ROTS Obi-Wan Kenobi vs Darth Maul.

Started by RagingBoner6 pages
G007
Yeah, because it, you know, took Kenobi forever to trounce Grievous in sabers.

We have reason (and when I say reason, I mean details from the ROTS novelization) to believe that Obi-Wan Kenobi was being empowered by the Force to an uncommon degree during that battle, hence his somewhat casual dominance over the general in what was otherwise a rivalry in which they seemed rather equitable in overall dueling ability.

Originally posted by RagingBoner
We have reason (and when I say reason, I mean details from the ROTS novelization) to believe that Obi-Wan Kenobi was being empowered by the Force to an uncommon degree during that battle,
You have the excerpt on hand? I'm way too lazy to look, atm.

G007
You have the excerpt on hand? I'm way too lazy to look, atm.

I have something in my hand, all right, but it's most certainly not the excerpt.

😐

Originally posted by Galan007
You have the excerpt on hand? I'm way too lazy to look, atm.

Something about him becoming a vessel of this Force or something like that.

Originally posted by RagingBoner
I have something in my hand, all right, but it's most certainly not the excerpt.

😐

😑

JT
😑

This must be the face of sexual arousal.

I'd say its more a 'oh crap somethings in ma butt' face.

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
Nah, especially given that Soresu users are known for getting involved in long, drawn out battles.
So it would take RotS Kenobi 20 minutes to kill Zett Jukasa? Having prolonged duels is a tactic used to wear down or provide opportunities against superior opponents. Nothing implies that it would take a Soresu user forever and a day to defeat someone who is vastly their superior in skills and technique.

Furthermore, even if it was a long duel, it would mostly be of Obi-Wan toying with him, ala his CW movie fight with Ventress. Hardly some desperate scrap like against Anakin.

Meant to say vastly their inferior. You cock.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
[B] Nothing implies that it would take a Soresu user forever and a day to defeat someone who is vastly their superior in skills and technique.

Assuming you mean inferior (although superior is probably right), where's your canon quote/evidence of Maul being "vastly inferior" to Kenobi in saber skill/technique?

N.
butt' face.

D... d-did you just call me... a butt face?

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
Assuming you mean inferior (although superior is probably right), where's your canon quote/evidence of Maul being "vastly inferior" to Kenobi in saber skill/technique?
Superior showings, has fought much more reputable characters, has a track record that isn't restricted purely to defeating two featless wonders then losing to a Padawan, etc.

Blax
has fought much more reputable characters,

Maul's fought Palpatine, who's a great deal more dangerous than anyone I can recall Obi-Wan raising his blade against. excellent

Dooku > Palpatine in sabers according to the infallible Sorgo.

Come at me (but not on me).

Blax
Dooku > Palpatine in sabersaccording to the infallible Sorgo.

I shan't insult or attack Sorgo (

Spoiler:
for I was rather fond of him
), but while the good Count's technical expertise very likelypossibly surpassed his that of his Master, Palpatine was substantially more powerful in the Force and that usually gives the opponent an edge; Palpatine is more dangerous, intelligent, and powerful than his elderly disciple.

So Maul's got the edge when it comes to the pinnacle of reputable opponents. excellent

Blax
Come at me (but not on me).

I believe I just did both. I will allow you to wipe your face off with the nearest available napkin, but you will keep it as a souvenir. uhuh

edited for accuracy

edited again for accuracy; Palpatine was a practitioner of Juyo, which requires that he be a master of multiple lightsaber forms, which indicates great skill.

The difference being that Kenbi didn't get his ass kicked against said reputable opponents like Maul did against Palpatine.

Originally posted by RE: Blaxican
Kenobi in seconds.

I really cant see Kenobi defeating ANY Sith Lord in seconds.

Originally posted by Nephthys
The difference being that Kenbi didn't get his ass kicked against said reputable opponents like Maul did against Palpatine.

LOL Kenobi never got his ass handed to him by Dooku??!! Even that was with Anakin at his side.

Kenobi has no feats against Dooku whatsoever.

Kenobi also got disarmed and knocked on his ass by Ventress, someone who is not even close to Dooku's league.

As ever, I'm talking about lightsaber combat.

Still no feat N.

All we have is a thought of Dooku's while he was under serious pressure from Anakin..

Oh and getting disarmed and tossed on the floor by Ventress was in Saber combat.