Originally posted by Silent Master
You haven't proven that Gorgon's TP is good enough to get past Thor's resistance, nor have you proven that he's fast enough to cover the starting distance before Thor can hit the ground.Which means that there is zero reason for me to humor you.
Wolverine has better TP resistance that Thor, he's no sold Emma Frost.
Originally posted by Silent Master
On the other hand, Mr X was able to read him just fine.
Mr. X's body automatically locks on to the neural impulses of anyone in range, in conjunction with low level telepathy. Two different powers working towards the same goal. TP resistance works largely on telepathic attacks / suggestions, only a handful of characters (like Bishop and Fantomex) are immune or resistant to mind reading and telepathic communication. People like Gorgon and X can't mind rap, they just gleam intentions off the surface.
Originally posted by Silent Master
Then Wolverine's general TP resistance doesn't prove anything in regards to Grogon's level of TP.In which case, you have to prove that Gorgon's style of TP would work on Thor.
TP resistance in general doesn't work on Gorgon's type of TP.
Prove that it wouldn't. Provide a single piece of evidence that even eludes to the fact that Gorgon would be unable to read Thor's mind.
Originally posted by Silent Master
You haven't proven that Gorgon's TP is good enough to get past Thor's resistance, nor have you proven that he's fast enough to cover the starting distance before Thor can hit the ground.Which means that there is zero reason for me to humor you.
i proved that gorgon can penetrate the mind of a telepath and i say he can penetrate thor mind, now its your job to prove that thor is more telepathically resistant than wolverine who profesor x and emma frost had trouble with and that thor can supress a telepath something gorgon accomplished so unless you prove it the point is simple gorgon will penetrate thors mind and use telepathy to read his mind and know any move he is about to make
i showed feats of gorgon being too fast for a speedster its up to you to prove that thor is at the same league and only then we will have something to debate about until then gorgon is blitzing thor
stop going circles with me you see that you HAVE to prove things here otherwise your statements are all just a pile of nothing
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
TP resistance in general doesn't work on Gorgon's type of TP.Prove that it wouldn't. Provide a single piece of evidence that even eludes to the fact that Gorgon would be able to read Thor's mind.
srank i thinkthis guy is either playing and joking with us or this is the most pathetic attempt at debating i ever saw just repeating "prove this and prove that" and after you prove it he will still say no you didnt, prove it again with another showing i dont like that one
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
TP resistance in general doesn't work on Gorgon's type of TP.Prove that it wouldn't. Provide a single piece of evidence that even eludes to the fact that Gorgon would be able to read Thor's mind.
That isn't the way it works, you're claiming that he will be able to read Thor, that means the burden is on you.
At most, all I'd have to do is give a reason that Gorgon's ability might not work on Thor, which I can easily do by pointing out that Thor is a completely different species.
Originally posted by Silent Master
That isn't the way it works, you're claiming that he will be able to read Thor, that means the burden is on you.At most, all I'd have to do is give a reason that Gorgon's ability might not work on Thor, which I can easily do by pointing out that Thor is a completely different species.
prove that mind reading doesnt work on thor like it works on anybody else, prove that thor is more resistant to telepathy than a freakin telepath
Originally posted by Silent Master
That isn't the way it works, you're claiming that he will be able to read Thor, that means the burden is on you.At most, all I'd have to do is give a reason that Gorgon's ability might not work on Thor, which I can easily do by pointing out that Thor is a completely different species.
IOW, you have no proof.
Originally posted by Silent Master
It's not my job to disprove your claims, it's your job to back up any claims that you make.
Soooooooo it's my job to disprove your claims?
Dude you're a troll, plain and simple. You are arbitrarily attributing Thor with immunity to powers he has never displayed on panel, merely because he is an Asgardian... and then asking people to prove your wrong? No one needs to prove you wrong, you need to prove that Thor has those abilities in the first place. Stating that "Well... he's different... so maybe he has like different immunities... you know?" Isn't enough.
Thor has been effected by mind control several times. He has hand his mind read dozens of times. Why would Gorgon be unable to do it? Because Wolverine isn't Thor? Pull your head out of your ass and come up with a legitimate argument. Wolverine has better telepathic resistance than Thor. Gorgon read his mind. Elektra has better telepathic resistance than Thor and is a telepath her self. Gorgon read her mind.
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Soooooooo it's my job to disprove your claims?Dude you're a troll, plain and simple. You are arbitrarily attributing Thor with immunity to powers he has never displayed on panel, merely because he is an Asgardian... and then asking people to prove your wrong? No one needs to prove you wrong, you need to prove that Thor has those abilities in the first place. Stating that "Well... he's different... so maybe he has like different immunities... you know?" Isn't enough.
Thor has been effected by mind controlled. He has hand his mind read. Why would Gorgon be unable to do it? Because Wolverine isn't Thor? Pull your head out of your ass and come up with a legitimate argument. Wolverine has better telepathic resistance than Thor. Gorgon read his mind. Elektra has better telepathic resistance than Thor and is a telepath her self. Gorgon read her mind.
Gorgon's level of mind reading and the way it works are different then the types that have been shown working on Thor, therefore you have the burden of proving it will work.
That is the way debates work.
As much as I usually disagree with most of what Skank says... Silent Disaster is worse. He never takes a stance and always ask for proof of stuff that doesn't need proving. Or he'll make statements that have nothing to do with anything being debated.. and you call him on those pointless statements to back them up.. and he goes.. nah.. I don't need to.. somehow the burden gets shifted to you every single time when arguing with him. Soon I'm sure he'll be banned for trolling and providing nothing useful to the forum
Originally posted by Silent Master
Gorgon's level of mind reading and the way it works are different then the types that have been shown working on Thor, therefore you have the burden of proving it will work.That is the way debates work.
its different types of telepathy but it is telepathy that is the same base which is penetrating the mind of the person and read it control it or what ever but its the same base which is penetrate it, thor was mind controlled before which proves us that his mind can be penetrated and controlled, gorgon was able to penetrate a mind of another telepath so you want to tell me thors mind which was penetrated already is more resistant than a mind of an actual telepath? and you want us to believe all that without any proof??? GTFO