Starkiller and Luke versus Kun and Sidious

Neutral setting, each at their peak, etc. In the middle of the Jedi Temple.

Team 1

I hope starkiller dies a painful death before Luke mops up.

Really close match. I may be leaning towards the Sith for the beamspam, but Starkiller should never be underestimated. He's as close to Kun as Luke and Sidious are.

Honestly, split IMO.

Well, to me, I see this as:

#1 Jedi & #5 Jedi vs. #1 Sith & (likely) #3 Sith

I agree with Vorpal. Starkiller dies miserably with Luke emerging as the lone survivor.

Starkillers only #5?

1. Luke Skywalker
2. Yoda
3. Mace Windu
4. Anakin Skywalker ("Zonakin"😉
5. Galen Marek/Starkiller

I would love to add Revan as #5, but we don't know enough. I really hope the book makes him better than that overpowered unnecessary protagonist of crappy TFU.

I'd put Marek above Windu personally.

Making Starkiller the third strongest Jedi of all time is an insult to decades of Star Wars mythology. It leaves a bitter taste in my mouth to give him the honor of being in the Top 5.

I'd also put Zonakin above Windu as well. Windu vs Dooku is a good fight, but Zonakin treated the latter like a bad joke as soon as he got serious.

But yeah, despite our distaste for him, Galen Marek is incredibly powerful (also Bane, Sidious and Nihilus are above Kun as well imo. Also maybe Zannah.).

Originally posted by Korto Vos
Making Starkiller the third strongest Jedi of all time is an insult to decades of Star Wars mythology. It leaves a bitter taste in my mouth to give him the honor of being in the Top 5.

Agreed. The teaser trailer for TFU II with the budding battle on Hoth and the rampant Force mastery on behalf of Starkiller made me want to hate-vomit. I can understand movie characters having low showings simply to keep them in line with GL's vision, and accepting EU characters as overblown and exaggerated keeping in line with the canon policy of "It gets blurrier as you move away from movie canon blah blah", but the whole Force choking a battalion and then Dark Phoenix-ing them with the Force is OP.

Huh, interesting placements.

I don't see Zonakin repeating the same treatment against Windu.

Yeah, I made the Caedus vs. Kun thread to see which Sith Lord was stronger. It seems fairly even atm.

I'd rank the Sith as Sidious, Bane, Caedus, Kun, and Vader. I'd probably place Nihilus, Revan, and Tyrannus in some arrangement as the next three.

Team 1 in a curbstomp, unless you're not talking full potential.

He's not.

Originally posted by Nephthys
He's not.

Well now how do you know? Are you, like, sleeping with him or something?

Well the teams aren't the only thing 'at peak' if you know what I mean. awepedo

Naw, but 'at peak' doesn't mean hypothetical full-potential versions.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Well the teams aren't the only thing 'at peak' if you know what I mean. awepedo

I don't.

Nephthys
Naw, but 'at peak' doesn't mean hypothetical full-potential versions.

I WILL NOT ASSUME UNTIL THE MOOSE HIMSELF SPEAKS

Moose can't speak you heathen bastard.

oh