X-men Movie series vs Twilight Movie Series

X-men
Professor X(first class version)
Magneto(first class version)
Storm
Wolverine
Cyclops
Havok
Jean Grey(Last Stand Version)
Emma Frost(First Class)
Gambit(orgins)
NightCrawler
Azazel
Mystique
Sesbastion Shaw
Riptide
Juggernaut
Shawdowcat
Beast(last stand)
Iceman
vs

The Cullen
Wolfpack
Volturi

Plot 1: The X-men realize that a growing threat comes to them in the form of a new bread of vampires with special abilties like them. The fight takes place in a forest.

Plot 2: The twilight vampires and wolfpack learn the x-men are coming for them. They take off to the volturi place in italy where the x-men are waiting from them in an ambush with the volturi already taking down.

Mutants win.

Mutants win.

Sabastian Shaw could solo if someone could take Jane out quickly.

Originally posted by the ninjak
Sabastian Shaw could solo if someone could take Jane out quickly.

Jean Grey as in Phoenix? If so, she wins.

Assuming not, X-men are generally too slow.

Professor X(first class version)

- Assuming Bella's shield is effective, he won't be any use.

Magneto(first class version)

- Limited effectiveness, will die quickly. Could stay in the air, then he could possibly contribute.

Storm

- If she stays in the air, could do a little damage. Don't want to hear about cyclones, since she would kill friendlies.

Wolverine

- Slice and Dice a few, but gets KO'ed or incapacitated by venom.

Cyclops

- Could take out a few before dying.

Havok

- Same as Cyke.

Jean Grey(Last Stand Version)

- Dark Phoenix rapes. Normal Jean too slow + Bella's shield.

Emma Frost(First Class)

- Useless - Bella's shield and will get ripped apart easily.

Gambit(orgins)

- Too slow. Although could do some damage with constant AOE ground strikes to keep them at bay.

NightCrawler

- Kung fu won't do anything. Using his father's technique, he'll be useful.

Azazel

- A real threat. Could at least take out all the wolves.

Mystique

- Useless.

Sesbastion Shaw

- Major weapon. Hard to take down, physically invulnerable, and AOE energy attacks.

Riptide

- Possibly useful, but cannot target enemies only and extremely vulnerable.

Juggernaut

- Slow, but good distraction and could do some damage, especially against the wolves.

Shawdowcat

- Major threat, however may be taken down by Jane or Alec.

Beast(last stand)

- Useless.

Iceman

- Freeze the ground, make it slippery? Very vulnerable.

Overall, I would say Twilight wins, they are too fast, and too many. At most only half of the X-men are serious threats, and even then most are vulnerable. I'd say around 10 of them are useful. Compare that to the Twilight team, there are at least 60 of them, and that is a rough, very conservative estimate. Even without special abilities, they would win on physical stats and numbers alone.

.

Didn't Bella's ability only work on Twivamps? Otherwise all the Werewolves wouldn't have been able to transform considering they were in her area of influence. 😛

We will never know.

Regardless her power had a limited focus point once the action got heavy.
She could only focus on individual areas.
The Xmen have knowledge on the vamps abilities and Cyclops or Havok can blast her whilst Xavier mind rapes the lot of them. (did he perform he feat in Origins?)

Game Over Twivamps. Cyclop's and Havok's beams will force Bella to unfocus her power long enough for an easy takedown.

Azazel teleports Sabastian Shaw in the middle of the crowd and he stomps his foot and incinerates them.

Mutants 10/10 If Origins Xavier has the minp rape feat.

Magneto could fly up to max range and use Wolverine as his little flying indestructible adamantium slice and dicer doll. :-p

Would be fun to watch.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Magneto could fly up to max range and use Wolverine as his little flying indestructible adamantium slice and dicer doll. :-p

Would be fun to watch.

Wolverine spinning at 10,000 rpm on his tippy-toes with arms and claws stretched out = THE DEADLIEST DREIDAL KNOWN TO MAN

Originally posted by the ninjak
Didn't Bella's ability only work on Twivamps? Otherwise all the Werewolves wouldn't have been able to transform considering they were in her area of influence. 😛

We will never know.

Regardless her power had a limited focus point once the action got heavy.
She could only focus on individual areas.
The Xmen have knowledge on the vamps abilities and Cyclops or Havok can blast her whilst Xavier mind rapes the lot of them. (did he perform he feat in Origins?)

Game Over Twivamps. Cyclop's and Havok's beams will force Bella to unfocus her power long enough for an easy takedown.

Azazel teleports Sabastian Shaw in the middle of the crowd and he stomps his foot and incinerates them.

Mutants 10/10 If Origins Xavier has the minp rape feat.

Bella made a shield bubble protecting her entire "army" from outside powers. It didn't affect those inside. I'm not sure if the shield can protect from physical attacks like Havok or Cyclop's blast, but I do know it negated every mental attack, meaning Prof. X's and Jean Grey would be useless here unless they can enter that shield bubble.

Sebastian Shaw is the biggest challenge here, but if Twilight team has knowledge of Xmen then Jane takes out Sebastian Shaw first. Then there's Jane's brother, Alec. He has the power to cut off the senses of multiple targets. What's the Xmen gonna do if they can't see, hear, smell, or feel?

lols, Twilight dies

'nuff said end thread

Originally posted by the ninjak
Didn't Bella's ability only work on Twivamps? Otherwise all the Werewolves wouldn't have been able to transform considering they were in her area of influence. 😛

I could be wrong, but I remember her shield protecting wolves as well. She can also be selective in her shield, and it only blocks psychic powers.

Originally posted by the ninjak
Regardless her power had a limited focus point once the action got heavy.
She could only focus on individual areas.

I don't think so. I don't remember it very well, but I'm inclined to think she can shield en masse in the film since in the book she was such a threat because Jane and Alec's powers became useless.

Originally posted by the ninjak

The Xmen have knowledge on the vamps abilities and Cyclops or Havok can blast her whilst Xavier mind rapes the lot of them. (did he perform he feat in Origins?)

And the Vampires will have knowledge of the X-men and their capabilities. Cyclops/Havok will take a few simply because there are so much of them, it's likely they will tag some with wide blasts. However, they are very vulnerable.

Your whole argument here is based on Xavier, and there are no Origin feats. I'm assuming you mean First Class, which is the version being used. Nothing too impressive there either, nowhere near as good as Patrick Stewart. He had to use illusions against the soldiers (hiding in truck scene) AND they had to maintain silence otherwise the illusion may have been broken. And he was struggling to telepathically hold Shaw in place, and that is only one person. In my opinion, it would be equally hard if not even harder to control a vampire with telepathic powers.

If it was Patrick Stewart, then there could be a real case made, but even then you'd need a mighty good argument against Bella - which if anything is immune herself, and will target Xavier first if we are going with the prior knowledge scenario. However likewise, X-men would try to protect him.

Originally posted by the ninjak

Game Over Twivamps. Cyclop's and Havok's beams will force Bella to unfocus her power long enough for an easy takedown.

Nope. There are over 60 vampires + wolves. All superspeed, who can finger-flick them. There is no way Cyke/Havok can be that selective in their targets, otherwise someone else will kill them rather quickly. They will die either way, in my opinion.

Originally posted by the ninjak

Azazel teleports Sabastian Shaw in the middle of the crowd and he stomps his foot and incinerates them.

Possible. I don't think that is instant kill/win, but could be effective strategy. Shaw is a real threat no matter what unless they know to remove his helmet.

Jean Grey Last Stand version is Phoenix.

She solos, end of discussion.

Yeah i dont see the vamps tanking a disintegration from her. Especially on the scale at the end of last stand.

Originally posted by omgchos
Yeah i dont see the vamps tanking a disintegration from her. Especially on the scale at the end of last stand.

And if Alec completely disables her senses?

Originally posted by FrothByte
And if Alec completely disables her senses?

It's not like she cared about killing anyone.

Yeah shes not gonna take kindly to that.

I like my idea of the spinning Topverine of death, tho. :-p

Out of curiosity, what's the range of Alec's ability?

Originally posted by Nibedicus
I like my idea of the spinning Topverine of death, tho. :-p

Out of curiosity, what's the range of Alec's ability?

In the books I believe it's mentioned that he's used it on whole battlefields before.

As for the movies, well he was pretty much ready to use it on the Cullen's entire army if Bella didn't stop him, so.... how big was that area?

It's pretty unfair to put phoenix in this match. She was a cosmic entity. Completely whacko though, and will probably kill everyone else here not named Wolverine. I guess that counts as an X-men win, but I'm still not sure if her powers can get through Bella's shield. Phoenix's powers (at least on the movies) seemed to be based off Jean's telekinesis and telepathy (although incredibly amped up). Bella's shield has been shown to completely deaden mind powers.

Originally posted by FrothByte
In the books I believe it's mentioned that he's used it on whole battlefields before.

As for the movies, well he was pretty much ready to use it on the Cullen's entire army if Bella didn't stop him, so.... how big was that area?

It's pretty unfair to put phoenix in this match. She was a cosmic entity. Completely whacko though, and will probably kill everyone else here not named Wolverine. I guess that counts as an X-men win, but I'm still not sure if her powers can get through Bella's shield. Phoenix's powers (at least on the movies) seemed to be based off Jean's telekinesis and telepathy (although incredibly amped up). Bella's shield has been shown to completely deaden mind powers.

but remember jean is so powerful mind constrants didn't work on her and only pissed her off to where she distingrated everything. xavier was at his best when he tried this.