The Avengers Vs the Fantastic four Vs Xmen

Originally posted by Newjak
This statement I like it... ANOTHER!!!

Originally posted by Robtard
Until it's shown that some solid in question has some sort of 'affecting phased matter' attribute, yes. Why wouldn't I?

Are we really going to go to extremes and say Kitty can only phase through exact solids we've seen? Plaster wall, wood and concrete; nothing else? Cos if so, apply the same ridiculous limitations to Thor and Mjolnir.

Agreed with that.

I was just making a point. By the same logic that Mjolnir hasn't shown to affect phased objects she has no feats affecting all solid items......but my real point is affecting materials from Asgard or of a mystical nature.

Originally posted by Robtard
As I said, the Silver was a possible, not a certainty.

Originally posted by Newjak
How would it not be a certainty when we clearly see the Silver used to physically bypass her shield later?

I'm not disagreeing with you in terms of Surfer. I've since seen the that scene and he simply just sticks his head through, by all appearances.

see:

Originally posted by marwash22
that shield was shown to stop solid matter, if Kitty isn't solid, i don't see why it would stop her.