Originally posted by RobtardThis post is a concession since you wont address the question. No one takes you seriously.
Since you broke up your three previous "concession accepted" posts with one of your 'ignore/wait/repeat' tactic post, this doesn't count as a fourth-in-a-row "concession accepted".So you're back to number one. Shall you go for a second?
Originally posted by Robtard
You still have yet to explain how a bunch of wizards hiding and waiting behind a shield is a fight? Why does HP get to play hold-out-and-wait while the LoTR armies are forced to fight and exhaust themselves like idiots, killing themselves against a magical barrier repeatedly? Scripting is silly.Go back a couple pages. It's similar to what is HP's answer to a huge rampaging ghost army and hill sized giants made of stone.
Why wouldn't they fight that way? Did the humans not hide in Helm's Deep instead of charging out onto the plain to meet the Orcs? You're just being dense now. The fact is that the shielding is a viable means of defense, it's used in the largest scale battle of the film, and there's no reason it wouldn't be utilized against these "massive armies" you keep touting.
Answer the question: how would he LotR crew overcome this? How would they put arrows into wizards underneath a magic-empowered dome?
Originally posted by Ascendancy
Why wouldn't they fight that way? Did the humans not hide in Helm's Deep instead of charging out onto the plain to meet the Orcs? You're just being dense now. The fact is that the shielding is a viable means of defense, it's used in the largest scale battle of the film, and there's no reason it wouldn't be utilized against these "massive armies" you keep touting.Answer the question: how would he LotR crew overcome this? How would they put arrows into wizards underneath a magic-empowered dome?
Poor example; here's why: The humans went to Helms Deep as a last defense, they knew they were outmatched since they were broken and not unified due to Sauron's/Sarumon's meddling. Theodan mentions this. Once unified (in RoTK) they met their foe in the open field.
What's there to answer? If HP's "epic war" tactics are to hide behind a giant shield and play the waiting game, no other franchise can get to them except with the possibility of the sorcerers from The Sorcerer's Apprentice, but they're going to be busy fighting with 8 other franchise armies to worry about trying to break a shield that's off somewhere in the distance. But you have the gal to say I'm being dense?
Scripting is hilarious. Wizards make shield and hide behind it until all other 9 franchise armies have obliteration themselves and then pop out, cast a few spells ending the rabble that's left over and call it a win. Celebration time.
Originally posted by AscendancyThe best is when Lotr characters dig in deep its tactical but not when the Potterverse does so. What's hilarious is the stomp the Deatheaters would pull on Helms Deep with that weak force protecting it.
Why wouldn't they fight that way? Did the humans not hide in Helm's Deep instead of charging out onto the plain to meet the Orcs? You're just being dense now. The fact is that the shielding is a viable means of defense, it's used in the largest scale battle of the film, and there's no reason it wouldn't be utilized against these "massive armies" you keep touting.Answer the question: how would he LotR crew overcome this? How would they put arrows into wizards underneath a magic-empowered dome?
Originally posted by quanchi112
The best is when Lotr characters dig in deep its tactical but not when the Potterverse does so. What's hilarious is the stomp the Deatheaters would pull on Helms Deep with that weak force protecting it.
Yeah, it's clear that Robtard refuses to play this straight. Use tactics shown in the films in other threads and it's the norm, but here it's being cowardly. We're assuming a war where if you lose you die, so why would you take unnecessary risks?
Even out in the open there are far too many mass spells and summonable monsters for massive armies to stand a chance. Potter's crew isn't unstoppable, but they are far superior here.
Originally posted by AscendancyThis isn't the only thread he does it in. Pay attention to him in other threads. He's a huge hypocrite and uses self serving logic from thread to thread. I can't believe no one has called him on it before.
Yeah, it's clear that Robtard refuses to play this straight. Use tactics shown in the films in other threads and it's the norm, but here it's being cowardly. We're assuming a war where if you lose you die, so why would you take unnecessary risks?Even out in the open there are far too many mass spells and summonable monsters for massive armies to stand a chance. Potter's crew isn't unstoppable, but they are far superior here.
Originally posted by RobtardYou clearly don't understand his posts if you think his point is HP doesn't stand a chance. You need a tutor.
Sure, ignore that I painted your "they're just going to hide and wait from the start" premise to be laughably bad, as all scripting is.Never mind that by doing so you're admitting that HP doesn't have a chance here against the heaviest hitting franchise, LoTR.
Originally posted by RobtardOne half creates the shield and the other half blitz them via Deathly Hallows part 2. Aerial advantages as well as Dementors stomping the weak armies from Lotr.
You don't even understand your own thread and the conditions you set. Each franchise army is 50 miles apart and you think HP can win by creating a giant shield and hiding behind it when the fight starts.That's essentially a no-show for the battle and akin to a forfeit. Cry more now.