Maul Brothers vs. Bane

Started by jmoul18 pages

Maul Brothers vs. Bane

Got this idea from my Maul vs. Bane thread. Savage and Maul face off with Bane in the Geonossian arena. Maul is TCW version. Three all-out rounds:

1. PoD Bane
2. RoT Bane
3. DoE Bane

Unless Bane is in Orbalisk Brothers should take it.

I think Current Maul even on his own can put up a decent fight against Bane.

He's quite powerful in the Force now able to Force choke the wind out of Kenobi (Sith Hunters) and toss a Jedi Craft pretty fast. And even though he's below Kenobi in Sabers, it's clearly not a huge gap when you look at their one on one's.

Then there's Opress who though untrained clearly knows how to wield a Lightsaber and has Monstrous strength and a mean Force Wave which has floored both Kenobi and Skywalker on more than 1 occasion.

Lastly even Sidious feels the need to use Jar Kai when fighting both brothers so unless Bane's Jar Kai skills are up to scratch and he has a spare Saber, he'll likely lose against both Brothers.

RoT Bane implies orbalisks, so for one round, yes, he is in Orbalisk armor

In orbs he takes them. Near invulnerability & stamina enhancement that allow him to focus entirely on offense leaves the brothers dead.

His speed by DoE is such that he is certainly capable of standing toe-to-toe with a pair of foes at once. That and his Force abilities should help him take the day, but it would honestly be a near thing. It's not like even Sidious stomped the pair and he knew Maul inside and out.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Unless Bane is in Orbalisk Brothers should take it.

I think Current Maul even on his own can put up a decent fight against Bane.

He's quite powerful in the Force now able to Force choke the wind out of Kenobi (Sith Hunters) and toss a Jedi Craft pretty fast. And even though he's below Kenobi in Sabers, it's clearly not a huge gap when you look at their one on one's.

Then there's Opress who though untrained clearly knows how to wield a Lightsaber and has Monstrous strength and a mean Force Wave which has floored both Kenobi and Skywalker on more than 1 occasion.

Lastly even Sidious feels the need to use Jar Kai when fighting both brothers so unless Bane's Jar Kai skills are up to scratch and he has a spare Saber, he'll likely lose against both Brothers.

Did you just imply Sidious needed Jarkai to deal with the Maul brothers? 😘

Bane beats these posers as easily as Sidious did. Easier with Orbalisks.

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
Did you just imply Sidious needed Jarkai to deal with the Maul brothers? 😘

I implied that he clearly felt Jar Kai would be needed hence why he brought 2 Sabers to the fight.

Anyway if Sidious could beat them both with a single Saber then he should have done so to prove it.

But as far as the evidence goes, all we know is that he can beat them wielding dual swords. And as Obi-Wan's fight with the brothers proved, that second Saber clearly helps when dealing with both of them.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Bane beats these posers as easily as Sidious did. Easier with Orbalisks.

You think Bane is a match for Sidious?

Even if he is, is he as skilled in wielding Jar Kai? Because last I heard Kas'im was beating him in Sabers when he switched to Jar Kai.

Nah brothers should win this one except when Bane has Orbalisk.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
You think Bane is a match for Sidious?

Even if he is, is he as skilled in wielding Jar Kai? Because last I heard Kas'im was beating him in Sabers when he switched to Jar Kai.

Nah brothers should win this one except when Bane has Orbalisk.

Yes.

No, I don't think he is. I do however think that your implication that he needs it is quite ludicrous. Bane is fast and skilled enough to fight more than one opponent at once with a single lightsaber. And Jar'Kai is not a requirement of doing so in the first place.

What if Bane incinerates Savage at the start of the fight? Dude can't block Force Lightning for shit so he's out of the game in that case.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Yes.

No, I don't think he is. I do however think that your implication that he needs it is quite ludicrous. Bane is fast and skilled enough to fight more than one opponent at once with a single lightsaber. And Jar'Kai is not a requirement of doing so in the first place.

What if Bane incinerates Savage at the start of the fight? Dude can't block Force Lightning for shit so he's out of the game in that case.

Dooku for all his great force powers and saber prowess was just about getting the edge over Opress and Ventress with a single Saber.

If you think Bane's is going to do just as well against Maul and Opress then you must think he's considerably above Count Dooku.

And Opress isn't just going to get incinerated with 1 blast of Force Lightning. He took many many blasts from Count Dooku and wasn't even KO'd.

And yes, Bane is superior to Dooku. His Force Powers are more lethal (you'll never seen Dooku kill someone with a burst of lightning or a single Force Push like you will Bane) and Bane has greater speed feats than him, is stronger and arguably has a similar degree of lightsaber skill. Bane is just an all-around superior combatant.

However, you can't just base things off of ABC logic. Dooku clearly couldn't engage Savage whereas Bane can, being bigger and stronger. So Dooku's big thing, lightsaber combat, was stunted in its effectiveness. Bane also has more devestating Force powers.

Dooku's lightning is.... mediocre. He certainly has never turned a being to ash in the way Bane has. The fact that Savage doesn't seem to know how to block Force Lightning renders him utterly exposed to Bane's lightning. Why wouldn't it incinerate him? Savage has no innate Force-resistance, without the ability to block Bane with the Force, he will be incinerated. And then it's just Maul.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Dooku clearly couldn't engage Savage whereas Bane can, being bigger and stronger. So Dooku's big thing, lightsaber combat, was stunted in its effectiveness. Bane also has more devestating Force powers.

Nah it was just difficult for him to deal with while fighting off a second opponent. Maul easily deflected Opress's blows with what seemed like some elegant Makashi. As Dooku did himself to Opress in their sparring session.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Why wouldn't it incinerate him?

Because he's a physical beast with body armor and with clearly a lot of raw power in the Force on top.

Just in terms of his physical abilities he's taken blaster shots head on.

And then there's the fact that he's taken not just one shot of FL from Count Dooku. But several without even being KO'd.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Savage has no innate Force-resistance,

Where are you getting this from?

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Nah it was just difficult for him to deal with while fighting off a second opponent. Maul easily deflected Opress's blows with what seemed like some elegant Makashi. As Dooku did himself to Opress in their sparring session.

Didn't seem to bother him. He was cool with simply dodging around Savage. It was only after he tried to actually block one of his blows that he got thrown across the room.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Because he's a physical beast with body armor and with clearly a lot of raw power in the Force on top.

Just in terms of his physical abilities he's taken blaster shots head on.

And then there's the fact that he's taken not just one shot of FL from Count Dooku. But several without even being KO'd.

Because big and strong doesn't mean you can resist millions of volts of Force lightning. 😐

Ok, then his armored body might be relatively intact. His head will still be dust on the wind though.

Yeah because Dooku's lightning is hella weak.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Where are you getting this from?

Zabraks aren't Force-resistant. 😉

And unless theres some evidence that Opress is a special case or that he is, why should be believe he is without any evidence?

Bane beats these posers as easily as Sidious did. Easier with Orbalisks.

Or Maul Force chokes him or either brother knocked him down with a Force blast. 😉

You'll never seen Dooku kill someone with a burst of lightning or a single Force Push like you will Bane

Dooku's feats come from film and CW, where you will never see Sidious do that either.

and Bane has greater speed feats than him

No, he doesn't.

Dooku's lightning is.... mediocre. He certainly has never turned a being to ash in the way Bane has.

Neither did Palpatine, so what? In Drew's books 6 year old child can vaporize with TK. Dooku never did that either, so he is below untrained child?

Originally posted by Arhael
Or Maul Force chokes him or either brother knocked him down with a Force blast. 😉

WTF? You seriously think Maul has enough Force prowess to choke Bane? What a joke. Bane can ragdoll both brothers when it comes to TK, lightning, and techniques they've never even seen.

The only reason they have a chance is that for a time it may be close saber combat only, and even then Bane wins the day, especially with Orbs.

I think Bane takes it in sabers in RoT and DoE, and in force and all out in all 3.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Nah it was just difficult for him to deal with while fighting off a second opponent. Maul easily deflected Opress's blows with what seemed like some elegant Makashi. As Dooku did himself to Opress in their sparring session.

Because he's a physical beast with body armor and with clearly a lot of raw power in the Force on top.

Just in terms of his physical abilities he's taken blaster shots head on.

And then there's the fact that he's taken not just one shot of FL from Count Dooku. But several without even being KO'd.

Where are you getting this from?

lol...

How have you not played Kotor already you noob!

WTF? You seriously think Maul has enough Force prowess to choke Bane? What a joke.

I was just mocking at how Nephtys makes absolute statements despite the fact that these characters are from completely different era with completely different Force portrayal making it impossible to make even relative comparison.

Anyway, what a joke is your statement. I have a revelation for you. Having "enough Force prowess" has nothing to do with ability to Force handle others.

Ventress Force choked Kenobi and Anakin. Was she more powerful than both of them combined? Definately not.

Opress choked Dooku and Ventress. Was he more powerful than both of them combined? Definately not.

Ashoka Force pushed Ventress across entire room into a pipe. Was she at least remotely as powerful as Ventress? Definately not.

Finally, Luke tanked all Abeloth's Force attacks as well as outwrestled her. Had he more prowess than her? Definately not.

I hope you get the point. Skill has much more relevance than prowess.

Kenobi demonstrated that he can't simply be overpowered. When Dooku tried to electrocute him, he casually blocked it with lightsaber in one hand. When Opress gave his rage boosted wave that destroyed all the droids aroind, Kenobi tanked it. When Anakin tried to overpower him, Kenobi stalemated him. Maul's Force attacks were instant enough to leave Kenobi no chance to anticipate it and put up adequate Force defence.

Whatever power Bane possess, it will be of no use, if he fails to anticipate opponent's Force attack.

Bane can ragdoll both brothers when it comes to TK

This claim is especially funny considering that even Sidious did not ragdoll them.

lol...

How have you not played Kotor already you noob!


The gamer has spoken. pray

When Opress unleashed his Force wave in "Witches of the Mist," Obi-Wan was put on his ass.

Arhael
This claim is especially funny considering that even Sidious did not ragdoll them.

Have you not seen the fight? Sidious ragdolls them multiple times with the Force.


Have you not seen the fight? Sidious ragdolls them multiple times with the Force. [/B]

Can't wait to see.

Yeah watch the fight. Then tell me with a straight face that Bane would beat both brothers together.

Heck he'd have enough trouble against Maul alone.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Bane beats these posers as easily as Sidious did. Easier with Orbalisks.
This. Sids kicked their asses with casual ease. Bane would too.