For me this all comes down to who has the better fighting style. Originally I was backing McClane with both superior fighting style and durability, but I am beginning to reconsider. And indeed, if McClane does have the sub-par fighting style (and of course, his ingenuity/luck will not play a factor in this fight), then, as quanchi said, McClane will just take a beating until he's knocked into unconsciousness. I need to see some more of McClane's fights
Originally posted by Lestov16
For me this all comes down to who has the better fighting style. Originally I was backing McClane with both superior fighting style and durability, but I am beginning to reconsider. And indeed, if McClane does have the sub-par fighting style (and of course, his ingenuity/luck will not play a factor in this fight), then, as quanchi said, McClane will just take a beating until he's knocked into unconsciousness. I need to see some more of McClane's fights
Van Zan had better fighting style? He grabbed, head-butted and push,then threw some basic punches that packed little heat.
McClane isn't a fancy fighter either, he just gets the job done.
Durability? McClane hands down, four movies worth of it.
Originally posted by Robtard
Van Zan had better fighting style? He grabbed, head-butted and push,then threw some basic punches that packed little heat.McClane isn't a fancy fighter either, he just gets the job done.
But Van Zan does too. That's why I asked for some clips of McClane in H2H. I need to compare.
Originally posted by quanchi112
In all seriousness McClane would probably be his errand boy if the two met.
That's the thing. I need to see McClane in a good H2H match. Like I said above, if McClane has sub-par fighting skills, then he will be beaten into unconsciousness because his durability will wear out eventually. If he does have the better fighting style however, added to his durability he will rock Zan's sh*t just like Zan rocked Quinn
Yes ...on an errand to beat all the guys that would quite naturally be beating the living piss out of lilly punching Van Zan...
(As seen in 'Apocalypse now' and 'Apocalypse now (redux)', errand boys, particularly ones sent to pick up the cheque, are the ones doing the ass kicking and name taking.)
....and he'd do that and then film 3 badassery packed sequels.
Originally posted by Lestov16
That's the thing. I need to see McClane in a good H2H match. Like I said above, if McClane has sub-par fighting skills, then he will be beaten into unconsciousness because his durability will wear out eventually. If he does have the better fighting style however, added to his durability he will rock Zan's sh*t just like Zan rocked Quinn
Well, how about rewatching the following movies...?
Die Hard (1988) (McClane Vs Karl)
Die Hard 2: Die Harder (1990) (McClane vs various Marines)
Die Hard with a vengence (1995) (McClane vs Lurch)
Die Hard 4.0 (2007) (McClane vs Hamster dude and Asian Chick)
Originally posted by Lestov16
That's the thing. I need to see McClane in a good H2H match. Like I said above, if McClane has sub-par fighting skills, then he will be beaten into unconsciousness because his durability will wear out eventually. If he does have the better fighting style however, added to his durability he will rock Zan's sh*t just like Zan rocked Quinn
He can fight at least as well as Van Zan, arguably better, considering he's faced off against high-end mercenaries and not average Quinn.
Another thing, look how winded Van Zan was after throwing a few hits, his stamina is shit. So he's got average fighting skills, cotton-fist and shit stamina. That's not defeating McDurability.