Who's stronger Juggernaut or Hercules

Started by carver98 pages
Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
Because he is from Marvel like Herc and the benchmark of strength like Thor.

Hulk is the benchmark of strength, period. Stop hating on him. You have a habit of bringing him up in threads he doesn't belong in.

Originally posted by krisblaze
What is Abhi and Cely debating?

Because celey has this habit of bringing up random Thor feats in threads where they don't belong.

I asked what.

Originally posted by abhilegend
So just going to ignore everything? Sure thing bro.
Ignore what? Hey I'm not the one grasping at straws here. I even showed actual MU index reference, but it seems you put blinders on and just keep yapping nonsense.

Originally posted by abhilegend

Why the double standards? Both are canon after all. But yeah, joke story is a joke story.
Double standards? You funny man. Do you see me disputing your scan? You fail to understand my point. You are using a character for comparison who is known to have extremely wacky and joky feats. Think about it for a sec and let it sink in.

Originally posted by abhilegend

Because its not meant to be taken seriously? Under the same writer a few issues later, Thor and hercules struggled to lift a few cars they were trapped under. I don't think DeFalco was writing Thor/Hercules to be planetary level in any of his comics.
Yeah, silver age hyperbole is great. Your point is?

Wow so you downplay the feat with a lowball? Why am I not surprised? Do you even understand the concept of high end feats, averages, and regular portrayals? You really, truly fail. Oh and the 90's is now silver age? Smh....

But about this lowball.. At least get your facts straight first. You choose one that had them fighting an amped Ulik(who consequently got ko'd after getting electrocuted while falling from a building... go figure). Let's not forget Herc was being written weak at that period in time because of loss of confidence. Lastly it wasn't a few cars. It was described as "a collapsing mountain of twisted metal". In your drive to lowball, you lowballed a lowball. That's pretty pathetic. Again, I'm not surprised.

Originally posted by abhilegend

No, he doesn't.
Right.....

Originally posted by abhilegend

Have you even read the comics you are randomly posting scans from? I guess not.

You really should ask yourself this.. 🙁

Originally posted by abhilegend
Because celey has this habit of bringing up random Thor feats in threads where they don't belong.

Erm.. Did you look at the title of this thread? It's a Herc and Juggs, strength comparison. I brought up 2 high end feats that involve Herc. You're the one who came in crying foul just because of anal pain seizures. And we all know the reason..

Keep embarrassing yourself. Go ahead...

Love Herc...

^The fight where he fights Thor and lifts Manhatten was just a joke story/hyperbole he told some children to impress them, it never happened.

IIRC

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
^The fight where he fights Thor and lifts Manhatten was just a joke story/hyperbole he told some children to impress them, it never happened.

IIRC

It Is a story but I thought It was a true story?

Hercules and Thor are fictional 😕

Originally posted by carver9
It Is a story but I thought It was a true story?

He was boasting to children who wanted to know who is stronger, he or Thor

You should take it as seriously as this part of the story.

IOW, his boasting worked 😈

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
He was boasting to children who wanted to know who is stronger, he or Thor
http://13thdimension.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/9g-thor356.jpg

You should take it as seriously as this part of the story.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v71/thecorpulent1/Thor/Thor_1985_356_09.jpg

👆

Thanks

Originally posted by carver9
👆

Thanks

You are welcome bro 🙂.

I'm actually in agreement with Abhi on the "arm wrestling" issue. It was hyperbole. Ditto that other "shatter worlds" comment.

In terms of QUANTIFIABLE feats, Hercules clearly wins though. Towing Manhattan and later, during the WWH arc, holding it together clearly trump anything Juggernaut has done in terms of strength feats.

Originally posted by zopzop
I'm actually in agreement with Abhi on the "arm wrestling" issue. It was hyperbole. Ditto that other "shatter worlds" comment.

In terms of QUANTIFIABLE feats, Hercules clearly wins though. Towing Manhattan and later, during the WWH arc, holding it together clearly trump anything Juggernaut has done in terms of strength feats.


Sure if your dislike of a character is so high you would be willing to disregard what's on panel.

Also you're the same guy who thinks the shattering of worlds in GoT was hyperbole. 🙁

Why am am I not surprised?

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Ignore what? Hey I'm not the one grasping at straws here. I even showed actual MU index reference, but it seems you put blinders on and just keep yapping nonsense.
MU index? What?

It specifically states that they only shattered the plateau. Good job destroying your own argument.

Double standards? You funny man. Do you see me disputing your scan? You fail to understand my point. You are using a character for comparison who is known to have extremely wacky and joky feats. Think about it for a sec and let it sink in.
So does that story which was played for laughs.

Wow so you downplay the feat with a lowball? Why am I not surprised? Do you even understand the concept of high end feats, averages, and regular portrayals? You really, truly fail. Oh and the 90's is now silver age? Smh....
Oh the hilarity. The marvel index already busted your claim.

But about this lowball.. At least get your facts straight first. You choose one that had them fighting an amped Ulik(who consequently got ko'd after getting electrocuted while falling from a building... go figure). Let's not forget Herc was being written weak at that period in time because of loss of confidence. Lastly it wasn't a few cars. It was described as "a collapsing mountain of twisted metal". In your drive to lowball, you lowballed a lowball. That's pretty pathetic. Again, I'm not surprised.
Right.....
Getting so defensive. On panel it was shown as some cars which Ulik threw at thor. But as usual you can't separate fact from hyperbole and somehow cars can make mountains of metal. Go figure.

You really should ask yourself this.. 🙁
I actually read the comics, not just take whatever the writer throws at the page.

Erm.. Did you look at the title of this thread? It's a Herc and Juggs, strength comparison. I brought up 2 high end feats that involve Herc. You're the one who came in crying foul just because of anal pain seizures. And we all know the reason..
Which means jack shit in terms of comparison of strength.

Keep embarrassing yourself. Go ahead...
Like you posting a scan which destroys your own argument?

Originally posted by abhilegend
MU index? What?

http://i1238.photobucket.com/albums/ff492/twinzeeto/More%20Thor/av60_zps07e9a0c4.jpg~original

It specifically states that they only shattered the plateau. Good job destroying your own argument.


Are you serious or are you just purposely being dense?
facepalm
Do you know what a synopsis is? Do you think a synopsis contains every detail of a story? Like how in the 4th story of this issue Loki escapes the dungeon by hypnotizing the guards... Or how he killed Eldred by tricking him into summoning Surtur?
That's why it's called a brief summary. You're so dead set on refuting this feat you begin to start losing all forms of cognitive thinking. I'm starting to think this feat is too much for you to bear. As if your world would come crashing down.. 🙁

Originally posted by abhilegend

So does that story which was played for laughs.

So no actual useful reply. Concession accepted.

Originally posted by abhilegend

Oh the hilarity. The marvel index already busted your claim.
Read above.

Originally posted by abhilegend

Getting so defensive. On panel it was shown as some cars which Ulik threw at thor. But as usual you can't separate fact from hyperbole and somehow cars can make mountains of metal. Go figure.
No. Tide was turned at one point. Actually Thor started beating the utter shiet on an amped Ulik(dynamic strength and all 😛 )until Herc waltzes in thinking he could help. He interrupts the beating, gets tossed like a ragdoll onto an area with many vehicles that start to collapse on him. Thor immediately shields Herc from the "mountain of twisted metal". Ulik did not throw a single car let alone a few. And here I thought you read the story. 🙁

Originally posted by abhilegend

I actually read the comics, not just take whatever the writer throws at the page.

Apparently you don't. And even if you do, you'd just butcher it anyway. And to suit your own agenda. 🙁

Originally posted by abhilegend

Which means jack shit in terms of comparison of strength.
Why would the two feats I brought up for Herc mean jack shiet? Why do you care so much about it? Butthurt much?

Originally posted by abhilegend

Like you posting a scan which destroys your own argument?

facepalm

To me this topic is pretty easy to figure out... Hercules is obviously stronger based on lifting feats, but that is to be expected, he's a hero after all. Bad guys don't have lift a mountain to saves lives.. they are the one causing the shit the heroes need to counter to save lives. So in Juggs case we can simply look at how's he's done against similar people and who's performed better. To me it's quite clear with his showings against various versions of Hulk, that Juggs is stronger. Maybe not a whole lot, but he's certainly performed better. That is enough for me to say he's above Hercules.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Are you serious or are you just purposely being dense?
facepalm
Do you know what a synopsis is? Do you think a synopsis contains every detail of a story? Like how in the 4th story of this issue Loki escapes the dungeon by hypnotizing the guards... Or how he killed Eldred by tricking him into summoning Surtur?
Considering it specifically mentioned the plateau breaking and discarded the hyperbole? Yes.

That's why it's called a brief summary. You're so dead set on refuting this feat you begin to start losing all forms of cognitive thinking. I'm starting to think this feat is too much for you to bear. As if your world would come crashing down.. 🙁
Yeah, you are just rambling now. Good job though, you destroyed the whole argument by yourself.

So no actual useful reply. Concession accepted.

Read above.

Quan, is that you?

No. Tide was turned at one point. Actually Thor started beating the utter shiet on an amped Ulik(dynamic strength and all 😛 )until Herc waltzes in thinking he could help. He interrupts the beating, gets tossed like a ragdoll onto an area with many vehicles that start to collapse on him. Thor immediately shields Herc from the "mountain of twisted metal". Ulik did not throw a single car let alone a few. And here I thought you read the story. 🙁

And few cars in a garage created a mountain in the middle of the city when even the most it was shown was not even a building level? Do you know how to look at a comic and not get carried away by narration? I can post a dozen such hyperbolic comments here, even flash has been stated to throw a punch which could alter the orbit of a planet. Not at speed, just standing and throwing a punch.

Apparently you don't. And even if you do, you'd just butcher it anyway. And to suit your own agenda. 🙁

And you'd butcher any common sense for wanting Thor just like you are doing here.

Why would the two feats I brought up for Herc mean jack shiet? Why do you care so much about it? Butthurt much?
Because random hyperbolic feats don't count and fights between characters shows the true strength level?

facepalm

Don't start crying now.