Quick question guys.Since this is a strength feat thread.Here's my question.In Thor#425, Thor was able to hurl Surtur's Twilight Sword against Surtur and Ymir.We all know Surtur destroyed a Galaxy forging this sword.Is this considered Thor lifting and hurling a Galaxy since Twilight is forged by destroying a Galaxy?
Originally posted by country1000
It has not been retconned, superman does not use much strength when flying heavy objects, he strains to lift a mountain until he starts flying and he tells why himself. Superman lifting feats are not as great as thors when it comes to pure strength... look at 16 and 17.
http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansites/BatmanvsWolverine/news/?a=49617
http://i219.photobucket.com/albums/cc260/Superman-Prime_Respect/Realityalterpunch2.jpg
You can see multiple rockets leaving a destructing krypton. They are indicative of many origins of superman since COIE which are no longer canon and anything linked with those origins are retconned away like parallax bug retconned away emerald twilight and zero hour. So try again with something recent.
Originally posted by Igniz
Quick question guys.Since this is a strength feat thread.Here's my question.In Thor#425, Thor was able to hurl Surtur's Twilight Sword against Surtur and Ymir.We all know Surtur destroyed a Galaxy forging this sword.Is this considered Thor lifting and hurling a Galaxy since Twilight is forged by destroying a Galaxy?
Originally posted by psycho gundam
not when magic is involved
was its weight ever explicitly referred to as being equivalent to a galaxy?
Originally posted by carver9
I never said she was more durable than Superman,I said she blocked his punch and she did.
Originally posted by carver9
So Manhunter was lying.?
Obviously.
Originally posted by carver9
So a pissed Superman that was amped punching at Wonder Woman and her catching this punch isn't a sign of strength. What fts am I dismissing to suggest Superman is stronger than Thor. Thor clashed hammers with another Thor which resulted in a impact resembling the big bang. That surpass any strength ft I can think of. Now go ahead and downplay.
It was specifically stated that it was a bolt of mystic energy and "big bang" was obviously a hyperbole.
Kal-EL and Kal-L broke entire space-time by punching each other
http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/70950400rk0.jpg
People take that book feat a bit too literally. I've even seen people try to use math calculations and shit. ermm
It proves that Superman is very strong, we run into problems when we got past that. A better strength feat would be Superman slowing down and stopping that huge Monitor ship.
Originally posted by abhilegend
It was specifically stated that it was a bolt of mystic energy and "big bang" was obviously a hyperbole.Kal-EL and Kal-L broke entire space-time by punching each other
http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/70950400rk0.jpg
Possibly but probably not. Zarrako was going to use the energy/force collected from the encounter to collapse an infinite number of time lines to make him the ruler of the Multiverse or some other similar plot.
I'm going to re-read Infinite Crisis.
Originally posted by Igniz
Quick question guys.Since this is a strength feat thread.Here's my question.In Thor#425, Thor was able to hurl Surtur's Twilight Sword against Surtur and Ymir.We all know Surtur destroyed a Galaxy forging this sword.Is this considered Thor lifting and hurling a Galaxy since Twilight is forged by destroying a Galaxy?
Originally posted by carver9
No need to reread the book. The time line was being screwed with during the time both Supes was fighting. Superman didn't have anything to do with breaking through space/time. That was more on Prime partner end (Alexander Luthor).
Originally posted by CosmicComet👆
The writer(s) obviously cared enough to create the explanation.Giving an explanation for the impossible is not the angle that can be called, 'nonsense', logically.
Superman lifting a mountain = nonsense.
Superman lifting a mountain because his tactile tk allows him to spread the force over the entire mass = oh wow. clever idea.
If you want to just turn off your brain to logic in comics, (which is fine) at least be consistent about it. Afterall. You are trying to push here that lifting 'half of infinity' is equivalent to lifting full 'infinity' because logically it should be. But guess what? 'It's comics'. 🙂
Superman needed help and struggled, Ultraman did not. It's non-sense, focus on quantifiable feats (Especially since Thor has a feat or two regarding something as stupid as 'infinite' weight as well). In which case, Superman should still have the edge.
Originally posted by abhilegend
So what happened when they punched each other in Infinite crisis 5. Don't tell me that Alex stopped to murk time-space in that book? Read Adventures of superman 649 and tell me about an on-panel statement that proves that it was due to alex phucking with the multiverse. Aren't you always demanding on-panel proof?
Time was being screwed with before and after that fight. The Supermans had nothing to do with it.
Originally posted by CosmicComet
but then there's also that.was its weight ever explicitly referred to as being equivalent to a galaxy?
No I don't remember the sword being referred to of having the weight equivalent to a Galaxy.To be honest, I asked this because a lot of people seem to buy the reasoning that it was made from a Galaxy.But I've also taken the account that said sword is forged by using magic.Surtur with the Twilight Sword gave Odin a lot of trouble.So Twilight itself gives Surtur an amp.I would probably consider it being a strength feat for Thor since I do believe Odin can wield it via the Odin power.Though if this is considered lifting and hurling a Galaxy, is still a mystery to me.Now at least we have a joke that Thor can hurl a Galaxy 😄
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
People take that book feat a bit too literally. I've even seen people try to use math calculations and shit. ermmIt proves that Superman is very strong, we run into problems when we got past that. A better strength feat would be Superman slowing down and stopping that huge Monitor ship.
Possibly but probably not. Zarrako was going to use the energy/force collected from the encounter to collapse an infinite number of time lines to make him the ruler of the Multiverse or some other similar plot.
I'm going to re-read Infinite Crisis.
