Superman VS Marvel: Slugfest Gauntlet

Started by Dolos22 pages

How about instead of bringing up a scan you just reference the comic issue?

Originally posted by Damborgson
The world engine is unquantifiable now?

Didn't you know? For some strange reason, all of Thor's high end strength displays are now unquantifiable non-feats that are heretofore banned from the VS forums.

💃

Which feat is the world engine feat?

@Diesldude...

Lol...Hulk has shown the ability to adapt, don't know why you keep debating on Hulk when you know minimum about the character.

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Hulk%20Powers/HulkEvolution03.jpg

http://s388.beta.photobucket.com/user/OneDumbG0/media/Hulk%20Powers/HulkEvolution06v39.jpg.html

There are more adaptive scans but whats the point of me posting them? You should have known this stuff (lol).

Also, lol, it was stated that Doomsday strength amps during the time he is anger but again, you should know this stuff...lol.

Doomsday doesn't amp like Hulk does any more than Superman does. Come on Carver. At least read up on the characters you're supposed to be debating.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Doomsday doesn't amp like Hulk does any more than Superman does. Come on Carver. At least read up on the characters you're supposed to be debating.

It's different though. It was specifically stated he amped off of his anger. This doesn't apply to Superman.

Originally posted by carver9
It's different though. It was specifically stated he amped off of his anger. This doesn't apply to Superman.

Superman amps off of his emotional state, which includes anger. Doomsday is the same. He's more like Superman than Hulk, like I said.

Them both being Kryptonian, and all.

And their status is still completely different.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Superman amps off of his emotional state, which includes anger. Doomsday is the same. He's more like Superman than Hulk, like I said.

Them both being Kryptonian, and all.

And their status is still completely different.

Just because they have the same source of power doesn't make them exact equals. Hulk and Doomsday are pretty much the same character with power source exemptions. Don't know what else to tell you if you don't think this. They have the SAME abilities, everything to the tee minus power source.

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Didn't you know? For some strange reason, all of Thor's high end strength displays are now unquantifiable non-feats that are heretofore banned from the VS forums.

💃

Yeah someone's up to something...

I have my suspicions:

Originally posted by carver9
Just because they have the same source of power doesn't make them exact equals. Hulk and Doomsday are pretty much the same character with power source exemptions. Don't know what else to tell you if you don't think this. They have the SAME abilities, everything to the tee minus power source.

Theyre not close to being the same character. They dont fill the same role in stories, and the only thing they have in common is powerset. Hulk is, like i said more like superman than he'll ever be like doomsday.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Not good enough Abhi. 👇 So I guess it is. To a point.

You're the one who wanted to compare. You get first go.


Why would that be quantifiable anyway? Do you know what size World-engine was compared to a physical body we can measure? Connected to nine worlds isn't the proof of how big it was.

You are the one who claimed Thor's feats are better than hulk. Post a feat and I would counter it.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Theyre not close to being the same character. They dont fill the same role in stories, and the only thing they have in common is powerset. Hulk is, like i said more like superman than he'll ever be like doomsday.

My entire post was based on their power, not their personality. Everything about Doomsday smells like Hulk minus the bones coming out of his skin. They are "physically" the same character minus a couple of differences.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Theyre not close to being the same character. They dont fill the same role in stories, and the only thing they have in common is powerset. Hulk is, like i said more like superman than he'll ever be like doomsday.
characterwise, you're right, but carv does have a point. in terms of design, doomsday was built on a hulk template

Originally posted by carver9
My entire post was based on their power, not their personality. Everything about Doomsday smells like Hulk minus the bones coming out of his skin. They are "physically" the same character minus a couple of differences.

I already said that they had similar powersets. That's not what I'm talking about. They don't fit in the same role, they aren't written the same, nor are they meant to come across the same. You could argue that Hulk is Grundy a lot more than he's Doomsday.

Originally posted by 753
characterwise, you're right, but carv does have a point. in terms of design, doomsday was built on a hulk template

I never denied that.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Why would that be quantifiable anyway? Do you know what size World-engine was compared to a physical body we can measure? Connected to nine worlds isn't the proof of how big it was.

You are the one who claimed Thor's feats are better than hulk. Post a feat and I would counter it.

Of course not, even with its connection to the 9 worlds, there's no hardcore proof he was moving 9 planets or something. Yggrdasil however, was being moved and it's f*cking huge.

That's the only scan I could find about its scale by the way. Generously provided by Biensalsa's videos 👆

So it is indeed quantifiable, with the battle of wills being the unquantifiable. And the connection to the other realms also being the unquantifiable.

😬 You extended the challenge, I accepted, but I don't play to other peoples' tunes. So if you want to get something out of this go for it. Otherwise don't. I don't particularly care either way.

and if it's just going to turn into a simple I'll post something, you'll post something you see as better then we argue about it for 6 posts until PR tells us to get away from each other, it's not going to go anywhere anyway.

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
I conceded a BALANCED outcome.

Oh and about your previous post of taking this personally, not at all dude. That thing is getting kind of old and has been used before.

So, no! 😄

You conceded that your opinion has no bearing on a forum fight. Victory.

Originally posted by LordofBrooklyn
This is a scenario that I think even Carver and Quanchi will agree with.

Superman lands the first punch given his speed advantage. For an opponent of comprable size I pick classic Mongol. Superman should land at least another shot before Hulk can respond.

No speedblitz, just a simple one-two combo.

Not at all. Hulk wins either way but in a slugfest where they exchange punches I'd give the Hulk, 10/10.

If they take turns, punch for punch, hulk won't get a turn if superman goes first.

Originally posted by Diesldude
If they take turns, punch for punch, hulk won't get a turn if superman goes first.
Based on what ?

Originally posted by Damborgson
Of course not, even with its connection to the 9 worlds, there's no hardcore proof he was moving 9 planets or something. Yggrdasil however, was being moved and it's f*cking huge.

That's the only scan I could find about its scale by the way. Generously provided by Biensalsa's videos 👆

So it is indeed quantifiable, with the battle of wills being the unquantifiable. And the connection to the other realms also being the unquantifiable.

😬 You extended the challenge, I accepted, but I don't play to other peoples' tunes. So if you want to get something out of this go for it. Otherwise don't. I don't particularly care either way.

and if it's just going to turn into a simple I'll post something, you'll post something you see as better then we argue about it for 6 posts until PR tells us to get away from each other, it's not going to go anywhere anyway.


That's obviously just an interpretation of Asgardian myth. Yggrdasil was never shown as that way in that comic and Earth was certainly never seen as surrounded by green trees and shit. Its just like the myth about Midgard Serpent, it was never that huge in actual appearance. If we actually believe that the tree was that heavy, hulk has still better feats than that. Gravage hulk moves tectonic plates of Sakaar

http://www.mynetimages.com/9794cc4c21_ga.jpg
http://www.mynetimages.com/d8faca4b4a_ga.jpg

FYI even Earth's tectonic plates weight around 1 sextillion ton. Sakaar was twice the size of earth IIRC.

Not when you made a claim which can't be supported by facts.

You people know that its worthless to argue with Quan, right? He's just derailing the thread.