Nova Prime vs Green Lantern (Kyle)

Started by OneDumbG015 pages

Originally posted by cdtm
The end result was the same, but one is exploiting a weakness, while the other is a pure power showing.

To overload the core of Oa is a display of insane energy output.

Only if you assume through a circular argument that Oa's core wasn't like a big battery that could be overloaded... the same way that the Death Stare's core reactor was like a battery that could be overloaded.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Only if you assume through a circular argument that Oa's core wasn't like a big battery that could be overloaded... the same way that the Death Stare's core reactor was like a battery that could be overloaded.
Your analogy makes about as much sense as a Loc Ness monster masturbating. Its bullshit, it makes no sense. One does not correlate with the other.

Your looking to much into Hal’s relationship with the planet OA. The planet in it of itself is not battery, given that it does not produce, or channel Oan energy.

Originally posted by "Id"
Your analogy makes about as much sense as a Loc Ness monster masturbating. Its bullshit, it makes no sense. One does not correlate with the other.

Your looking to much into Hal’s relationship with the planet OA. The planet in it of itself is not battery, given that it does not produce, or channel Oan energy.

And even if it did channel energy, that would make it a huge battery. Merely overloading a a planet sized battery by pouring energy directly into it would be impressive enough.

But yeah, Oa's core didn't actually possess any of the CPB's power.

Originally posted by 753
nah, he's mid with a couple of feats in the high herald class
Tell me how that makes any sense. Nothing about Nova suggests mid herald. He's a high herald, just not highest of the high ala Surfer etc.

Originally posted by dmills
Tell me how that makes any sense. Nothing about Nova suggests mid herald. He's a high herald, just not highest of the high ala Surfer etc.
Because if we compare him to the others ranked in the high and the mid herald class, he's closer to the mid and has a few feats that put him on the high herald class. In time, as he gets more screentime he might make it there, but remember that characters like wonder woman, magneto and monica rambeau are officially in in the mid herald class in this site and they're very very powerfull with a lot more feats than him.

I think we're all forgetting the point of this thread. Kyle has some impressive feats, but what good are those varied feats against Nova? In a dogfight, I believe Nova has the physicality, the durability, and the power output (potential pwer output also) to KO Rayner.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
I think we're all forgetting the point of this thread. Kyle has some impressive feats, but what good are those varied feats against Nova? In a dogfight, I believe Nova has the physicality, the durability, and the power output (potential pwer output also) to KO Rayner.
The purpose of these feats is to show that Kyle matches Nova step for step, and then some. It answers what will happen if they get involved in a dog fight. Albeit Nova being beaten by Kyle.

Originally posted by "Id"
The purpose of these feats is to show that Kyle matches Nova step for step, and then some. It answers what will happen if they get involved in a dog fight. Albeit Nova being beaten by Kyle.
Wait a minute. Aren't you the OP? Why'd you make this thread if you thought Kyle wins all along?

Originally posted by 753
Because if we compare him to the others ranked in the high and the mid herald class, he's closer to the mid and has a few feats that put him on the high herald class. In time, as he gets more screentime he might make it there, but remember that characters like wonder woman, magneto and monica rambeau are officially in in the mid herald class in this site and they're very very powerfull with a lot more feats than him.
Going by his portrayal in the books, the respect he gets from his peers, his feats etc. I have to disagree. Do you consider Quasar High herald?

Originally posted by dmills
Wait a minute. Aren't you the OP? Why'd you make this thread if you thought Kyle wins all along?

It makes for a good argument, when you have members who think otherwise.

Originally posted by "Id"
It makes for a good argument, when you have members who think otherwise.
So you already had an outcome in mind?

"Id": Except Kyle stated that the core of Oa was like a battery. Your argument would be more persuasive if, y'know, you just completely choose to ignore that.

Originally posted by dmills
Going by his portrayal in the books, the respect he gets from his peers, his feats etc. I have to disagree. Do you consider Quasar High herald?
Respect for his leadership, character, willpower etc. It's not his power level that draws respect from them. The tiers revolve arround power. What has he done that is beyond the other midheralds?

Yes, classic Quasar was high herald.

Originally posted by dmills
So you already had an outcome in mind?

Yes but I am open to persuasion.

Originally posted by 753
Respect for his leadership, character, willpower etc. It's not his power level that draws respect from them. The tiers revolve arround power. What has he done that is beyond the other midheralds?

Yes, classic Quasar was high herald.

Nah. They respect his power too.

You want me to list his feats that are beyond MH? You sure you want to play this game? You know that Nova is my turf.

Originally posted by "Id"
Yes but I am open to persuasion.
Interesting...

How bout a list that puts him in high heralds class..

Originally posted by Ambient
How bout a list that puts him in high heralds class..
:/ Your request is ridiculous. The feats that he has accomplished can be replicated by most if not all in the HH tier. That's why they're high heralds.

Originally posted by dmills
Nah. They respect his power too.

You want me to list his feats that are beyond MH? You sure you want to play this game? You know that Nova is my turf.

knock yourself out. You show things you believe the other mid heralds couldn't do and I'll try to find compatible feats from them. Might also try to find some high herald feats he couldn't replicate - provided he has the powerset to make it conceivable.

Originally posted by dmills
:/ Your request is ridiculous. The feats that he has accomplished can be replicated by most if not all in the HH tier. That's why they're high heralds.
That's a fallacy. The HHs can replicate the feats of the lesser ties, but the opposite isn't true. So the fact that they can replicate his feats means nothing, showing that he can replicate their average and high end feats is what would put him on their level. Showing he can do things beyond the midheralds would also prove it.