Originally posted by Lestov16
McClane is a chump in H2H and this is an undeniable fact. Keep ignoring that mcclane has struggled in h2h against far less than Zan. In dh4 he got overpowered by some chump mook and could only subdue him by shooting him in the foot. And again you have no proof the bystander in DH5 was near Van Zan or Quinn's level, so your point there is moot. Zan wins 6.5/10 because McClane has no fight scenes showing he can outmaneuver Van.
I've already listed multiple McClane fights that are better than having the advantage against an average person.