Avengers vs Death Eaters

Originally posted by Nephthys
No wizard ever actually apparates in combat.

Except when they do like at the Ministry of Magic battle.

Anyone have an objective argument in this thread? I have not seen a single objective argument from anyone (except myself).

Check the last page at the bottom.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Except when they do like at the Ministry of Magic battle.

Oh, you mean smoke-apparating. Whatever. Thor smites them from the sky.

Originally posted by Nephthys
No wizard ever actually apparates in combat.

NVM:

YouTube video

This is pretty incontrovertible. 😬

The gate clearly turns to smoke, not Snape.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Except when they do like at the Ministry of Magic battle.

Looks like DDMs full of shit. OMFG SURPRISE!

Sigh

He knows I'm just joshing with him, we bicker all the time. 😉

Thats not why i sighed lol. Im just BOOOOOOOORED.

As hell.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Anyone have an objective argument in this thread? I have not seen a single objective argument from anyone (except myself).

Originally posted by omgchos
Which is obvious to anyone who actually saw the scene.

Rob said something about another scene tho. I wanna know the general area of the movie its in. I dont want to watch either of the DH movies again if i can avoid it.

The thing about apparating is you either have a clear focus on a destination in mind or they will rip there body apart. Doing any extensive battle in this form would be very harmful.

Originally posted by omgchos
Rob said something about another scene tho. I wanna know the general area of the movie its in. I dont want to watch either of the DH movies again if i can avoid it.

I could be wrong in it being in TDH part 1, as most of the films run together for me. Or I could be going insane and no wizard ever passed through a gate in smoke form.

Sorry.

Originally posted by Robtard
I could be wrong in it being in TDH part 1, as most of the films run together for me. Or I could be going insane and no wizard ever passed through a gate in smoke form.

Sorry.

YouTube video

FF to 2:55

😬

That's pretty clear that Snape made the gate intangible. He even flicked his wand at it. And we see it rematerialise at about 3:03.

Still, the Death Eaters would win.

Edit: Seems others have already discussed this.

No. snape is trailing smoke as he passes through it. Not the only example of wizards going intangible, mind you.

Looks more like the gate turned to smoke and the "smoke trail" looks more like smoke being pushed forward/aside as Snape's passing, to me. /shrug

Why would Snape be waving his wand at the gate if he's turning intangible?

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Looks more like the gate turned to smoke and the "smoke trail" looks more like smoke being pushed forward/aside as Snape's passing, to me. /shrug

YouTube video

FF to :35, we can plainly see Death Eaters flying right through one another.

FF to 1:13, we can plainly see the Death Eaters going invisible as they circle the bridge.

And, at the end of the vid, as they appear from invisibility, the Death Eater on the right flies right through the Death Eater in the middle.

But hey, people will see what they want to see.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Why would Snape be waving his wand at the gate if he's turning intangible?