Manga comparison thread

Started by Nephthys83 pages

I'm going to devour that cock. And then I'm going to rip your heart out of Gecko's cold lifeless hands. Or maybe it'll be more fun the other way around.....

Remember kids, first impressions are the most important. Lack of context can make or break a post.

I'll eat it with butter and the Colonels special sauce.

YouTube video

D'awww....Narupiece. :3

[list=1][*]Naruto [*]Bleach[/list=1]
While Bleach was probably better written with the captains actually fending for their own and Byakuya being killed, parts of it felt dragged out and other parts rushed. In Naruto we got a good chunk of backstory as well as the set up for the determining battle. Unless Madara shows up and interferes.

1. Road to Ninja One Shot
2. Bleach
3. Naruto

Naruto was good but mostly for just the typical reasons. The teasing of Tobi's identity, Bee being hilarious, Naruto having heroic determination despite all of the odds. I liked it, though it felt fluffed and there is a possible major plot hole at the moment.

Bleach was different. I've never seen Bleach go this angle with a villain and I'm liking As more and more. Villains that are just cruelly ****ing with the heroes are something Kubo can do surprisingly well, so long as he remembers to show that the villain still has limits. I've started to consider Byakuya as one of my favorite characters right around this time so it was pretty darn effective for me at least. And that face...uhgerdh.

Road to Ninja was just very fun, with Kishi taking a splash page and turning it into a little character story in celebration for his new movie. I enjoyed the humor a lot, especially the Hinata moments. She can be a funny punching bag type of character when jokes are made at her expense and it kinda made her more endearing to me than a lot of the canon moments. And overall, it just felt like a nice read. Compared to all the drama in Bleach and Naruto at the moment, I just like a little relaxation. Might explain why I really do like the Davy Back arc in One Piece.

1. Road to Ninja One Shot
2. Naruto
3. Bleach

Bleach was very good, but half of it was still Ichigo once again failing to get out of that cage. ****s sake Kubo, we get it.

Plus I always like the banter between Naruto and Tobi.

Originally posted by TheAuraAngel
YouTube video

D'awww....Narupiece. :3

I agree with a lot of what he says, but strategic battles are gone from Naruto now. At this level theres no room for much strategy, Its all beam-spam.

I wouldn't say they're completely gone. Even with the big Bijuu brawl, Naruto was focused on hitting a target, not really just beating them into submission. And though I hated it, Izanami did take some strategic setup.

He also makes Korra videos. He goes from liking all of the characters(Cept Tarrlok I guess) to hating one in particular. 3 guesses who.

Yeah, I watched him while Korra was on. He's pretty cool. Better than that OtakuAssemble douchebag.

Huh

Here I thought I was the only one on here that probably knew about that guy. Weird.

Course, I discovered him thanks to the absolutely amazing reveal of Madara Uchiha.

**** that was a great chapter.

His Obito-senses are tingling.

Imma track down his reaction to that now actually. It should be cool.

1. Bleach ( for hope of death)
2. One shot (dem titties)
3. Naruto

Now that there are no serious fights I can safely go back to enjoying the fanservice in Kenichi. I guess this was bound to happen eventually in this manga:

http://www.mangareader.net/historys-strongest-disciple-kenichi/483/12
😐

Oh and for the rankings:
1. One shot
2. Bleach
3. Naruto

1. Bleach
2. Naruto
3. One Piece

Bleach had what seems to be a character death at the moment, and if it's true than it is effectively a big deal fro the series. A decent cliffhanger, though I don't exactly like that guy or dislike him. The idea of seeing the Big Bad in battle has got me pumped.

Naruto was all action. And not bad actually. Guy and Naruto show off new techniques and Tobi gets to be really badass fighting off three opponents at once, barely getting scratched for all their efforts. Kakashi should be about to pass out though.

One Piece just bored me. Some people might be interested in this big event that happened 3 years ago in this Island in the middle of bum **** nowhere(the Post doesn't even point to Punk Hazzard) but I don't. And I either wish we'd get a scene of it or Caesar would just shut up. And Law's powers make no sense and his bargain with Caesar makes even less sense.

im tempted to say bleach actually beat toriko this week

the Ecstasy of bishies death is that intense

Indeed. Gosh why is One Piece so ****ing boring right now? I actually had to force myself to read this chapter after reading Naruto and Bleach first.

So the ranking goes as the following:
1.Bleach
2.Naruto
3. One Piece

Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
Indeed. Gosh why is One Piece so ****ing boring right now? I actually had to force myself to read this chapter after reading Naruto and Bleach first.
Litterally the only reason im reading is law. Who looks to be out for the count for a while

I might just pull a skypeia arc and drop it then watch the anime and catch back up in a few months

Wouldn't it be funny if Kubo ret-con Byakuya's death based on the massive amount of hate mail and death thread he'll receive? It's probably not going to happen for the same reason he didn't ret-con Ulquiorra's death, but still.

It would be funny but...honestly, the manga is better for his death. I like Byakuya, he's my favorite Captain, but damn it if his death doesn't add some tension.

...If he's dead that is. I say this not as a fan of Byakuya but as a jaded reader of Bleach.

It would be funny due to the reaction if would have on this forum.