Captain America Shields Test

Originally posted by janus77
Pre Reboot Superman hitting it - Superman is bounced away, the shield is unblemished.

Thor charging Mjolnir and striking it - see Superman, only Thor might get KOed as a consequence too.

HOTM Hulk slamming it - The shield is shattered.

Superboy Prime's Heat Vision - The shield probably is damaged.

Silver Surfer point blank power cosmic blast - standard blast will do nothing, but his most powerful blast should break it.

Thanos blasting it - see Surfer.

Bonus: Classic Juggernaut rushes the shield. - Juggernaut is stopped, the shield remains unblemished.

I think that you may have opened a new portal to hell.

Every Superman/Surfer, Hulk/anyone thread is a new portal to hell, only most walk through without realising 😉.

Originally posted by Stoic
How do you think it does?

lol eggs

Originally posted by Silent Master
Going off on a tangent about eggs doesn't prove anything in regards to the shield.

Now, Can you prove that Superboy prime's hv is over 999 trillion times as powerful as Thor/Hulk's damage output?

It's harder to prove something true than false. To prove something false you provide a counterexample. I did. I showed that if an attack can't damage an object then that doesn't mean the object can withstand multiple times more force. Remember, a rule is only true if it is always true. Any counterexample proves the rule false.

But to prove that an attack is multiple times that of the durability of an object is simple. Just look at how the attack damaged the object. For example, it takes astronomically more power to pulverize the moon into dust than to break it into 1000 pieces. It takes astronomically more power to penetrate an object without any visible resistance (like a ghost) than to penetrate it with good resistance.

Now please don't argue just to win the debate. If I'm right then say so or prove how I'm not right. Even you can be bias at times.

Lastly, IMO Superman would have withstood being penetrated completely through by PF Cykes blast. This is because it didn't completely penetrate Thor.
Some where Cykes blast not penetrating the shield as proof Prime's hv won't penetrate. Superman can also withstand being penetrated completely through from Hulk's and Thor strikes. Sure they can damage him but they won't penetrate his being completely through. This shows that the shield is more durable than Superman's body. But it's not much more durable than Superman's body since it didn't withstand attacks greater than the things Superman has withstood. Otherwise we would have a no limits fallacy.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
lol eggs

The shield isn't an egg, therefore your example doesn't prove anything.

Now, Can you prove that Superboy prime's hv is over 999 trillion times as powerful as Thor/Hulk's damage output?

Originally posted by Silent Master
The shield isn't an egg, therefore your example doesn't prove anything.

Now, Can you prove that Superboy prime's hv is over 999 trillion times as powerful as Thor/Hulk's damage output?

The shield not being an egg is irrelevant to the rule you are imposing (Cap's shield is over 999 trillion times that of Thor/Hulk's output).

Thus you never proved that the shield can withstand 999 trillion times that of Thor's output.

Originally posted by h1a8
Superboy prime's hv went through Superman's shoulder like he was a ghost. That means the hv was over a thousand times more powerful than Superman's durability

Pls provide scan and pls provide proof of the numbers you mentioned.

😈

Originally posted by h1a8
The shield not being an egg is irrelevant to the rule you are imposing (Cap's shield is over 999 trillion times that of Thor/Hulk's output).

Thus you never proved that the shield can withstand 999 trillion times that of Thor's output.

Sure I did, just like you proved that SBP's hv was over a thousand times more powerful than Superman's durability.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Sure I did, just like you proved that SBP's hv was over a thousand times more powerful than Superman's durability.

Your proof is this rule:

If an attack can't damage ANY object then it would take a force over 999 trillion times greater to damage it.

Well an egg is [/b]ANY[b] object but fails at your rule. Thus your rule is false.

Now as far as my proof. I always give conservative lower bound estimates. This means the actual amount is much higher.
The level of penetration proves it. For example, a small insect can't penetrate the surface of water because the force of it's weight is less than the strength of the surface tension. But an object 1000 times more massive will.
Note: floating in water =/= not breaking the surface tension

Let's ignore my numbers and say I was wrong. Then it is still clear that penetrating something like a ghost shows many times that of what is being penetrated. I doubt that the shield is many times the durability of Superman, by feats. I'll be back later.

Pls provide scans that prove your point, h1. 🙂

H1 doesn't have any scans.

Hulk effortlessly ripped Adamantium and Uru like tissue paper. I see no reason on him "not" being able to rip Cap shield to shreds.

Originally posted by carver9
H1 doesn't have any scans.

Hulk effortlessly ripped Adamantium and Uru like tissue paper. I see no reason on him "not" being able to rip Cap shield to shreds.

Originally posted by Nihilist
still trying to pedal them lies eh Carter.

I don't care what your thoughts on involving Hulk. Back on topic, Hulk prevails.

Originally posted by carver9
I don't care what your thoughts on involving Hulk. Back on topic, Hulk prevails.

Originally posted by carver9
H1 doesn't have any scans.

Hulk effortlessly ripped Adamantium and Uru like tissue paper. I see no reason on him "not" being able to rip Cap shield to shreds.

Originally posted by Galan007
When did Hulk rip up Uru?

My bad, he broke Uru to get rid of the Serpents influence. He crumble his hammer in his hands with ease.

Originally posted by Nihilist
no cares what you thoughts are period you lying troll.

When you buy that medication to take care of that temper you have, holla at me but until then, Hulk>Thanos.

Originally posted by carver9
My bad, he broke Uru to get rid of the Serpents influence. He crumble his hammer in his hands with ease.

http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/9397730/10-12-2011_20.jpg.html

@Galan.