Revan -vs- Darth Vader

Started by shinkoryu6 pages

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Mr. Drew revealed to me that Revan was skilled in all forms of lightsaber combat. However, his style was unpredictable.

.

What drew claims isn't canon until its actually written down in either a sourcebook or a novel. Because drew has also revealed to me that Revan has no dick.

Seriously quit bothering drew with your constant emails of sexual harassment you smelly curry muncher.

Originally posted by shinkoryu
Seriously quit bothering drew with your constant emails of sexual harassment you smelly curry muncher.

If reading those emails keeps Karpyshyn glued to his inbox and away from Microsoft Word and Star Wars, then keep 'em coming.

Fair point, hes a piss poor writer anyway.

I'd say he's a piss poor novelist (though that's a generous assessment of his abilities). As a writer, in a collaborative effort, he's produced excellent work.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
I'd say he's a piss poor novelist (though that's a generous assessment of his abilities). As a writer, in a collaborative effort, he's produced excellent work.
The only good "writing" iv seen him do is Mass effect, which even then is a pretty dull story. All his other novels were utter crap that he spewed from his ahnus.

I love Mass Effect. KotOR is pretty good, too.

Ahrael, your "arguments" are creeping over into Retard-territory, again. 😛

I just gave you Canon proof of Vader's speed being inhibited greatly by his armor and prosthetics, so be aware of that.


You gave proof that his armor weights a lot, not that his speed is reduced. Within the same book he gets used to his armor and readjusts his style. His single swing knocked two Jedi over, that's how strong he was. Such strength is more than sufficient to move as fast as others despite heavy armor. Moreover, in the same book he blitzed other Jedi. This is canon proof that his weight of armor doesn't prevent him from being as deadly as ever with lightsaber.

Except for his physical-showings in A New Hope. 🙄

🙄

And Ferus Olin's account of Vader's "speed" is inconsistent, because during his time in the Order, he would have seen a few Jedi, a physically-prime Obi-wan Kenobi among them, being able to move much faster than Vader.

During his time in order he personally knew Anakin and Kenobi and participated with them on the same missions. So basically what you just said is void.

As for old Kenobi you still haven't provided any evidence that he got slower. Yoda was in far worse condition, he couldn't even walk properly, yet, his speed did not suffer from it.

This:
"Executing a move of incredible swiftness for one so old, Kenobi lunged at the massive shape. Vader blocked the stab with equal speed, riposting with a counterslash that Kenobi barely parried. Another parry and Kenobi countered again, using this opportunity to move around the towering Dark Lord.

They continued to trade blows, with the old man now backing toward the hangar."

Vader matched Kenobi's speed and nearly killed him with first counterattack.

I was however, going off the earlier hypothesis of a few others, that Marek was apparently lacking in skill, due to his showings.

The only thing that was apparent from the book is that his opponents were immensely powerful in their own right.

His first opponent - Kota could literally reflect any Force attack including lightning. Moreover, he could block lightsaber attacks and dodge telekinetic projectiles while Force choked. In comparison look how helpless Kenobi, Anakin and Dooku are, when Force choked.

And Shaak Ti on her death gave Force explosion, which is not even common for lightsiders.

Originally posted by shinkoryu
What drew claims isn't canon until its actually written down in either a sourcebook or a novel.

It still is useful information.

Originally posted by shinkoryu
Because drew has also revealed to me that Revan has no dick.

No, you are lying.

Originally posted by shinkoryu
Seriously quit bothering drew with your constant emails of sexual harassment you smelly curry muncher.

I won't.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
It still is useful information.
No it isn't.
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

No, you are lying.
No im not. Do you get my point now?
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

I won't.

So you're close to 30 years old and you still sexually harass a piss poor novelist for "feats" of a fictional character?

Go out and get some hoes mate, and take a shower while you're at it you smelly paki.

Originally posted by shinkoryu
No it isn't.

Not for you perhaps.

Originally posted by shinkoryu
No im not. Do you get my point now?

You got such an email from Drew? Show it to us.

Originally posted by shinkoryu
So you're close to 30 years old and you still sexually harass a piss poor novelist for "feats" of a fictional character?

Go out and get some hoes mate, and take a shower while you're at it you smelly paki,


Please keep these idiotic comments to yourself. Act mature.

Originally posted by shinkoryu

Go out and get some hoes mate, and take a shower while you're at it you smelly paki.

Do you mean Pakistani? If so I'd advise you apologize for that comment right now.

Also a bit lame you calling him sad for asking Drew questions about a character's abilities when your on here discussing the same thing yourself.

And I'm sure SWL is above resorting to hoes.

Originally posted by Arhael
You gave proof that his armor weights a lot, not that his speed is reduced. Within the same book he gets used to his armor and readjusts his style. His single swing knocked two Jedi over, that's how strong he was.

He's like a fully trained and highly skilled version Opress 😄

Originally posted by Arhael
Such strength is more than sufficient to move as fast as others despite heavy armor. Moreover, in the same book he blitzed other Jedi. This is canon proof that his weight of armor doesn't prevent him from being as deadly as ever with lightsaber.

Yep he also blitzes Jedi in Purge. His Cyborg legs should easily be able to carry his weight and run fast just like Grievous and CW Maul do. And his Cyborg arms should still be able to swing fast. Just like Grievous and ROTS Anakin could.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Not for you perhaps.
Not for anyone for that matter

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

You got such an email from Drew? Show it to us.
Again, what drew claims is irrelevant.
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Please keep these idiotic comments to yourself. Act mature.
Not with some curry muncher

So Shink is a notorious troll. I suggest just spamming this picture until it goes away:

Originally posted by Zampanó
So Shink is a notorious troll. I suggest just spamming this picture until it goes away:

thumbup1

Originally posted by shinkoryu

Not with some curry muncher

This is your last warning before I report you for your racist remarks.

In this troll's defense, "curry muncher" sounds hilarious.

Is this funny as well:

Originally posted by shinkoryu
and take a shower while you're at it you smelly paki.

Sorta.

Yup. What is it with this pathetically sensitive generation?

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
This is your last warning before I report you for your racist remarks.
Ooooh im scared to get banned on an INTERNET FORUM! Go ahead you angel wanna be, i bet you're the kind of geek who thinks he can get laid if he is a white knight on the internet.