Cross Genre Match #21: Frieza vs Thanos

Started by illadelph1285 pages

There's nothing wrong with anything in the cartoon. People just need to stop being assholes and look at context.

some of this is obviously directed at me so....

Originally posted by illadelph12
- 60% people trying to dictate what evidence is admissable because they don't want to use a cartoon (even if the OP explicitly states to use the cartoon, in fact, they refuse to use the cartoon because it's "not 100% loyal to [insert writer's name]'s vision", and is full of filler [which can easily just be reconciled as simply being cartoon antics, but has to be bemoaned ad nauseum]).
if that has ever happened it's in the 1% of all threads made in that category, but even though, using the manga makes it far easier to post feats that are concrete for all to see, just like we do for comics.

it doesn't have to cause headaches

Originally posted by illadelph12
There's nothing wrong with anything in the cartoon. People just need to stop being assholes and look at context.
There was something wrong with how long they dragged out the Freiza fight...

but besides that no.

Stop being an asshole and it will all make sense.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
He was constantly getting stronger cause the moon (<-?) came closer to earth or something.
garlic junior saga, which never happened in the manga.

as in he doesn't exist

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Not canon.

They certainly looked like they were struggling. And piccolo got his liscense right?

Yeah. With the dark mists things that turned everyone into "zombies" for garlic junior?

This is him directly from the anime.

Thats after the freiza saga.Piccolo should stomp him as before he was having trouble beating goku and piccolo before the sayian saga.

So why are you using movies that aren't canon to the anime or the manga and how powerful was garlick junior during that time?

Squirrel girl have human strength and controls squirrels... she defeated thanos.

Nah, it wasn't directed at you specifically PG. Many people have used that approach in vs threads and in the tier discussions. Nemebro, for example. I just think it's bad form and blurs the matter at hand.

Originally posted by carver9
So why are you using movies that aren't canon to the anime or the manga and how powerful was garlick junior during that time?

Squirrel girl have human strength and controls squirrels... she defeated thanos.

Its not a movie. Its episodes in the anime that are filler. As far how powerful he was...well he should have been stomped with ease. I mean he was immortal but Krillian,Gohan, or piccolo all should have soloed him with ease. He was fighting a good fight with pre sayian saga Goku and piccolo.

And she beat galactus. By feats she should stomp him. Being beaten by SG isn't a low feat.

SG is an obvious spoof.

Originally posted by carver9
So why are you using movies that aren't canon to the anime or the manga and how powerful was garlick junior during that time?
HAHA If you really had watched the german version you would know that this was from the show and not a movie haw-som

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Its not a movie. Its episodes in the anime that are filler. As far how powerful he was...well he should have been stomped with ease. I mean he was immortal but Krillian,Gohan, or piccolo all should have soloed him with ease. He was fighting a good fight with pre sayian saga Goku and piccolo.

And she beat galactus. By feats she should stomp him. Being beaten by SG isn't a low feat.

Again I ask, how powerful was garlic junior? What was his power level? If you use common sense you would of known that he reach their power level or was close to it. Then let's not even include the fact that piccolo was beating the hell out of him until something happened to kami which weakened him.

She has human stats.. that's a low showing for thanos... no matter how you put it... she isn't a dbz character (even though I know that squirrell girl have no rights at beating thanos, ist happened).

Originally posted by Black bolt z
And she beat galactus.

She didn't. Just because some writer made a joke in the freakin interview doesn't mean anything.

Originally posted by illadelph12
SG is an obvious spoof.
to some.....

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
She didn't. Just because some writer made a joke in the freakin interview doesn't mean anything.
Would it be a suprise for you if she actually did?

Originally posted by Parmaniac
Would it be a suprise for you if she actually did?

Of course not, but she has yet to do that.

Originally posted by jinzin
AS FOR YOU! 😠

I saw what you said back...... there..... and I WILL have vengance.... Oh I will.

heh. never had a doubt. and happy new year. just wish i knew something about vegetables so i could contribute in this thread instead of just trolling it. 😐

Originally posted by Philosophía
You don't understand what the analogy was meant to say - my problem with your argument is that you're from the start categorizing all fruits as growing in the trees (ie. all statements are invalid/hyperboles) because apples grow in trees and are fruits (ie. cyclops destroying a planet or sentry stalemating galactus are invalid/hyperbolic statements). And that's illogical.

No, I understood it quite well. It's possible you didn't understand me though.

I don't think unsupported claims(ie. Cyclops busting a planet) are the same as supported claims (ie. some fruits not growing on trees).

Originally posted by -Pr-
Leave Cyclops alone dammit.

😂
Originally posted by illadelph12
I think it could be epic, however, that's assuming that people actually debate the fight rather than debating how to debate the fight.

I've been saying this since before I even said it; however, I think it's more a problem with DBZ threads specifically than anime in general.

Admittedly, I contribute to it though. 🙁

Nah, even in the Bleach thread peeps were waxing poetic on how to interpret what was happening on screen and whether to use the cartoon or the manga version.

Plus Wonder Woman can solo the whole universe.

Originally posted by illadelph12
Nah, even in the Bleach thread peeps were waxing poetic on how to interpret what was happening on screen and whether to use the cartoon or the manga version.

Plus Wonder Woman can solo the whole universe.

😂

Classic stuff

Originally posted by illadelph12
Nah, even in the Bleach thread peeps were waxing poetic on how to interpret what was happening on screen and whether to use the cartoon or the manga version.

Plus Wonder Woman can solo the whole universe.


In hindsight, I worded that extremely poorly; I don't mean to say it's exclusive to DBZ threads. I think it's easier to reach general consensus on "non-quantifiable" feats in most other anime though. It will still be contested of course.