Beta Ray Bill vs Supergirl

Started by abhilegend34 pages

Who cares about what you think? Post a proof or STFU.

Abhi, cut it out.

Carver, stop trolling.

^Sorry, he's just flat out wrong here as usual and trying to pass it as truth.

Nice to see the war between Abhi and Carver hasn't died.

Originally posted by abhilegend
^Sorry, he's just flat out wrong here as usual and trying to pass it as truth.

Stop bashing.

^You've already warned me. I would stop.
fear

SG easily,supergirl strength could match wonder woman who almost as strong as superman even help him move the earth,thor or bill never has like this feats,marvel fanboys always let me lol

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Wow. Bottom line is the other 3 had a hand in decelerating that ship to prevent it from destroying a continent. It's a shared feat. Again it's true Supes was the main contributor, but one must be either blind or choosing to be blind to say that he did it all by himself.

On this thread,i would be says SG wins,the bill not really take down a planet buster and this ship Includes a pocket universe could be destroy the earth by overspeed,they are can stopping it,superman once move the earth,supergirl also could be do it,thor or bill cant
i dont know this pocket universe how size but at least enough destroy the earth,even you says destroy earth need speed

Originally posted by a88378438
On this thread,i would be says SG wins,the bill not really take down a planet buster and this ship Includes a pocket universe could be destroy the earth by overspeed,they are can stopping it,superman once move the earth,supergirl also could be do it,thor or bill cant
i dont know this pocket universe how size but at least enough destroy the earth,even you says destroy earth need speed

bangin

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
bangin

You dont need do this,I'm not a fangirls,I'm talk the true,thor or bill never move the earth even need help,thor+bill lift a city?sure,superman,wonder woman,MM move the earth

bill

Not sure if this has been asked before, forgive me if it has, I know Beta Ray Bill is similar to Thor, but I'm not sure to what extent:

Does Beta Ray Bill's hammer have a "no one but Bill can lift or palm this thing!" clause, like Mjolnir, or no?

Because this version of Supergirl was pretty resourceful at using opponent's weapons against them, demonstrating this perhaps most famously by stealing John Stewart's Green Lantern ring and using it against him (Supergirl #4, Volume 5), even as she found a way to use Cassandra (Wonder Girl) Sandsmark's own lasso to take Cassie down a few issues prior (Supergirl #2, Volume 5).

Note that Sandsmark's Lasso is or was a god-blessed weapon that channeled magic lightning ...

Originally posted by bluewaterrider
this version of Supergirl was pretty resourceful at using opponent's weapons against them, demonstrating this perhaps most famously by stealing John Stewart's Green Lantern ring ...
Originally posted by bluewaterrider
this version of Supergirl was pretty resourceful at using opponent's weapons against them, demonstrating this perhaps most famously by stealing John Stewart's Green Lantern ring and using it against him (Supergirl #4, Volume 5)

Originally posted by bluewaterrider

found a way to use Cassandra (Wonder Girl) Sandsmark's own lasso to take Cassie down ... (Supergirl #2, Volume 5).

Note that Sandsmark's Lasso is or was a god-blessed weapon that channeled [b]magic lightning ... [/B]

I never thought about that. Stormbreaker doesn't have the worthy enchantment on it. That makes Thor>>>>Bill IMO. Someone can just take Bill's hammer away easily.

....

Bill's hammer has a worthiness enchantment on it.

supergirl take it

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
....

Bill's hammer has a worthiness enchantment on it.

I'm not sure that's true.

I went and looked up "Stormbreaker" on Marvel Wikia just now.

The site says there is no proof.

It also goes on to say that Eric Masterson was able to wield Stormbreaker in place of Bill, as was Thor himself, as were several Skrulls. Eric and Thor can be argued as "worthy", given that they are Uru hammer wielder themselves and Thor avatars, but ... the Skrulls? That tells me either there is NO worthy enchantment on the thing, the requirements for "worthiness" are lower on it, or the Skrulls were very clever about circumventing that clause.

For the sake of argument, though, I'll simply give my opinion for both cases.

1) Supergirl, if Stormbreaker is user-friendly ...

2) Undecided, at this point, if Stormbreaker is Beta Ray Bill exclusive.

The reasons for being undecided at this point are

a) I am not sure how much fight experience BRB has

b) I am not sure how likely Beta Ray Bill is to teleport opponents in battle

and

c) I am not sure how strategically Beta Ray Bill thinks

If he's a straight brawler like Thor but without Thor's fight experience, I give it to Supergirl, who, from what I can tell, is stronger, faster, and marginally tougher than BRB, especially if we're going with the pre Sterling Gates version of her.

Marvel Wikia and Handbooks and the like are nice, but the actual comics supersede those.

And in this comic I'm looking at right now, #412 of Mighty Thor, the worthiness enchantment is clearly in effect.

As far as the Skrulls go...they made Galactus skrulls (wtf) and were able to fool Marvel Earth with their sleeper agents, bypassing Richards level tech and fooling even the most practiced mages. They even had their own "gods", so the Skrulls being able to work around Stormbreaker's enchantment with off panel shenanigans isn't the craziest thing in the world.

Still, for all intents and purposes under typical circumstances, Stormbreaker has a worthiness enchantment.