Movie Hulk(Avengers) vs Movie Thor

Started by Starscream M61 pages

Originally posted by SuperiorTech
I thought it was common knowledge you hate Thor just as much as Carver hates Superman. 😕
no, I dont hate any comic book character...least of all thor

but the fact is there is a lot of misinformation and wanking regarding thor on the board so I appear to oppose him

Originally posted by Mindset
He didn't hit with the same force, that was the whole point of him escaping from the container, or else he would have died.
How would he have not hit with the same force as the Hulk when he landed?

It's doesn't make logical sense. You can only fall so fast and so hard.

I could say that Thor had added force because he had the force of the free fall mixed in with the force of what it took him to escape the container.

Originally posted by Starscream M
first of all, I do like thor, he's one of my fav marvel characters...just becuz I don't see him being greater than hulk doesnt mean I dont like him

two, sure mjolnir evens things out a bit...but I just don't buy the notion that it turns to thor's favor with mjolnir

guys like you and jake like to project what you think thor should do, and when he does, that he'd best hulk

unfortunately, thor never does those things. can he unleash lightning on hulk, maybe...but I doubt it'd put hulk down, and furthermore, very likely enrage hulk even further to the point where it becomes even more lopsided in hulks favor

if movie hulk and movie thor were to fight full on, I think its pretty clear from the movies that hulk would be victorious even if thor went all out. they depict thor less a god than a very powerful hero...they depict hulk as an unstoppable force of nature.

Thor's one of your favorite marvel characters?

😂

Alright then, agree to disagree. I think Hulk would win in a hand to hand fight but Thor would be my pick in all out battle unless the comic book effect of the Odinson brawling every time with the Hulk comes into play.

Thor's ability to control the lightning and weather, coupled with flight and Mjolnir are advantages Hulk can't overcome. I think a large blast will be at least as effective against the Hulk as the alien blast barrage near the end of the movie.

Originally posted by Starscream M
first of all, I do like thor, he's one of my fav marvel characters...just becuz I don't see him being greater than hulk doesnt mean I dont like him

two, sure mjolnir evens things out a bit...but I just don't buy the notion that it turns to thor's favor with mjolnir

guys like you and jake like to project what you think thor should do, and when he does, that he'd best hulk

unfortunately, thor never does those things. can he unleash lightning on hulk, maybe...but I doubt it'd put hulk down, and furthermore, very likely enrage hulk even further to the point where it becomes even more lopsided in hulks favor

if movie hulk and movie thor were to fight full on, I think its pretty clear from the movies that hulk would be victorious even if thor went all out. they depict thor less a god than a very powerful hero...they depict hulk as an unstoppable force of nature.

Lol.

Lol x2.

It's not what Thor should do as much as stuff he actually has done in fights before...just not against Hulk for whatever reason. If you really liked Thor and read comics like you claim to, you'd know that in battles against people such as Firelord, Silver Surfer, Gladiator, Surtur, Loki, Etc. Thor can and has used his powers outside of raw strength and clubbing things with Mjolnir. The in character reason for why Thor fights down on Hulk's level is because of his warrior's pride and the sense of fair play.

Funny, because Thor has knocked out Hulk with lightning before. And when he amped a Mjolnir strike with lightning, one-shot BFRed Nul-Hulk into orbit. That, my friend, was an amped Green Scar. WTF do you think that would have done to Savage Hulk? Unless you follow Carverithmatics and think an Asgardian hammer amp actually weakens somehow.

Which is based on nothing. I certainly didn't see anything to suggest that Hulk could no sell a barrage of lightning or hammer throws.

Originally posted by SuperiorTech
I thought it was common knowledge you hate Thor just as much as Carver hates Superman. 😕

lol

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus

Alright then, agree to disagree. I think Hulk would win in a hand to hand fight but Thor would be my pick in all out battle unless the comic book effect of the Odinson brawling every time with the Hulk comes into play.

you call it 'comic book effect'...I call it 'thor being thor'.

Originally posted by Newjak
How would he have not hit with the same force as the Hulk when he landed?

It's doesn't make logical sense. You can only fall so fast and so hard.

I could say that Thor had added force because he had the force of the free fall mixed in with the force of what it took him to escape the container.

It doesn't have to make logical sense.

Obviously, they were trying to portray him needing to escape the container to save his live.

i dont see how the movies make it obvious that Hulk wins. Sure Hulk was throwing Thor around like a ragdoll, but he still tanked it all. I still think a blast like the one Thor used to slow the alien invasion would rock Hulk's world.

Thor was pleading with Loki and pretty much got tricked by him i highly doubt a serious going for the kill Thor would have too much trouble killing Loki

Originally posted by Zack Fair
i dont see how the movies make it obvious that Hulk wins. Sure Hulk was throwing Thor around like a ragdoll, but he still tanked it all. I still think a blast like the one Thor used to slow the alien invasion would rock Hulk's world.

👆 Anyone who thinks Hulk would no sell Thor's lightning is deluded. Concentrated fire from Chitauri was enough to halt him in his tracks, probably dealing superficial damage if anything. A prolonged lightning strike is something else entirely.

Originally posted by iceman24567
Thor was pleading with Loki and pretty much got tricked by him i highly doubt a serious going for the kill Thor would have too much trouble killing Loki

👆 Thor was still trying to redeem Loki and bring him without much of a fuss.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
i dont see how the movies make it obvious that Hulk wins. Sure Hulk was throwing Thor around like a ragdoll, but he still tanked it all. I still think a blast like the one Thor used to slow the alien invasion would rock Hulk's world.
thor would have a hard time landing such a blast on a much smaller, more mobile and less predictable target such as the hulk

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
👆 Anyone who thinks Hulk would no sell Thor's lightning is deluded.
I bet before the movie, you'd said the same thing about IM.

Originally posted by Mindset
It doesn't have to make logical sense.

Obviously, they were trying to portray him needing to escape the container to save his live.

Couldn't it just be he was free falling in a container and was getting tossed around and he just wanted out of it like any person in a situation like that would try and do?

Originally posted by Starscream M
thor would have a hard time landing such a blast on a much smaller, more mobile and less predictable target such as the hulk

I agree. Thor would be hard pressed to land that shot, but I think we agree it would **** Hulk if it landed.

Originally posted by Starscream M
I bet before the movie, you'd said the same thing about IM.

You're right. Because I had no idea that they'd go with the electricity powering up Iron Man's armored suit route. 😐

Unless you think that Thor's lightning would amp Hulk, in which case, you're worse than I previously imagined.

Originally posted by Starscream M
thor would have a hard time landing such a blast on a much smaller, more mobile and less predictable target such as the hulk

So Hulk is faster than lightning now? baka

Originally posted by Zack Fair
I agree. Thor would be hard pressed to land that shot, but I think we agree it would **** Hulk if it landed.

Thor was able to hit flying mobile craft and summoned lightning in multiple bursts. I don't think he'd have much issues hitting Hulk, tbh.

I haven't seen it yet, but from the sounds of the attacks it seems incredibly unlikely that Thor wouldn't be able to land those blasts against Hulk.

Hulk certainly isn't as fast as those aircrafts, if I'm assuming correctly.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
So Hulk is faster than lightning now? baka

Thor was able to hit flying mobile craft and summoned lightning in multiple bursts. I don't think he'd have much issues hitting Hulk, tbh.

i agree, but Hulk was still dangerously fast. IMO Hulk sort of blitzed Loki. That shit is dangerous, I do believe Thor can tank anything Hulk dishes out, but the way Hulk was portrayed in the movie suggests he would give Thor little time to summon such a blast. I still think the battle will most likely be a stalemate.

His movements are certainly more erratic and his initial jump speed is faster than the craft's propulsion, but Hulk isn't faster than lightning, figuratively or literally.

Originally posted by CosmicComet

Hulk certainly isn't as fast as those aircrafts, if I'm assuming correctly.

its not about speed, but predictability

aircrafts may be faster, but they move in a predictable trajectory

hulk zigzags like crazy and would be very hard for thor to track