Thor VS Thanos

Started by zeel39 pages

[QUOTE=12856763]Originally posted by h1a8
Surfer fighting to his best abilities can't lose to Thanos. [/QUOTE

you know i was going to comment on this but i change my mind i have better things to do be back later have to go take a zhit. 😕 ]

^ Oddly enough, Thor's never once met 616 Gladiator.

Originally posted by Nihilist
Still waiting for Lord of Blunder to show that Thor doing a soul suck against a non magic/asgardian based character or Thanos lvl in power/willpower

Level in power or willpower has nothing to do with resisting a soul suck. Other factors are needed. But being a non asgardian probably has something to do with it. Did the comic hint or mention that Thor was able to do it ONLY because of a someone being magical or Asgardian?

Originally posted by h1a8
Level in power or willpower has nothing to do with resisting a soul suck. Other factors are needed. But being a non asgardian probably has something to do with it. Did the comic hint or mention that Thor was able to do it ONLY because of a someone being magical or Asgardian?

Nope...NOTHING about it only working because Loki was Asgardian or Magical was mentioned (of course Loki is not Asgardian at all...he's a runt Frost Giant).

The point that some of these Thanos enthusiast cant handle is that there is NO SHOWING or PROOF on the behave of Thanos that indicates that he can withstand this kind of assault....

And you are correct h1a8, Thanos's power level has jack s**t to do with wether or not he can survive this attack; although Nihilist, with his supremely flawed reasoning ability, tried to argue just that...that because Thanos was powerful he automatically resists this attack...LOL!!

But at the end of the day, the Thanos fanboys have nothing reasonable to base their argument upon; all they can say is "it doesnt work because we are talking about Thanos dammit!"

LOL...

Epic Logic fail at 10 o'clock...Nihilist is the criminal in police custody...details after sports!

💃

I'm a little late on this debate. But what argumentation is there that exist that the soul suck could affect Thanos in the first place?

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Nope...NOTHING about it only working because Loki was Asgardian or Magical was mentioned (of course Loki is not Asgardian at all...he's a runt Frost Giant).

The point that some of these Thanos enthusiast cant handle is that there is NO SHOWING or PROOF on the behave of Thanos that indicates that he can withstand this kind of assault....

And you are correct h1a8, Thanos's power level has jack s**t to do with wether or not he can survive this attack; although Nihilist, with his supremely flawed reasoning ability, tried to argue just that...that because Thanos was powerful he automatically resists this attack...LOL!!

But at the end of the day, the Thanos fanboys have nothing reasonable to base their argument upon; all they can say is "it doesnt work because we are talking about Thanos dammit!"

LOL...

Epic Logic fail at 10 o'clock...Nihilist is the criminal in police custody...details after sports!

💃

When you can show this tactic has been used more than once and as a regular battle tactic not something he did under extreme duress or out of extreme anger then you can use it as a viable tactic if not then it remains a one time circumstantial feat.

the fact that the whole debate is whether the soul suck would work or not gives a clear view on who should get the majority if they fought

Soooo, what proof is there that the Thor soul suck would work vs Thanos in the first place?

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Soooo, what proof is there that the Thor soul suck would work vs Thanos in the first place?
What proof is there he has a soul?

Originally posted by thanos-prime
What proof is there he has a soul?

Well, he DID appear outside his body AFTER his death in Annihilation when he was shown with Death in front of Nova before he passed out after his fight with Annihilus. It didn't say "soul" but that's roughly enough for it to be a seen as a soul.

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Well, he DID appear outside his body AFTER his death in Annihilation when he was shown with Death in front of Nova before he passed out after his fight with Annihilus. It didn't say "soul" but that's roughly enough for it to be a seen as a soul.
Twas a joke. I know he has a soul.

who cares?

If Thor's only option (and that's an IF) is an attack he has only once some years ago I don't think there's much to debate.

Thanos should win a solid 9/10 as he should against every high tier character as he surpasses them.

I can see Thor taking 1 or 2 if he goes all out llike in his fight with Durok and Thanos is too complacent at the time to let his guard down

I don't even see Thor taking a win from Thanos. :-/

Thanos is a step up over Thor as much as Thor is a step up over Colossus or Namor.

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
I don't even see Thor taking a win from Thanos. :-/

Thanos is a step up over Thor as much as Thor is a step up over Colossus or Namor.

true... as I said Thor might take one or two if he is at his most deterrmined and at the same time Thanos underestmates him enough to let him go all out on him.

Having said that I don't see any high herald taking a win against a determined going all out Thanos

Thanos

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ Oddly enough, Thor's never once met 616 Gladiator.

really? didnt he fight gladiator in the ff4 book or something? or maybe not...i seem to recall gladiator being from some alternate reality or something not sure though.

Thanos stomps.

Once again thanos stomps all high heralds.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Nope...NOTHING about it only working because Loki was Asgardian or Magical was mentioned (of course Loki is not Asgardian at all...he's a runt Frost Giant).

The point that some of these Thanos enthusiast cant handle is that there is NO SHOWING or PROOF on the behave of Thanos that indicates that he can withstand this kind of assault....

And you are correct h1a8, Thanos's power level has jack s**t to do with wether or not he can survive this attack; although Nihilist, with his supremely flawed reasoning ability, tried to argue just that...that because Thanos was powerful he automatically resists this attack...LOL!!

But at the end of the day, the Thanos fanboys have nothing reasonable to base their argument upon; all they can say is "it doesnt work because we are talking about Thanos dammit!"

LOL...

Epic Logic fail at 10 o'clock...Nihilist is the criminal in police custody...details after sports!

💃

Instead of posting all this bravado crap, you simply could of said you have no proof to back up your so called fool theory of a soul suck working on Thanos, when we know he has used a few times at most and Loki(magic/asgardian) is its highest scalp to date, so again proof is what you need to show and not trying to act cool.

If we are gonna go down this 1 feat route, Thanos turns Thor to stone after all he did it to a Skrull who have complete molecular control over their body, and Thor couldnt resist matter manip for another Eternal(Sersi)

Originally posted by Nihilist
If we are gonna go down this 1 feat route, Thanos turns Thor to stone after all he did it to a Skrull who have complete molecular control over their body, and Thor couldnt resist matter manip for another Eternal(Sersi)

I'm gonna use your own logic: who says this will work on Thor ? Thor isn't a skrull, and Thanos sure ain't Sersi.