Classic Mangog vs Thanos

Started by Horrificus16 pages

Originally posted by quanchi112
This isn't a ufc fight. You are taking one sports rules and applying it here to a street fight. 😂
Also, if we use your argument, do you understand we would have to go back and dig into every battle Thanos ever had where his opponent either did not verbally yield, or was able to stand up after the battle?

It would end up negating some of Thanos' wins as well.

Originally posted by Galan007
In UFC, if 'fighter a' pummels 'fighter b' for all 3 rounds without KO'ing him, 'fighter b' still lost the fight.

Same thing here. Odin beat the crap out of Thanos for most of the issue--Thanos not being KO'd and refusing to yield, doesn't change the fact that he still lost the fight from a technical aspect.

Odin defeated Thanos period, if I was judge it was unamious, that being said Classic Mangog is on the same level as PC Validus walking a$$ kickers, Thanos will have to be very, very elusive, if Thanos couldnt phase Odin he sure in hell isn't harming Mangog, unless he has CC or Chalice of Power!

Originally posted by Horrificus
Also, if we use your argument, do you understand we would have to go back and dig into every battle Thanos ever had where his opponent either did not verbally yield, or was able to stand up after the battle?

It would end up negating some of Thanos' wins as well.

You can say Odin was winning the battle up until was stopped. That's what the comic clearly shows. Thanos wanted more and was ready for more. That isn't a loss and it wasn't a ufc match with judges.

Originally posted by Horrificus
After panels of Thanos being brutally punished, the writer made sure the panel states Odin's thought's. "At last. It is over".
This is done for a reason.
Then, Thanos is shown on his knees, while Odin offers him a chance to avoid taking more punishment.
Then, several panels are shown, to see the effort it takes for Thanos to even stand up. Also, showing Thanos is tough.

All of that was done to show he was defeated. THAT is the point to those panels.
There is no evidence that supports your opinion, that the point to the panels was to show that Thanos was STILL in the fight and it was not finished.
The entire battle showed a one-sided combat, ending in a decimated Thanos and a shiny new Odin offering a way out.

You are interjecting your feelings again.

If he was defeated he would have been ko'd or accepted submission. Thanos knew he wasn't near death or defeat. Fighting Odin wasn't his purpose and saying he lost is showing bias because the fight was undecided.

Originally posted by the Darkone
Odin defeated Thanos period
Based on the battle we saw on panel, absolutely. 👆

Originally posted by quanchi112
If he was defeated he would have been ko'd or accepted submission. Thanos knew he wasn't near death or defeat. Fighting Odin wasn't his purpose and saying he lost is showing bias because the fight was undecided.
Thanos did not submit, because he is "Thanos".
He doesn't quit.
But, he still gets beaten.
And, again, going by your statements, there would be an uncountable number of combat results which would have to be overturned if we went by your criteria.
Including results that were once in Thanos' favor.

And, I'm sorry, but you stating, again, what Thanos KNEW, "Thanos knew he wasn't near death or defeat.", is getting kind of creepy. 😕

Agreed, Thanos took alot of Odin's blast in Asgard. You can clearly see Thanos was bruised and damaged lightly and was smiling. When he rose to his feet, his body healed in a minute. He has one bad to the bone healing factor. Even Odin was in Awe with Thanos. Mind you, Odin was using his his Odin Sceptor while battling Thanos with nothing.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You can say Odin was winning the battle up until was stopped. That's what the comic clearly shows. Thanos wanted more and was ready for more. That isn't a loss and it wasn't a ufc match with judges.

Originally posted by Horrificus
Thanos did not submit, because he is "Thanos".
He doesn't quit.
But, he still gets beaten.
And, again, going by your statements, there would be an uncountable number of combat results which would have to be overturned if we went by your criteria.
Including results that were once in Thanos' favor.

And, I'm sorry, but you stating, again, what Thanos KNEW, "Thanos knew he wasn't near death or defeat.", is getting kind of creepy. 😕

Thanos won't forfeit his life when it's in jeopardy for no good reason. Look at the example against Galactus which also throws mud all over your theories on Thanos.

I go by the comics you go by ufc rules. Laughs.

Even if your opinion is that the fight wasn't over because Thanos had yet to submit, you still have to agree that Thanos lost the fight up to THAT point. BADLY.

That's all people are saying.

Originally posted by Merlyn
Even if your opinion is that the fight wasn't over because Thanos had yet to submit, you still have to agree that Thanos lost the fight up to THAT point. BADLY.

That's all people are saying.

I have never denied Thanos was losing up until the point that it was stopped. Not once. saying he lost is completely different than saying he was losing a fight that ended before someone won the fight.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I have never denied Thanos was losing up until the point that it was stopped. Not once. saying he lost is completely different than saying he was losing a fight that ended before someone won the fight.
But up to that point Thanos DID lose completely. 😕

Originally posted by Merlyn
But up to that point Thanos DID lose completely. 😕
No, because the fight hadn't yet been decided. Thanos was losing but the fight wasn't over.

AGAIN: up to THAT POINT Thanos DID lose completely. Him refusing to give up doesn't change the fact that Odin beat his ass up and down Asgard... Up to THAT POINT.

Originally posted by Merlyn
AGAIN: up to THAT POINT Thanos DID lose completely. Him refusing to give up doesn't change the fact that Odin beat his ass up and down Asgard... Up to THAT POINT.
You only lose when you get ko'd/die/submit or are bfr'd. Thanos didn't lose.

Thanos was getting his a$$ handed to him, he's just lucky that Odin took pity on him and stopped attacking for the several panels it took Thanos to get back up.

Don't care what Quan thinks but its obvious Thanos lost the fight hell Odin no longer felt threatened which is why Thanos was able to recover

Originally posted by Silent Master
Thanos was getting his a$$ handed to him, he's just lucky that Odin took pity on him and stopped attacking for the several panels it took Thanos to get back up.
This isn't accurate at all. Ofdin respected him and only stopped because BrB interfered.

Originally posted by iceman24567
Don't care what Quan thinks but its obvious Thanos lost the fight hell Odin no longer felt threatened which is why Thanos was able to recover

Exactly, Odin just stood there for 6 or 7 panels watching Thanos struggle to get back up.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You only lose when you get ko'd/die/submit or are bfr'd. Thanos didn't lose.
Haha! Wow!
I guess you are right.
This entire forum now needs to be deleted, reconsidered and recreated, using your new logic.

You are negating your own previous statements and opinions about many other fights.

You aren't here to debate. You are just here to disagree. And, you don't know the difference.

As the writer of the book stated through Odin's narration,
after decimating and standing over a kneeling, crumpled,
smoldering, ineffectual Thanos: