(Dynasty of Evil) Darth Bane -vs- Darth Plagueis (Darth Plagueis)

Agreed.

Frankly, Existentialist, you can point out my flaws as much as you want. I welcome the improvement I can gain from them.

Though, the, "I am not sure Plagueis would win, but the fact Sidious didn't want to fight him head on makes me think he might" doesn't make much sense. Whether Sidious did or did not want to fight him has no relevance.

Originally posted by Pwned
Frankly, Existentialist, you can point out my flaws as much as you want. I welcome the improvement I can gain from them.

That's why I'm doing it.

Originally posted by Pwned
Though, the, "I am not sure Plagueis would win, but the fact Sidious didn't want to fight him head on makes me think he might" doesn't make much sense. Whether Sidious did or did not want to fight him has no relevance.

It (likely) stems from the belief that, since Sidious is more powerful than Bane (confirmed by sources ranging from The Dark Side Sourcebook to The Complete Visual Dictionary), Plagueis's superiority over Sidious would indicate superiority over Bane.

How that would necessarily result in Plagueis's ability to defeat Bane in the context of a strict duel remains to be seen, but then, so does the idea that Sidious was weaker than Plagueis.

Becuase being more powerful than someone indicates victory in all cases. Thats why Abeloth has routinely obliterated Luke in combat.

Funny, many people here consider Bane to be roughly on par with Sidious.

Originally posted by Pwned
Funny, many people here consider Bane to be roughly on par with Sidious.

First and most importantly, you should learn not to trust what most people consider or believe here. Not only is blind acceptance of popular opinions fallacious, a lot of people think Bandon could take Dooku, Revan could take Luke, Ragnos could take the rest. If you want a KMC poster with supernatural precision and an uncanny ability to make valid arguments and objective conclusions, seek out Gideon. Not sure if he comes here anymore, but he's your best bet.

Second, Sidious being more powerful than Bane doesn't mean that the disparity is tremendous. They can still be on par with one having an edge.

Originally posted by Existentialist
a lot of people think Bandon could take Dooku,

And they would be right.

Originally posted by ares834
And they would be right

to kill themselves, yes.

Originally posted by Existentialist
to kill themselves, yes.

😆

Despite what you apparently think, I do not blindly accept what people here say. I consider Bane to be on par with Sidious, and I say, "some people" because I am not the only one.

I've actually been here since '04, and Gideon wasn't as uber as you try to make him seem. He was good at it though.

And they are right. Bandon could TOTALLY take them.

Originally posted by Pwned
Despite what you apparently think, I do not blindly accept what people here say.

I'm sure.

Originally posted by Pwned
I consider Bane to be on par with Sidious, and I say, "some people" because I am not the only one.

I'm sure Goebbels wasn't the only one who believed Hitler was a cool dude, too. See where I'm going with this?

Spoiler:
I kid, I kid

Originally posted by Pwned
I've actually been here since '04, and Gideon wasn't as uber as you try to make him seem. He was good at it though.

Nah, Gideon was definitely the best debater this place has ever seen. Eminence was good, too, though.

Originally posted by Pwned
Despite what you apparently think, I do not blindly accept what people here say. I consider Bane to be on par with Sidious, and I say, "some people" because I am not the only one.

I've actually been here since '04, and Gideon wasn't as uber as you try to make him seem. He was good at it though.

And they are right. Bandon could TOTALLY take them.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
You're join date is 2010... 😕

lol

Edit - If I reported you right now it's very likely you would get permenantly banned... lol

I wouldn't do that though. 😄

Originally posted by Pwned
Funny, many people here consider Bane to be roughly on par with Sidious.

In that case then Bane must be miles above Plagueis. Afterall, Palpatine can move at sublight speeds.

Originally posted by Nephthys
In that case then Bane must be miles above Plagueis. Afterall, Palpatine can move at sublight speeds.

😂

You're so butthurt. Wait 'til you see his arguments about Plagueis.

Let me guess, he can blow up galaxies with his farts.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Let me guess, he can blow up galaxies with his farts.

I honestly can't wait for both debates between you two; he's attacking two of your very favorite characters, which means you'll engage with superhuman ferocity. It will be popcorn-grade entertainment.

Now go please me. uhuh

Originally posted by Darth Ray Park
lol

Edit - If I reported you right now it's very likely you would get permenantly banned... lol

I wouldn't do that though. 😄

Originally posted by Pwned
Actually, I had a whole different IP, and the only reason I made a new one was because I lost my previous email due to switching providers. Had no way to get the old one back.

Sucks when that happens.

Originally posted by Existentialist
Gideon was definitely the best debater this place has ever seen

Come to think of it, Gideon might disagree as well.

Originally posted by Zampanó
Come to think of it, Gideon might disagree as well.

As would his sock.