ROTS Obi-Wan Kenobi vs Darth Maul.

They fight in the same location as the Phantom Menace fight.

Maul isn't screwing around this time.

Kenobi.

Ditto.

I take it this is TPM Maul..

In that case Kenobi wins with difficulty.

But Im betting CW Maul will return considerably more powerful than CW/ROTS Obi-Wan.

Originally posted by Nephthys
They fight in the same location as the Phantom Menace fight.

Maul isn't screwing around this time.

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
Kenobi wins with GREAT difficulty after a very prolonged duel (ala his duel w/ Vader on Mustafar).

Originally posted by ares834
No... not at all.

Yes... yes to all.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
I take it this is TPM Maul..

In that case Kenobi wins with difficulty.

But Im betting CW Maul will return considerably more powerful than CW/ROTS Obi-Wan.

So Maul can defeat Qui-Gon and Young kenobi but his superior cannot?

Innnnnteresting......*

*

Spoiler:
yes this is why I made the thead.

Anakin is one of the mightiest Jedi of all time. What has Maul done that puts him anywhere in his league?

Originally posted by ares834
Anakin is one of the mightiest Jedi of all time. What has Maul done that puts him anywhere in his league?

Maul is one of the deadliest Sith of all time.

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
Maul is one of the deadliest Sith of all time.

And what has he done that gives him this position.

Theres a quote that states it.

I think the quote used Sith apprentice rather than Sith... However I still fail to see how that puts him in Anakin's league who has considerably better feats.

Originally posted by Nephthys
So Maul can defeat Qui-Gon and Young kenobi but his superior cannot?

Innnnnteresting......*

*

Spoiler:
yes this is why I made the thead.

LOL I KNEW IT!!!!

If you remeber I did mention Maul had a double blade to help him fight mutiple opponents.

I doubt Maul would have lasted as long against these same 2 with just a regular lightsaber.

Originally posted by ares834
I think the quote used Sith apprentice rather than Sith... However I still fail to see how that puts him in Anakin's league who has considerably better feats.

Kenobi's no match at all for ROTS Anakin. He was able to put up such a good fight at the end because of:

1) Anakin's mental state.

2) According to the ROTS novel, and according to Nick Gillard Kenobi and Anakin both know each others moves inside out, so its difficult for either of them to get past the others defences.

As for this fight, factor in how good Maul is at hand to hand combat. His martial arts, his kicks (which would be deadlier than Ventress's kicks).

This fight has no connection to the Anakin vs Obi-Wan fight, and no one would argue Maul could beat or even match ROTS Anakin.

Obi-Wan was defending against 4 lightsabers at once. 😬

Not having a double-lightsaber isn't going to hinder him.

^

It is in this fight. If each jedi fight on opposite sides of him, (like they were against Maul at different points in the fight) I dnt see how he can defend against that.

It would at the very least make this fight A LOT harder than it was for Maul. And even though I said ROTS Obi-Wan would defeat TPM Maul, combat wise I see them in the same league.

Kenobi in seconds.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
Kenobi in seconds.

Nah, especially given that Soresu users are known for getting involved in long, drawn out battles.

JT
Nah, especially given that Soresu users are known for getting involved in long, drawn out battles.

You'll have to forgive my dark colleague: He has clung tightly to a deep-seated hatred for the first known Sith apprentice of His Imperial Majesty for years and characteristically underestimates him.

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
Nah, especially given that Soresu users are known for getting involved in long, drawn out battles.