Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Gillard is more important than Lucas in regards to versus, Ziggy.
You're literally giving me a hernia.
Are Gillard's statements a source viewed as canon by LFL - like Lucas' are - or is it merely his personal thoughts which - at the end of the day - don't mean anything under the laws of LFL canon (legends)? I believe The latter is correct.
Now you might want to understand why Lucas' opinion - was at the time - considered the indisputable word of god. Star Wars stories does not have a single writer, and the collaborators may not actually agree with interpretations of their story that weren't made explicit in the work - i.e canon. In this case, there are multiple creators giving potentially contradictory explanations, so whose word is to be considered correct? Nick Gillard was not the copyright holder, meaning that he was not the highest authority. Lucas was - at the time - the chief copyright holder. Everything in Star Wars was his intellectual property. All characters, concepts, planets and stories belonged in his name, up until Disney's renovation in 2014. Now that's just from a legal perspective. From an intellectual perspective, all continuity created outside of the films stemmed from Lucas' vision of Star Wars. The Force, midi-chrlorians a Galaxy far far away, are all ideas that a taken into consideration when creating characters like Revan.
Lucas is the only creator, and he is certainly more important than someone involved in an ancillary role for the production.
Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Why Shaak, huh?WHY SHAAK
Why do I hate her?
Jensaarai, Reti and Evan wank her so hard it's turned me against her. Saying her Makashi is as good as Dooku's, saying her force defense is enough for her to contend with Palpatine, Shaak and Plo > Anakin etc.
It's all too much and driven me insane, I ****ing hate her with a passion
Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Why do I hate her?
Jensaarai, Reti and Evan wank her so hard it's turned me against her. Saying her Makashi is as good as Dooku's, saying her force defense is enough for her to contend with Palpatine, Shaak and Plo > Anakin etc.
It's all too much and driven me insane, I ****ing hate her with a passion
You should hate the debater in question, not the character. I personally don't agree with some of Sel's arguments, so does that mean I have to hate Surik or Ti? Nah, I still love'em.
Originally posted by Ziggystardust
That image gives me a strange feeling of Deja Vu for some reason...
Originally posted by MythLordThat image gives me a strange feeling of Deja Vu for some reason... [/B]
Yes, I was that guy debating you here click me.