Rots Obi-Wan and Mace Windu vs. Rots Vader and dark jedi Galen Marek

KT
There was also nothing to suggest Mace was anywhere on par with a stronger than Marek Sid in terms of Force Strength... Yet, we saw how that went

😐

RandomGuy
Negative, Mace, being the Bad Motha ****a Jedi Master he is, would have a Force bubble/shield up throughout the battle, so that Marek's Repulse trick would probably just fling him 20-50 meters or so rather than burning his flesh and bones to dust.

Gideon^

Yeah, there's nothing to suggest that Windu is anywhere on par with Marek in terms of Force Strength.

...We're not talking about the outcome of a duel, but a comparison in Force strength. So... I appreciate your input, but it's irrelevant.

who are you even talking to?

kodiak430
who are you even talking to?

KT; I was originally talking to SWFan4Life, but KT decided to step in.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Oooooo were back to this... Sids threw the fight.... 👇

I always thought sidious lost the saber fight, but was feigning weakness during the force fight?

The whole "help me I'm a weak old man, can't hold out!"

With the book saying mace was at his limit and could go no more, then sids just gives out.

Then once anakin turns, he shoots out more force lightening then ever prior, electrocutes mace so much you can see his skeletonand then proceeds to force throw mace a hundred meters out the window. Followed by a backflip onto his feet and revived vigor.

Originally posted by Gideon
KT; I was originally talking to SWFan4Life, but KT decided to step in.

BW
I always thought sidious lost the saber fight, but was feigning weakness during the force fight?

The whole "help me I'm a weak old man, can't hold out!"

With the book saying mace was at his limit and could go no more, then sids just gives out.

Then once anakin turns, he shoots out more force lightening then ever prior, electrocutes mace so much you can see his skeletonand then proceeds to force throw mace a hundred meters out the window. Followed by a backflip onto his feet and revived vigor.

He was exaggerating that part.

so are you saying that galen would beat windu, or what?

kodiak430
so are you saying that galen would beat windu, or what?

If it was a strict battle of Force powers, absolutely.

so that brings us back to the topic of this thread, which is not just a force battle, but an all out. and who would win in the battle between obi-wan and vader?

It depends on Vaders mindset.

As long as vader uses force illusion on himself and sees obiwan as dooku he wins.

Originally posted by Board Walker
As long as vader uses force illusion on himself and sees obiwan as dooku he wins.

So he can be in the zone....and not have any emotional hang ups with obiwan...?

wtf is force illusion? ive never even heard of that and im pretty sure vader doesnt know that

.........

you gna tell me or just make me feel stupid? 😛

Force illusion is very powerful......very mystic.....remember in episode of cloud city where luke and rebels thought lando cal rizzo was there...but itwas actually vader?

Originally posted by Gideon
KT; I was originally talking to SWFan4Life, but KT decided to step in.

Yea I don't see how Windu could have greater Force strength than Marek either, but I still suspect that Windu wouldn't be killed outright from the Force Repulse if he was defending against it. He would likely be pushed several dozen meters or burned. If he had his guard down, that's a different story.

I am talking to Gideon for this post, but kodiak feel free to listen in (or "read" in)!

But what happens if marek repulses mace, quicky follows up mace while he is still being pushed, and then repeatedly force repulses mace in quick succession. I don't think mace would survive...

Originally posted by Board Walker
But what happens if marek repulses mace, quicky follows up mace while he is still being pushed, and then repeatedly force repulses mace in quick succession. I don't think mace would survive...

That assumes Marek could do his maximum Force Repulse technique repeatedly within a number of seconds, and that he actually has the reserves available to perform this feat multiple times so quickly.

If I were George Lucas, I would probably say yes, because I completely disregard the PT and OT movies.

But I'm not, so I'll defer to higher judgment from this forum.