I would imagine inferring infinite weight from an object only said to have "infinite pages" is sort of putting too much real world science into a comic. For instance, an object with infinite mass also has infinite gravity, and the book didn't collpse the universe into itself... or did it? I guess I'm not familiar with the feat
Originally posted by inimalist
I would imagine inferring infinite weight from an object only said to have "infinite pages" is sort of putting too much real world science into a comic. For instance, an object with infinite mass also has infinite gravity, and the book didn't collpse the universe into itself... or did it? I guess I'm not familiar with the feat
For example...Flash's IMP.
Originally posted by zopzopIs juggernaut unstoppable? Is Odin omnipotent?
Yes it is. Since he lifted (let's say half for the sake of argument) half of an INFINITE weight. The level of power required to do that is insane. An object with no limit to it's weight was lifted by him and CM.
Its called a hyperbole.
And its still unquantifiable. Because if it only takes superman level strength then thor could lift it, hulk could, sentry could. A lot of people could.
Originally posted by Galan007a mod should have closed the thread after this, cause that's the answer he's looking for
Simply put: the character in question would need to have Superman-level feats.
everyone quote it and have a nice day
Originally posted by zopzopit's funny how a magician found a way to circumvent the need for a neverending series of books by putting all the entries into a magical tome, but somehow managed to phuck up the weight issue. go figure
Fine. Alternate reality versions of characters feats don't count toward the mainline versions. Superman STILL lifted 1/2 an infinite weight, that's abstract level power right there.
ultimate hulk could probably lift the book also though mmm
Originally posted by inimalist
I would imagine inferring infinite weight from an object only said to have "infinite pages" is sort of putting too much real world science into a comic. For instance, an object with infinite mass also has infinite gravity, and the book didn't collpse the universe into itself... or did it? I guess I'm not familiar with the feat
There's scans in this very thread of Thor being bombarded with "neutron star" level gravity yet the planet he's fighting on doesn't collapse. The hydrogen and other gases in the atmosphere didn't condense into liquids/solids because of the intense gravity etc.... Why nit pick this feat but not that?
It's a comic book, it doesn't have to make sense.
Originally posted by psycho gundam
a mod should have closed the thread after this, cause that's the answer he's looking foreveryone quote it and have a nice day
it's funny how a magician found a way to circumvent the need for a neverending series of books by putting all the entries into a magical tome, but somehow managed to phuck up the weight issue. go figure
ultimate hulk could probably lift the book also though mmm
You got an on panel feat of anyone doing anything comparable to lifting "half" of an infinite weight? I'm genuinely interested.
Originally posted by Black bolt z
Is juggernaut unstoppable? Is Odin omnipotent?Its called a hyperbole.
And its still unquantifiable. Because if it only takes superman level strength then thor could lift it, hulk could, sentry could. A lot of people could.
Post scans of them lifting half an infinite weight and you'll have a point. Till then, I'm just gonna ignore your posts.
Originally posted by Black bolt z
I'll check tomorrow.I'm pretty sure its always just said infinite knowledge but my memory is sketchy.
If it says "knowledge", you are 100% right, lifting it means nothing. But the rabid Superman fanboys latched on to this feat and are milking it for everything it's worth. Plus why would Superman AND Captain Marvel strain to lift a book of infinite 'knowledge'? Why would the Superman fanboys drool over this feat?
Originally posted by zopzopNot entirely sure they were straining.
If it says "knowledge", you are 100% right, lifting it means nothing. But the rabid Superman fanboys latched on to this feat and are milking it for everything it's worth. Plus why would Superman AND Captain Marvel strain to lift a book of infinite 'knowledge'? Why would the Superman fanboys drool over this feat?
I mean Ultraman seemed to lift it with no problem. And in the exact same two issue series superman and Ultraman would depicted to be 100% equals.
Originally posted by zopzopso what, it's a comic after all.
It had an INFINITE amount of pages. You do the math.
if you tried doing the math, you'd have to factor in ultraman getting tooled by superman, the same guy who would have to be half as physically powerful as he is (assuming the book was level). i guess superman and captain marvel didn't eat their wheaties that morning