Originally posted by dmills
[B]if that's the case, and indeed it hasn't been retconned, then that's game, set, match. If Dr. Light controls photons and can effect a GL energy ring, Quasar should be able to do the same since photons are basic units within the EM spectrum. So draining the ring is possible, or at the very least, manipulating its energy is.
See the Caveat?[/quote]
But that wasn't the case, and nothing was ever retconned, and no evidence was ever provided to indicate that it was.
Not just me. Iirc there are at least 3 others that shared that opinion and 1 that was open to the idea. So far you're the only one arguing against it. Or at least the most the most vigorous.
Three others? I see one other, all with nova or quasar in their sigs and/or Avatar. And there is someone else who seems to be backing me up at every turn, and another who is randomly vouching for me.
None of that matters, though, because right is right regardless of public perception.
And again, the argument was that Dr. Light controls the "Light aspect" of the energies, not nessecarily the energies themselves per se. So if that's the case, then it doesn't matter if it's a magical lightning bolt, or any other energy for that matter, if it gives off light then he can manipulate it. And since light (photons) is apart of the EM spectrum, and Dr. Light supposedly in the past has manipulated GL energy, then it's at least fair to conclude Quasar has a reasonable chance of replicating that. I don't see what's so hard to understand about that. Obviously there's some ambiguity there, but I just don't see this "majority of evidence" that you speak of. You're the GL expert so surely you can provide it no?
I understand the argument, but the argument is MOOT. Dr. Light was INCAPABLE of controling the Green Lantern energies until AFTER he had become trapped in Hal's battery for comic book months/years, and his ability to control energy has already proven itself to be greater than that of Quasar in breadth.
Dr. Light once being able to control Kyle's energy (and I stress once, in GL 3D, because he was INCAPABLE of doing so without the aid of the Worlogog when they later met) means nothing in regards to Quasar's ability to control that same energy. We've seen him unable to control psionic energies, which give off light components, and Dark Matter energies, which cast a glow, and other-dimensional energies, which have a light component, and magical energies, which have a light component.
Originally posted by zopzopDead issue bro. That's already been clearly established.
For those who missed it :Uploaded with ImageShack.us
Q-bands have NO control over non EM energies.
On another note, check your PM box when you get a chance bro. Thanks.
Originally posted by Desaad👆 Well if all that's true then that puts a serious wet blanket on that argument. Thanks for providing some context.But that wasn't the case, and nothing was ever retconned, and no evidence was ever provided to indicate that it was.
Three others? I see one other, all with nova or quasar in their sigs and/or Avatar. And there is someone else who seems to be backing me up at every turn, and another who is randomly vouching for me.
None of that matters, though, because right is right regardless of public perception.
I understand the argument, but the argument is MOOT. Dr. Light was INCAPABLE of controling the Green Lantern energies until AFTER he had become trapped in Hal's battery for comic book months/years, and his ability to control energy has already proven itself to be greater than that of Quasar in breadth.
Dr. Light once being able to control Kyle's energy (and I stress once, in GL 3D, because he was INCAPABLE of doing so without the aid of the Worlogog when they later met) means nothing in regards to Quasar's ability to control that same energy. We've seen him unable to control psionic energies, which give off light components, and Dark Matter energies, which cast a glow, and other-dimensional energies, which have a light component, and magical energies, which have a light component. [/B]
Edit: Did you get a chance to read that pm I sent to you?
Originally posted by celeyhyga17HAHAHA! Yeah that did kinda get lost in the shuffle huh?
btw this is a GL/MM vs. Q/NP thread. not a 1v1 so there are a lot of other factors involved.
Oh and BTW, apparently you and I can't have an unbiased opinion since we both have NP sigs and avatars! How cool is that!!!!
Originally posted by dmills
HAHAHA! Yeah that did kinda get lost in the shuffle huh?Oh and BTW, apparently you and I can't have an unbiased opinion since we both have NP sigs and avatars! How cool is that!!!!
i guess anyone with a name/sig/avatar based on characters cant have an unbiased opinion eh?
😉
