but give credence to his unlimited power line?

How's that working for you?

Apology accepted. Don't let it happen again.

Oh noes! Outwitted again!