Bronze Tiger vs Steve Rogers: H2H Only

Started by Marvelknight31 pages

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
to be fair you are fairly ignorant, to the point were you think reading 200 batman comics makes you the end all be all of bat knowledge did not help your case.

Honestly please explain to me your argument for why Bronze tiger wins. In fact can anyone explain to me why they are giving him the win? I love to see the reasoning.

Do you even know "which" Batman comics that I have before addressing me? I think not. I have every important major story arch from Year one to Batman Incorporated. I also read JLA, Robin, Red Robin, Nightwing, Batgirl, Outsiders, and Birds of Pray. So yeah I don't think it's ignorant to think that I at the very least, I have an all around understanding of who Bruce is as a character and the people he surrounds himself with.

I seen Bruce in all kinds of situations, and how he deals with them. I can tell you that Bruce is a genius, and highly efficient in advance science, biology, forensic science, criminology, and martial arts. He's very focus and determined. At times he can be over confident in his own abilities and be caught in bad situations. But he's always show that he has the "know how" to get out of them. He can be condescending towards his peers at times, but at the same time, he respect them.

Bruce has a deep compassion for the safety and betterment of his fellow man, with the will and dedication to strive for his own perfection as a man, for the safety and betterment of all mankind. So make sure you know your facts before addressing me again regarding what I know about Batman. Well I just broke it down for you. Now tell me that I don't know who Batman is... I didn't think so.

Under what basis do people believe Bronze Tiger can take Steve in this fight?

Originally posted by Deadline
First of all I'm quite sure blindsided means that when the person attacks you can't see them coming. Thats not true because DS was looking straight at BT.

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/53838/1331023-deathstroke_vs_bronze_tiger_1_super.jpg

How can he be blindsided if DS is looking straight at him and there is a noise when the window smashes? You can argue he was suprised but there are several pages of him fighting when hes not suprised thats the point.

No "the point" was that this fight was SUPPOSED to prove something about Bronze Tiger and his fighting ability being > Steve.

The point becomes skewed when multitudes of other circumstances become involved that contribute to the fight beyond the two fighters themselves.

Now you may think that since Deathstroke turned his head towards BT immediately before being kicked in the face, that he wasn't blindsided, but that would make you wrong, AS USUAL.

Regardless of DS' ability to turn his head towards the sounds of a crashing window, he was CLEARLY not ready for the fight when it kicked off.
Bronze Tiger landed two blows that he otherwise would not have been guaranteed in a straight up confrontation.

That right there should tell you that this fight was nowhere near 100% proof of what a real fight between BT and DS would be.

Originally posted by Deadline
The reason why he was hurt was because BT kicked him in the chest. We then see BT holding his chest, therefore the reason why DS was hurt was because BT kicked him in the chest.

He had time to recover and was healed by the time the fight started.


😂

🙄

Like I said, I'm talking to the guy who ignored the entire premise of the origins and endings arc, it makes sense that you would disard the same exact kind of context here.

No.... He wasn't holding his chest... I guess YOU could try and argue that, but it doesn't make any sense AS USUAL.
The panel you're reffering to (I think) has one hand hovering above his chest maybe, but he's not grabbing his chest in pain.

Lets look at the panels of the fight.
First attack lands flush in Deathstroke's face, BT's entire body weight and momentum being commited to the attack. The effects of the attack send DS towards the floor, THROUGH a desk and leaving him no recourse to counter.
Second attack BT lands is a spinning back kick, BT's body leaning away from the kick robbing him of his total power and the kick's actually landing under his pectorals. The effects of the attack send DS back the other way, but he's able to grab the kick before Tiger's brought the kick back to chamber, launching BT through the air for his troubles and engages in banter.
Third attack BT lands is a mule kick to Deathstroke's back sending DS sprawling forward arms flailing in the air.

SO: You think Deathstroke was holding his chest, which was why BT made the comment towards DS being hurt.... Great....

Except for the fact that Deathstroke was never hit IN the chest... at all. The only panel that COULD be misconstrued as Slade holding his chest has a single hand hovering over his pectoral major where BT never landed an attack.... AND even if you wanted to continue to argue that he was holding his chest due to being kicked in the ****ing solar plexus and we were going to throw you that bone..... it STILL wouldn't make any sense! I'm supposed to believe the attack that had the worst residual effects on Slade was the ONLY attack that he reacted to, countered, and talked back during? WHA?! Why wasn't he "holding" his face? Or his back?

Maybe because he wasn't holding anything in pain during that fight?

And again this nonsense about "well he had time to heal"... Deadline stop this trolling bullshit right now. You know VERY well how healing factors are typically depicted in comics. They get taxed, their user gets taxed. It's not some mystery or left up to open ended loads of debate.

Wilson flat out states that he's staggering his way into the museum..... So what's your take now?
He has a healing factor that can compensate for being shot, blown up, tortured, and gassed in a matter of hours with NO residual affects, BUT that he couldn't recover from several MA kicks even though he's wearing armor and would be worse off in a game of cat and mouse than BT even though DS has superhuman stats across the board and BT is bleeding?

Again, it makes no sense. Like....... AT ALL. 😐

Originally posted by Deadline
I'm not arguing that BT was trying to kill him, I'm arguing that if BT took him they would have killed DS. DS stated that:

"I was set up the Government's got to know it."

Doesn't that indicate that he thought that the Government knew hes wasn't guilty?

"They don't want me alive."

Whose they? He's obvoulsy refering to the Government. The Govt want him dead as well and they know hes been set up.

"They were never going to let you take me in. They need me dead."

What people want BT to take DS in? The Govt so the 'they' is obvoulsy the Govt.

Look at 11 and 12

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/53838/1331033-deathstroke_vs_bronze_tiger_11_super.jpg

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/53838/1331034-deathstroke_vs_bronze_tiger_12_super.jpg

BT: They wanted me to bring him in.
DS: Turner, you believe that, then you're the madman

Which is what DS was trying to say all along. The Govt did not want BT to bring him in alive, it was a front. The Govt knew he was set up as well and if was brought in a captured he would have got killed.

Deathstroke knew that he was in trouble with the government, that much is obvious. Which is why I stated that his presumptions were based on the people who were coming after him and how they were doing it.

It doesn't mean he was going all out on someone he respected and needed. He wasn't.

Just because he didn't want to be taken in doesn't mean he was doing everything he could to put Bronze Tiger down... Again, he was more occupied with trying to run away than to stand and fight.

Originally posted by Deadline
If you're going to be rude and insulting at least get my argument correct. Heres what I said.

Or it means that you're desperate.
It doesn't automatically dictate that DS was willing to seriously hurt Tiger, since y'know he tried to keep BT from serious harm... 😐

Say what you will, and I really don't care much about your personal vendetta, it isn't a good example of BT's prowess and that much is clear to nearly anyone who's read the book or even glanced at it really.

If you want to make arguments for his prowess in combat choose better examples than this one. As someone already mentioned, this fight's well contested from about 5 different positions now.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Under what basis do people believe Bronze Tiger can take Steve in this fight?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methamphetamine

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methamphetamine

Anything resembling an actual, appropriate answer?

Originally posted by -Pr-
Under what basis do people believe Bronze Tiger can take Steve in this fight?

That's a good question. It's one I've been trying to get an answer for for about 20 pages now.

Maybe you'll get an answer since you're a mod or something.... we certainly didn't.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methamphetamine
😂

Originally posted by -Pr-
Under what basis do people believe Bronze Tiger can take Steve in this fight?

It could certainly be argued that BT is more skilled than Cap because he has beaten DS in h2h and Batman. It could be argued that Batman is more skilled than Cap in h2h eventhough he lack stats, and it could certainly be argued that DS > Cap.

Personally I think Steve wins the majority but certain people are in the habit of only looking at one point of view and lowballing feats.

Originally posted by Deadline
and it could certainly be argued that DS > Cap.

No more then it could be argued that Cap > DS. The better case for this verdict.

Although IMO there about as equal as it gets.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Anything resembling an actual, appropriate answer?

This one time BT fought a weakened, holding back Deathstroke and couldn't beat him.

That is the real argument for why this is a fight BTW.

-Pr- As Deadline pointed out. Bronze Tiger did defeat Bruce and rather very fast wouldn't you agree? Now take a look at Bruce and Steve's test of skill in the JLA/ Avengers crossover... Batman made it very clear that Steve could defeat him, but it would take a very "long" time to do it. Even though Bruce and Steve weren't fighting as hard as they could. Bruce saw everything Steve through his way. Now on the other hand Bronze Tiger with one feint punch, caught Bruce off guard and knocked him out within a matter of seconds.

What that shows you is that Bronze's skill was on another level all together from Bruce's. Tiger and has also taken on other meta-human (who were not weaken in any way) And held his own very well. Tiger has the "know how" in ways that he could strike Steve where it'll hurt the most ( after all he's a superb master martial artist). And it's very probable that Tiger can take whatever Steve can dish out, because he took clean blows from Slade and got right back up with no signs of being really hurt at all and he didn't tire out after what could have been 8 minutes of fighting.

Originally posted by Deadline
It could certainly be argued that BT is more skilled than Cap because he has beaten DS in h2h and Batman. It could be argued that Batman is more skilled than Cap in h2h eventhough he lack stats, and it could certainly be argued that DS > Cap.

you should have left it at that.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
This one time BT fought a weakened, holding back Deathstroke and couldn't beat him.

That is the real argument for why this is a fight BTW.

were they posted in this thread?

Originally posted by Marvelknight
-Pr- As Deadline pointed out. Bronze Tiger did defeat Bruce and rather very fast wouldn't you agree? Now take a look at Bruce and Steve test of skill in JLA/ Avengers crossover... Batman made it very clear that Steve could defeat him, but it would take a very "long" time to do it. Even though Bruce and Steve weren't fighting as hard as they could. Bruce saw everything Steve through his way. Now the other hand Bronze Tiger in a feint punch caught Bruce out guard and knock him out within a matter of seconds.

What that shows you is that Bronze's skill was on another level all together from Bruce's. Tiger and has also taken on other meta-human (who were not weaken in any way) And held his own very well. Tiger has the "know how" in ways that he could strike Steve where it'll hurt the most ( after all he's a superb master martial artist). And it's very probable that tiger can take whatever Steve can dish out, because he took clean blows from Slade and got right back up with no signs of being really hurt at all.

jla/avengers isn't valid on this forum.

what fight with bruce are you referencing?

Originally posted by -Pr-
you should have left it at that.

were they posted in this thread?

jla/avengers isn't valid on this forum.

what fight with bruce are you referencing?

I'm talking about Bronze Tiger and Batman's first encounter.

And that JLA/Avengers crossover is canon.

Originally posted by Marvelknight
I'm talking about Bronze Tiger and Batman's first encounter.

And that JLA/Avengers crossover is canon.

What issue was it in?

It might be canon, but it's in the rules that we don't use it on the forum.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
This one time BT fought a weakened, holding back Deathstroke and couldn't beat him.

That is the real argument for why this is a fight BTW.

thumbsup

Originally posted by -Pr-
What issue was it in?

It might be canon, but it's in the rules that we don't use it on the forum.

It's Detective Comics # 485.

Well in this case the rule makes a very important piece of info unusable.

I've always viewed Batman as more skilled than Cap but Cap has the stats over Bats.

Originally posted by Marvelknight
It's Detective Comics # 485.

Well in this case the rule makes a very important piece of info unusable.

i'll check it out.

narration is the only set in stone speech outside of feats that we use to determine skill. what comes out of the character's mouth is rarely usable unless there's evidence to back it up.

bruce saying that steve is his equal or superior/inferior really has no bearing on this fight, seeing as bruce and steve have barely encountered one another.

JLA/Avengers crossover is DC canon as it has been referenced outside of the crossover, but not Marvel Canon. Essentially Batman stalemated fought to a stalemate with an alternate version of Captain America, and as of little relevance to a debate concerning the real one. At most it is a What If, as far as Marvel is concerned.

Isn't Marvel vs DC considered cannon for DC also?