DE Sidious and DE Luke vs Sith Emperor and Darth Revan

Who Wins? This is Pre-Kotor Revan during his sith lord days.

Ragnos blesses Vitiate and Revan and they win.

Luke or Sidious solos 💃

Yea, in your fantasy world.

Agreed. That guy clearly hates Revan and it's clouding his judgment.

Or the guy clearly loves Sidious and it's clouding his judgment🙂

Unlikely; he said that either Sidious or Luke could solo-- there is no evidence of bias {much less love} on his part for Sidious. It is more likely that he simply hates Revan and Vitiate.

Originally posted by RevanSpoilers
Unlikely; he said that either Sidious or Luke could solo-- there is no evidence of bias {much less love} on his part for Sidious. It is more likely that he simply hates Revan and Vitiate.

In all seriousness though Luke takes Revan after a long fight.
Sidious kills Vitiate.

Or Sidious solos 😛

Good one🙂

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
Good one🙂

Sidious has feats that eclipse Emperor Vitiate's. Vitiate was slain by a lone Jedi Knight.
Granted that Knight was the Champion of the Light. But Sidious defeated the "Supreme Master of the Jedi Order, the fiercest most implacable, most devastatingly powerful foe the darkness had ever known"

Looks like somebody is 10 years behind.

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
Looks like somebody is 10 years behind.

Looks like somebody likes to ignore established canon. From day 1 Sidious has been the most powerful Sith Lord and Yoda the most powerful Jedi.
Luke being the most powerful force user of all times. The only beings who eclipse them are The Ones of Mortis who are neither Jedi nor sith.

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
Looks like somebody likes to ignore established canon. From day 1 Sidious has been the most powerful Sith Lord and Yoda the most powerful Jedi.
Luke being the most powerful force user of all times. The only beings who eclipse them are The Ones of Mortis who are neither Jedi nor sith.

If it has been argued all over the place that DE Luke can take on Orbalisk Bane and win (some thread, some time ago), than I think he is perfectly capable of taking on Revan as well.

Meanwhile DE Sidious force-storms Vitiate.

If it has been argued all over the place that DE Luke can take on Orbalisk Bane and win (some thread, some time ago), than I think he is perfectly capable of taking on Revan as well.

Meanwhile DE Sidious force-storms Vitiate.

Being argued isn't the same thing as winning the argument. I can argue that I can beat MJ in basketball, doesn't mean my argument holds any merit. Bane would destroy DE Luke.

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
Being argued isn't the same thing as winning the argument. I can argue that I can beat MJ in basketball, doesn't mean my argument holds any merit. Bane would destroy DE Luke.

Do you have something to back up that claim?

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
Being argued isn't the same thing as winning the argument. I can argue that I can beat MJ in basketball, doesn't mean my argument holds any merit. Bane would destroy DE Luke.

Regardless, I'm not sure about the force contest, but what have Revan accomplished with a saber?

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
Do you have something to back up that claim?

Originally posted by axel_jovan
What I'm sayig is that the case was made (feats etc.) for DE Luke's superiority to Bane.

Regardless, I'm not sure about the force contest, but what have Revan accomplished with a saber?

Sure, Bane's a beast, but DE Luke is no pushover, and as far as I remember the thread didn't have the clear winner.

Nobody said Luke is a pushover but as of DE, there's very little evidence of him being anywhere near Bane's league.