DE Sidious and DE Luke vs Sith Emperor and Darth Revan

One might say that. I am not arguing DE Luke's supremacy, just bringing the example.

Besides, what proof there is that Revan is in the same league as Bane?

Da Bane Respect pleases me.

Originally posted by axel_jovan
One might say that. I am not arguing DE Luke's supremacy, just bringing the example.

Besides, what proof there is that Revan is in the same league as Bane?

Some obscure Drew Karpyshyn quote stating that Revan Bane and Vader were equals.

Splendid 😎

One might say that this is not an abundant proof.

I don't think Drew has the authority to make such statements.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I don't think Drew has the authority to make such statements.

He doesn't he made it in an interview. He says in his opinion it's a tie between them.

Excellent.

http://www.drewkarpyshyn.com/faq.htm
He even says it's not up to him to make that kind of call.

So beside this, any evidence that Revan is up there with the likes of Bane?

Feats? Quotes? Anything?

Originally posted by axel_jovan
So beside this, any evidence that Revan is up there with the likes of Bane?

Feats? Quotes? Anything?

QFT

If it has been argued all over the place that DE Luke can take on Orbalisk Bane and win (some thread, some time ago), than I think he is perfectly capable of taking on Revan as well.

Meanwhile DE Sidious force-storms Vitiate.

I love this kind of acceptance. Basically, you're already opposed to the idea that Revan is a contender who could win, so you're taking arguments against him as givens and demanding evidence to satisfy your already-closed mind to the contrary.

Why bother?

Did you notice there's been a string of n00bs today?

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
Did you notice there's been a string of n00bs today?

It's like whack-a-mole.

Nah.

Lately there has been a big boom for Revan. My point is: lets use, say Bane, as a yardstick and place Revan somewhere in the power scale?
I asked if he is in the same league as Bane?
Damn, he can be above him or below him for what I care, but what are his feats that would prove it?

Revan and Vitiate win. The evidence in favor of these two has been posted in abundance on this thread, I'd quote it but it would be a waste of time. In a nutshell, Revan deflected lightning powerful enough to reduce a Sith Council member to ash and deflected Vitiate's Sith lightning with his lightsaber. That alone is indicative of elite skill in both the Force and swordsmanship. Vitiate himself drained the Force of hundreds of Sith Lords after dominating their minds telepathically.

Originally posted by RevanSpoilers
Revan and Vitiate win. The evidence in favor of these two has been posted in abundance on this thread, I'd quote it but it would be a waste of time. In a nutshell, Revan deflected lightning powerful enough to reduce a Sith Council member to ash and deflected Vitiate's Sith lightning with his lightsaber. That alone is indicative of elite skill in both the Force and swordsmanship. Vitiate himself drained the Force of hundreds of Sith Lords after dominating their minds telepathically.

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
I disagree. On some other forums it was argued that DE Luke would own Bane, therefore the DE duo win.

Truly.

TKing an AT-AT >>>> Anything Bane's ever done.

That's a dumb argument.
Sure, DE Luke tanked an AT-AT's laser cannons without any visible damage, but there's no way in hell he could do that with Sith lightning. Luke isn't anywhere near Bane's level and Bane is nowhere near Revan's level.

Originally posted by RevanSpoilers
Revan and Vitiate win. The evidence in favor of these two has been posted in abundance on this thread, I'd quote it but it would be a waste of time. In a nutshell, Revan deflected lightning powerful enough to reduce a Sith Council member to ash and deflected Vitiate's Sith lightning with his lightsaber. That alone is indicative of elite skill in both the Force and swordsmanship. Vitiate himself drained the Force of hundreds of Sith Lords after dominating their minds telepathically.

I have seen the light now. All is clear.

Not even sure why Bane is introduced into this argument but go to town!

Right. And because Revan is only substantiated as being better than everyone but Vitiate, he must be a nobody because the Sidious brigade refuses to believe anyone but Sidious could be of consequence. Mace and Yoda are naturally powerful because they've already demonstrated defeating RotS Sidious, but since no one else has demonstrated this on-screen, they must be assumed to be inferior. Especially because a multitude of side-media pumps up Sidious' legacy even more. But anything which pumps up Vitiate or Revan is flawed. We're on the same page.