Dooku and Maul vs ROTS Anakin and ROTS Obi Wan

Started by Jinsoku Takai8 pages
Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
Not that Kenobi wouldn't utterly hand Maul his ass in an even worse fashion than he did in TPM.

He didn't exactly hand him his ass in TPM, and he wouldn't here either- although he would likely defeat him with great effort.

He did, literally, put Maul on his ass. Weither or not there's some silly PIS involved doesn't change the fact that he did.

And yes he would. Maul isn't that impressive compared to the big league fighters. I mean, due to Soresu it might take awhile, but, Obi-Wan would never be in any danger. He'd handle him in the same lazy non-chalant way he handled Assaj in the clone wars movie.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
He did, literally, put Maul on his ass. Weither or not there's some silly PIS involved doesn't change the fact that he did.

And yes he would. Maul isn't that impressive compared to the big league fighters. I mean, due to Soresu it might take awhile, but, Obi-Wan would never be in any danger. He'd handle him in the same lazy non-chalant way he handled Assaj in the clone wars movie.

Damnit Blax, he didn't walk up to him, ass in hand, and hand it to him - didn't happen! To say Maul isn't a threat to the big league fighters is borderline nonsense - Maybe not Dooku, Sidious, and Yoda, but Ob1 - yeah.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
He did, literally, put Maul on his ass.

Was that after or before Maul chucked him down the shaft and killed Obiwan's Jedi Master?? If it was a one on one fight Qui-Gons lightsaber wuldnt have been conviniently hanging around therefore Obi-Wan lost his actual One on One Lightsaber duel with Maul.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
And yes he would. Maul isn't that impressive compared to the big league fighters.

Well he's more impressive than Ventress thats for sure. And Ventress has given Obi-Wan hell on more than one occasion.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
[B]I mean, due to Soresu it might take awhile, but, Obi-Wan would never be in any danger.

I dunno.. Juyo's no joke.. And Maul's kicks are lethal.. And despite Obi-wans defence its been proven many times he can still be kicked or punched mid-saber fight.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
He'd handle him in the same lazy non-chalant way he handled Assaj in the clone wars movie.

You mean the fight where at one point Ventress disarms him.. I sure hope he fights better than that, cause if Maul disarms him he aint gna miss!

Im sure the Master of Soresu would defeat Maul but I seriously doubt it'd be a walk in the park against a guy who was chosen and trained by Sidious himself, was a physical beast, and Mastered Juyo, Martial Arts, the Lightsaber, Saber Staff and Teras Kasi/Jar Kai or watever its called.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Was that after or before Maul chucked him down the shaft and killed Obiwan's Jedi Master?? If it was a one on one fight Qui-Gons lightsaber wuldnt have been conviniently hanging around therefore Obi-Wan lost his actual One on One Lightsaber duel with Maul.

Well he's more impressive than Ventress thats for sure. And Ventress has given Obi-Wan hell on more than one occasion.

I dunno.. Juyo's no joke.. And Maul's kicks are lethal.. And despite Obi-wans defence its been proven many times he can still be kicked or punched mid-saber fight.

You mean the fight where at one point Ventress disarms him.. I sure hope he fights better than that, cause if Maul disarms him he aint gna miss!

Im sure the Master of Soresu would defeat Maul but I seriously doubt it'd be a walk in the park against a guy who was chosen and trained by Sidious himself, was a physical beast, and Mastered Juyo, Martial Arts, the Lightsaber, Saber Staff and Teras Kasi/Jar Kai or watever its called.

...in other words...

He wouldn't just cut Maul in two, he would cut him up in 19 pieces, in one second.

yes.

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
He wouldn't just cut Maul in two, he would cut him up in 19 pieces, in one second.

Yeah just like he did to Ventress right?? One long second that was!

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
...in other words...

He would defeat him with a lot of effort

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Yeah just like he did to Ventress right?? One long second that was!

I'll rephrase for you: He'll cut Maul in 19 pieces, within one and the same second. Not after one second.

He cut Anakin up in less than a second. I find it very likely he could do the same to Maul.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
He would defeat him with a lot of effort

I was agreeing w/ you - indicating that you stated virtually the same thing (albeit in expanded format) that I stated in my earlier post.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
He did, literally, put Maul on his ass. Weither or not there's some silly PIS involved doesn't change the fact that he did.

And yes he would. Maul isn't that impressive compared to the big league fighters. I mean, due to Soresu it might take awhile, but, Obi-Wan would never be in any danger. He'd handle him in the same lazy non-chalant way he handled Assaj in the clone wars movie.

He was tapping some anger at the time. Give him 13 years, war experience, and mastery of Soresu... Maul's not touching him.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
He was tapping some anger at the time. Give him 13 years, war experience, and mastery of Soresu... Maul's not touching him.

As was stated earlier; Just like Ventress didn't "touch him", right? And no bs about abc logic.

Ventress got humiliated by Kenobi.

Like from the :36 second mark to the :55 second mark? Can't see Kenobi grabbing Maul and forcing him back like he did Ventress. Do you really believe an unarmed Kenobi would survive Darth Maul? I mean, Kenobi could, and would probably win, but it'd be damn close, and if he give Maul the slightest opening (ala his fight w/ Ventress in the video), he's done.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hMUntfHgSxc

pretty sure kenobi was laughing at her the whole time.

That was just his way of frustrating her, saying things like "you'll have to do better than that my darling"

And listen and watch carefully, he didnt actually start winning the fight until she sensed Anakin was gone. And Obi-wan used that to frustrate Ventress further.

Remember in a later episode she was fighting both Anakin and Obiwan simultaneously. Obi-wan was hardly laughing then.

All this comparing of the Obi-Wan vs Ventress fight and the Obi-Wan vs Maul fight makes you wonder how far Ventress is actually behind Maul in terms of lightsaber combat.

Probably not too far behind. I think Ventress has come far since being trained by Dooku. In a deleted scene from the CW movie, Ventress almost defeats Anakin. Then in an episode later on she fights off both Obi-Wan and Anakin together. So shes tough, no doubt about that. But Maul is certainly ahead of her.