Originally posted by psycho gundam
uhuh
To be honest, I think we are mostly on the same page.
Originally posted by No End N Site
Yeah, the thing was, he said "very similar", it's not that similar. Even Sean can win 2 outta 8 against Yun or Chun. And in 2nd Impact, Sean was top tier. He actually sucks now cuz he got nerfed to hell.No they don't.
You don't base you're whole scope around tourney results cuz if you look at a game like SSFIV, you will be decieved.
"Very" is a relative term obviously, but my point stands.
Yes, they do. I don't see how can someone can look at typical EVO/SBO results and think otherwise.
I agree usually. Still, it's a more reliable an indicator than most.
Originally posted by No End N Site
A few characters are gonna get thrashed, but if most of the cast is actually viable, than the balance is not bad.MVC2 is phucked up in mind boggling ways but MVC2 has 56 characters, about 9 are good. 3S has 20, about 13 are good, with 2 of the 13 being REALLY good. There is no comparrison. CVS2 has some really phucked up things in it and even I have stayed away from having CVS and MVC in the same sentence (until now). 3rd Strike is unbalanced (like every other fighting game on the planet that's not SFI), but it's not anywhere near overwhelming.
The game wouldn't still be played at major tournies if it was.
I'd disagree on most of the cast being viable, but that discussion leads to nowhere. You and your backwards 3rd Strike fanboyism. 😛
Nah. MVC2 still gets tournament play. An unbalanced game can still get massively popular.
Originally posted by No End N Site
3rd Strike is unbalanced (like every other fighting game on the planet that's not SFI), but it's not anywhere near overwhelming. The game wouldn't still be played at major tournies if it was.
Perfect balance can't be achieved without having every character have the exact same moves, but there are some balanced games out there. Guilty Gear and Arcana Heart come to mind.
Either way, you and I have already had several pages of discussion on this in the past. I feel this would wind up going down the same road.
In the end, we did agree though. 3rd Strike is unbalanced and some characters are disproportionately represented in competition; however, it is not as unbalanced as MVC2. We'd just be arguing pedantries after that.