Thor vs Superman-HTH

Originally posted by abhilegend
No, you are taking away a part of his durability. OP didn't took anything away, it just said that they would use only their strength and skill. Durability was taken as default.
Post the scans. We would see who is more agile.
It spans entire career of superman too. He is a brawler by default.
I have still seen nothing that makes me believe that thor is so much skilled than thor. I haven't seen anything from thor that tops stomping CSA in a few panels.

Did I say Thor is more agile I simply said I don't see Superman being more agile and with their level of strength jumping around shouldn't be a problem for either one.

Good for you I guess. Thor has more years experience, way way more showings of skill use then Superman ever had powered and depowered both.

Thor ftw.

Originally posted by Newjak
It's not a part of his Durability it is another power just like it is for Wolverine. And I took the opening post to mean any powers besides strength and H2H skill would be removed from this fight considering it specifically says no Super Speed to with the exception being Durability since they would both die from one hit without it.

Did I say Thor is more agile I simply said I don't see Superman being more agile and with their level of strength jumping around shouldn't be a problem for either one.

Good for you I guess. Thor has more years experience, way way more showings of skill use then Superman ever had powered and depowered both.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
I've said this exact thing before in another thread. And I believe you agreed there too.

Ninjas are made of fail anyway.

Yeah. MA skill is very often equated to the Asian systems. Western systems of combat are often overlooked. As are some of the southeast Asian systems for that matter. Point is that you don't need to fight like Crouching tiger hidden dragon to be skilled in MA and combatives.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Nope, OP didn't depower them. He just restricted them using their active powers. HF isn't an active power of superman which he can negate by will.
You said thor has done better than a flip so he is more agile. I asked proof. You denied your claim. Classic. By that reasoning hulk would be the agilest one there is!😱
You're not the first guy who said that in this thread and certainly wouldn't be last. Thor could've trained for every moment of his life and he still wouldn't be more skilled without on panel proofs.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Pre Flashpoint Superman vs Thor in Hand to Hand combat. No other abilities will be used. (No flying, no super speed, no lightning, no Durok droppers, etc...) Just their strength and skill. Who takes it?

Originally posted by Silent Master

Originally posted by abhilegend
Nope, OP didn't depower them. He just restricted them using their active powers. HF isn't an active power of superman which he can negate by will.
You said thor has done better than a flip so he is more agile. I asked proof. You denied your claim. Classic. By that reasoning hulk would be the agilest one there is!😱
You're not the first guy who said that in this thread and certainly wouldn't be last. Thor could've trained for every moment of his life and he still wouldn't be more skilled without on panel proofs.

No I said and if you read it you said because Superman can do a flip that makes him more agile, and I said that Thor has probably done something better or similar. So doing one flip won't make him more agile Thor. Maybe you misread what I was trying to say.

I never stated Thor was more agile.

Originally posted by Newjak
If that's the case then yes his HF would still be here.

No I said and if you read it you said because Superman can do a flip that makes him more agile, and I said that Thor has probably done something better or similar. So doing one flip won't make him more agile Thor. Maybe you misread what I was trying to say.

I never stated Thor was more agile.

http://img433.imageshack.us/my.php?image=177ec.jpg

Pretty sure Thor in the Son of Asgard mini was doing flips and rolls while fighting dragons and crap.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Pretty sure Thor in the Son of Asgard mini was doing flips and rolls while fighting dragons and crap.

I'll have to find them.

Either way, being completely serious, neither one of those guys is going to be doing a bunch of needless flips and rolls in combat. That's stupid.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I'll have to find them.

Either way, being completely serious, neither one of those guys is going to be doing a bunch of needless flips and rolls in combat. That's stupid.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Why not?
baka

Serious question?

Because in a fight stripped of powers aside from strength and durability, I don't see Superman suddenly cartwheeling and doing combat rolls in the midst of the fight against Thor. And neither would Thor.

Black Adam>Superman>Thor (in strength)

In power though , Black Adam>Thor>Superman

Since this is h2h superman beats hor

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Serious question?

Because in a fight stripped of powers aside from strength and durability, I don't see Superman suddenly cartwheeling and doing combat rolls in the midst of the fight against Thor. And neither would Thor.

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
Black Adam>Superman>Thor (in strength)

In power though , Black Adam>Thor>Superman

Since this is h2h superman beats hor

Absolutely incorrect.

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
Black Adam>Superman>Thor (in strength)

In power though , Black Adam>Thor>Superman

Since this is h2h superman beats hor

So, Strength is the only thing that matters in HTH fights?

^Its big c.

Originally posted by abhilegend
^Its big c.

Good point.

^The guy made a thread about eating mjolnir once.