Superman vs Thor: EXTREME RAGE EDITION

Started by JakeTheBank27 pages
Originally posted by h1a8
Because I said the one scan wasn't canon? Well I accepted the feat regardless.

It is canon, btw. It was a back up story in Thor #600, written by a guy I like to call The Man. Says "Excelsior!" a lot.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
It is canon, btw. It was a back up story in Thor #600, written by a guy I like to call The Man. Says "Excelsior!" a lot.

I'll look it up. It looked like it came from a cereal box though lol. But it's irrelevant to bring it up since I gave it the benefit of the doubt and accepted it.

why do you guys keep indulging this troll?

Originally posted by psycho gundam
why do you guys keep indulging this troll?

You; that's why.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Based on what?
Batman.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Batman.

Not exactly much, considering who wrote it.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Not exactly much, considering who wrote it.
It's still canon.

Originally posted by quanchi112
It's still canon.

Doesn't make it representative of the average, though, nor does it make it fact.

Character statements aren't taken as gospel for a reason.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Doesn't make it representative of the average, though, nor does it make it fact.

Character statements aren't taken as gospel for a reason.

I didn't say they were but you asked and I gave you my answer. You have your opinion and I have mine.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I didn't say they were but you asked and I gave you my answer. You have your opinion and I have mine.

So you base your entire opinion of the two's speed on one single panel in one single comic?

All right.

Originally posted by -Pr-
So you base your entire opinion of the two's speed on one single panel in one single comic?

All right.

No, I base it off of how WW is portrayed. She isn't as durable as Superman and usually doesn't swing back and forth with her foes as he does. She uses her reflexes and skill far more regularly than Superman typically does.

The writer made it plain as day with Batman's logic and I for one agree with it. You don't. It's that simple.

Speed Blitz = over in ten seconds or less

Supes FTW

Originally posted by ColossusGrundy
Speed Blitz = over in ten seconds or less

Supes FTW

😆

😐

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman goes intangible and removes thor's heart./Thread.

You my friend, are the brightest poster on the board. 👆

Originally posted by h1a8
That was a lightning bolt from the sky and totally irrelevant.

It was an energy blast the originated from Thor, not a lightning bolt from the sky. Do you even read the scans I post?

Depends on whether or not you count it as a God Blast. I personally don’t, ODG might. Either way, it’s sufficiently powerful enough to finish off Superman.

Originally posted by h1a8
Again, not a god blast or an omnidirectional blast.

It was an omni-directional explosion when Thor struck the Midgard Serpent, it counts.

Still sufficiently powerful enough to suit the needs of this discussion.

Originally posted by h1a8
Doesn't look canon. Also seems it isn't the god blast either.

Please stop talking out of your ass, it was cannon.

Originally posted by h1a8
Again not omnidirectional.

What’s your definition of omni-directional?

Originally posted by h1a8
That might be a winner there. But can we really tell what happened? Seems like a bolt coming from up top. I give him that one though. But still no godblast.

What the hell are you talking about? We can see the energy blast being projected from Thor.

Originally posted by h1a8
This proves my point. He must block the beam.

If Thor didn't hold the hammer towards the incoming beam then he wouldn't be able to absorb it.

Irrelevant to my posts and this fight.

Again my point is still valid.

My point again.

Again my point.

In all of those instances I posted, he draws the energy into the hammer. Thor pointing Mjolnir at the source isn’t prove that he can’t absorb energy without pointing in that direction.

I have no idea why I’m indulging your stupidity but here he doesn’t even point the hammer towards the energy source:
http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/NullBombAbsorb.jpg

Originally posted by h1a8
Doesn't show us how much time he needed to get into space. The scan makes some reference of traveling through both time and space. Did he open a portal? Doesn't even mention the time frame in which Thor didn't anything. My point whas that Thor needs to spin the hammer for a moment in order to throw it at great speed. Thor can fly at lightspeed and beyond it just takes him time to accelerate to that speed. He can't achieve lightspeed from rest just like that.

Skuttlebutt flies past Thor at many times the speed of light. The Odinson turns around and immediately catches up to it. This proves that he doesn’t need to whirl his hammer or any other such bullshit to hit speeds far faster than light.

Originally posted by h1a8
Nothing shown was a godblast. Two scans actually show omni-directional blasts. One being not canon and the other is still iffy as to what happened. But what the hell I will give him it. But now you have to contend with:

I’m not going to indulge your trolling.

Originally posted by h1a8
1. Superman hitting Thor before it happens.
2. Superman withstanding it (it's not a Godblast) like he has withstood other mega magic attacks (not without pain though) in order to HV through Thor.
3. Superman becoming intangible until Thor tires. Yes there is evidence that the godblast tires Thor. Irrelevant to this fight. That is a clear lie as Mjolnir can't reach light speed instantaneous. Also I'm not sure it can reach bullet speed instantly.
Thor and the hammer needs time to build to the necessary speed.

Not a likely scenario.

He isn’t withstanding those attacks and then counterattacking in that manner.

You claim that the scene with Durok is irrelevant and yet you reference it here as evidence that a God Blast weakens Thor?

I’ve proven otherwise.

Originally posted by h1a8
And I'm not wrong about anything.
1. I didn't see Thor godblast AOE from his body
2. I didn't see Mjolnir absorb beams when Thor wasn't pointing the hammer towards the beam.
3. I didn't see Mjolnir nor Thor with Mjolnir achieve light speed instantly.
4. I didn't see Thor react to light speed attacks from 5ft away or deal with multiple light speed attacks at once.

My points still stand.

1) Like I said, depends entirely on ODG definition. If he wants to call it a God Blast type attack, you are really in no position to argue with him.

2) That’s a blatant lie.

3) That’s a blatant lie.

4) What?

Originally posted by -Pr-
You; that's why.

Originally posted by -Pr-
h1a8, you're really starting to stretch the limitations of the slack you've been given, tbh.
pr protection: confirmed

Originally posted by quanchi112
No, I base it off of how WW is portrayed. She isn't as durable as Superman and usually doesn't swing back and forth with her foes as he does. She uses her reflexes and skill far more regularly than Superman typically does.

The writer made it plain as day with Batman's logic and I for one agree with it. You don't. It's that simple.

So you don't base it off of how Superman is portrayed? Okay.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
pr protection: confirmed

Yeah, sure. 😬

Originally posted by psycho gundam
pr protection: confirmed

I thought Bada was the power, and pr the token mod. 😈

Originally posted by psycho gundam

shrug

Originally posted by cdtm
I thought Bada was the power, and pr the token mod. 😈

He likes to think so.